External Content x.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.sad stuff
A bunch of millionairs fighting over money. wo could have thought the court wants their share. 
Brave Girls are a very iffy case. I'm not super familiar with them or their circumstances, but if there weren't any original members left by their 10th anniversary, I'm not sure that should count. I would probably be hesitant to count any group that's lost most of its original members, but there should be at least one left. Otherwise it might as well be a different group altogether.
Mamamoo... ehh. The thing is, a lot of groups these days don't officially disband, but in reality that's what they're doing once they leave their company and go inactive for long periods, until it's time for a reunion. They're likely one of those cases at this point. So I think whether or not they should be penalized for not making it to ten years before this happened is highly debatable, but at the very least, I would put an asterisk next to them. If they actually promoted for their 10th anniversary I would take a more lenient stance, but they didn't.
Kara & EXID were inactive long enough that they could be considered effectively disbanded. Same goes for groups like T-ara and 2NE1. It's nice that they got back together, but I wouldn't count them.
Even without the first line up Brave Girls are about to enter the 10 year club soon. The second Line up debuted in 16th february 2016. They celebrated their 9th anniversery some month ago. So they will have their 10th in early 2026.
...BeThief has literally admitted to stealing the document without permission. I highly recommend you to go do your homework and review all the factually confirmed events that have transpired since the announcement of the audit a year ago.
First, Belift said that they didn't use NJZ as a base for their concept design with ILLIT, then they recanted and said that "of course every group was somewhat inspired by a group like NJZ" (gaslighting), then they said they never took any planning documents for NewJeans, then once the whistleblower gave a timeline for all their shady activities, they said "we already finished planning out ILLIT's concept by the time we took the planning document". And that's not even accounting for their getting caught lying about the time frame for when they had decided on ILLIT's concept.
I don't really care what random fans on X are saying, because it doesn't absolve BeThief of their culpability in this; those are two separate matters. Treat them as such.
Lol. Even if its like you say. a company steal from another company who are under the same company. How is that even an issue? Why does it bother you so much? Be happy if they like njzs concept so much that they make a cover band.
I dont care about Belift actions. Belift is not here in this thread going at people for their age. acting not better as your comrades on x. if its two separate matters like you say than you can stop going at people because they like a group from that company.
its up to the court to judge the company. maybe wait till the court made their decision about criminal acts. Also i dont really care if you go for the company. Im just saying that its business as usuall and not just something that happen to njz. also your fandom didnt went on the company but other groups. and their fandoms went on your group. thats what i condemn.
we as fans have to care about our behavior. i thought fans cheer for their idol, listen to their music, buy their album. but you guys here play laywer and detective. 
Display MoreTheir company literally stole the planning documents for NJZ, released a video making inaccurate comparisons of choreography between NJZ and groups whose choreo was made AFTER the NJZ choreo they were compared to, called NJZ concept the fantasy of adults, publicly demanded Hanni apologize when THEY were the ones who unnecessarily name dropped ILLIT and dragged them into the controversy with the manager ignoring Hanni, and they were even exposed for using DC Gallery, one of the most incel infested forums in Korea, as a resource for the aforementioned video.
And company stans for months have been gaslighting and accusing Bunnies of being toxic, when EVERYBODY was calling ILLIT NewJeans 2.0 when they debuted (except for me. I actually argued the opposite).
There is no way to discuss this case without also discussing ILLIT. I hope you can start to control your emotions better and realize this isn't about the group itself but the company.
There's no point in us constantly going Group A from Company B.
But Kpop companies say and copy all kind of stuff. When njz debuted they said its the sisters of bts. bunnies didnt complain about that.
YG disbanded 2ne1 to debut bp as 2ne1 but prettier.
Thats no excuse to hate on the idols. Like if they have a choice anyway. they just get told "do this or that concept". Its terrible to see how hybe fandoms act on reddit. but njz fandom on twitter wasnt better.
I took a over 100 degree hot water shower, and horizonshard got me some Lemon Mint cough drops and Coca cola.
i stoped drinking coca cola. its now salvus for me. 
Of course, she had hits, she was pretty big between 2012-2017 or so, but she's not a Kpop Idol, and she's not your typical Korean singer either, people think she's more like an American than Korean. And now she's basically an indie artist.
She's a Legend, just like Sohyang, but they're not mainstream. This is the life of a soloist in Korea.
Most of them have a good 5 year, and they will disappear from the Charts.
the new song is really very american, for a korean.
Ailee never sold much albums but this really sad. 
This thread is for the GIRLS. Show up and show out for the Queens of K-Pop.
I will officially become a Fan tomorrow. 
I haven't been on this site for a while, but am surprised that this topic seems to be monitored and replied to by some people almost 24/7.
Just saying that Kpop is fun and sometimes dramatic, but it shouldn't be all people talk and think about.
im neutral. waiting for the court decision. but its interesting. like a drama. but for free. since its the hybe groups fandoms who pay both sides.
BHS, MHJ, Njz, illit, the companies ceos, manager, employees. They probably all live and fight for their lifes. I wont judge who i dont know. thats the courts job. but its scary to see the fans actions from all sides. what damage, hate and vile it cause.
I thought none of the groups are active anymore. So its unlikely they come back. If they are still active, they will at least perform their old songs in Festivals etc.
Zero. K-Pop has entered the Age of the 14-Year-Old. If your group doesn't have any, you are yesterday's news.
Bbgirls make comebacks and their youngest is more than twice the age of 14. Being yesterdays news doesnt contradict keep making comebacks.
Display Morecould be
contract cases are ambiguous and hard to prove most of the time
On my side I did think they must have a smoking gun waiting to be revealed in court
Its hard to get a contract nullification on the basis on the damages that might incur in the future
yeah they better come with a plot twist for their drama.
if they win they are free.
if they loose. wont this not create a lot more drama? like they made lots of accusations. if they cant proof them. this means lots of people may want to counter sue them for defamation and stuff.
Some people probably have changed their mind too. I guess the court ruling in favour of this manager against mhj and the 3 rulings in favour of ador with the bully may also play a part.
These girls did suffer hate, and I believe companies will act similarly to HYBE if they were in this situation. I should correct myself--I despise the KPOP industry.
I'm sure there are KPOP music/artists that are well taken care of and does music out of love for the craft. Just less likely to find them.
The industry cant force the people. they only make offers. its the people who choose. kim soohyun and seungri still have their fanclubs. many people are simply there for entertainment and not for morals.
I trust in bbgirls. Im fine. I pray for the other poor souls, still searching.
