this is the thread of the month

either i haven't been on here enough or there aren't any outstanding contenders. and i'm here to change that. Ms. SoShiStan *cough* VioletParr *cough* *cough* VioletWinters *cOuGh* VioletPunisherr *COUGH COUGH* FeLiNa *WHEW GOT IT* is jonesing for a custom gif badge. i hold a firm belief that allkill members should be able to commission for 3k+ akorns but that's not a can of worms i'm opening here.

so instead i'm going to open an even more malicious can of worms and make a thread filled with tons of edgy kpop questions that you can choose to debate others on (or just give your own opinion on). you don't have to answer all of them but i have a feeling this should do the trick. i won nov 2021 and i'm back for more. i'm too busy with finals to write a full analysis thread so this'll do for now. don't let me down.... or else....

DISCLAIMER:

Some of the groups I'm asking questions about here I either ult or I'm a big fan of. While I do love seeing different opinions, sometimes you gotta do what you gotta do This is meant to spark discussion, that being said it is not meant to start full on fanwars. If this goes to dumpsterfire I'm gonna remake it without the inflammatory question that caused it to go there. Let's keep it peaceful folks, I can see how this would attract trolls, if it's obvious bait then just react with a facepalm and keep it moving.

GUIDELINES:

1. No fighting, namecalling or callouts

2. Be respectful

QUESTION...? (bonus points if you got that reference, you're automatically hot and cool and funny and smart)

~

~

1. What 4th gen girl group fell off the most and why?

2. What 4th gen boy group fell off the most and why?

3. What 3rd gen girl group fell off the most and why?

4. What 3rd gen boy group fell off the most and why?

5. Most unpopular opinion about a member who got kicked out?

6. Do girl or boy groups lead the 4th gen? (This is an easy one btw)

7. Name some groups you think need new producers or new musical direction asap

8. Name some groups companies have gotten way too complacent with

9. What soloist fell off the most and why?

10. Do you think overperfectionism and too long of a wait kills hype? (eg: Dean)

11. Name some artists who dug their own grave

12. Name some girl groups with a couple of songs that put them on mid tier... and then fell off

13. 2012, 2014, and 2016 were the best years musically in k-pop, prove me wrong or come up with an argument (check wikipedia for releases that occurred those years and your jaw will drop. AOA saves the day!)

14. Name a group from the big four that comes back way too much

15. Name a group from the big four that comes back way too little

16. If you could resurrect one group, what group would it be, and would they be successful?

17. Why do you think Jessica's solo career didn't perform well? (music slapped anyway)

18. Do you agree with JYP's recent musical direction of Itzy and Nmixx, and SM's recent musical direction with Red Velvet (not including solos)?

19. Looking 5 years down the road, do you see Lesserafim or Newjeans being more successful?

20. Group you think will disband in 2023?

21. Fandom that is hanging on for dear life to a hopeless cause?

22. The quality of mid-tier girl groups was better pre 2017 than it was now, argue or agree with proof.

23. Name a member that should be kicked out of a group

24. Name a member that you wish you could bring back to a group

25. Name a soloist that you believe a company mishandled (I'll make this one easy, YG mishandled Lee Hi after giving her the best release ever by locking her up)

26. Why do you think Korean rap (namely Jay Park) has fallen off so hard after peaking in 2016/17?

27. Inactive soloists you miss dearly?

28. Groups that always said they were coming back but never did? (looking at you Orange Caramel)

29. Groups that had amazing Japanese releases and aesthetics? (two right answers here if we're talking 2nd gen girl groups)

30. Eff, Marry, Friend, Kill: SM, YG, HYBE, JYP

31. (BONUS) A song from your faves that you wish you could burn from existence?

boy oh boy i can't wait to wake up to some disssscourse! remember to keep it cute, calm, and classy or else i have to call in my friends to make you go bye bye. it's completely possible to answer a question without throwing shade babes.

- Vi/FeLiNa (yes i'm posting this at 2:40 in the morning, what about it)

Quote from unbannBLACPINK

Display Spoiler

1. What 4th gen girl group fell off the most and why?

ur mom

2. What 4th gen boy group fell off the most and why?

ur dad

3. What 3rd gen girl group fell off the most and why?

ur grandma

4. What 3rd gen boy group fell off the most and why?

ur grandpa

5. Most unpopular opinion about a member who got kicked out?

all except chuu were deserved

6. Do girl or boy groups lead the 4th gen? (This is an easy one btw)

idk all bad

7. Name some groups you think need new producers or new musical direction asap

loona

8. Name some groups companies have gotten way too complacent with

no clue

9. What soloist fell off the most and why?

soloists never took off

10. Do you think overperfectionism and too long of a wait kills hype? (eg: Dean)

depends if your influencer career is popping off or not

11. Name some artists who dug their own grave

bigbang

12. Name some girl groups with a couple of songs that put them on mid tier... and then fell off

momoland

13. 2012, 2014, and 2016 were the best years musically in k-pop, prove me wrong or come up with an argument (check wikipedia for releases your jaw will drop)

anything before 2019 was good

2016 was legendary

14. Name a group from the big four that comes back way too much

blackpink

15. Name a group from the big four that comes back way too little

exo

16. If you could resurrect one group, what group would it be, and would they be successful?

jaden jeong's loona

yes

17. Why do you think Jessica's solo career didn't perform well? (music slapped anyway)

bad music

sm fans

18. Do you agree with JYP's recent musical direction of Itzy and Nmixx, and SM's recent musical direction with Red Velvet (not including solo)?

no

19. Looking 5 years down the road, do you see Lesserafim or Newjeans being more successful?

both fall off when they become adults

20. Group you think will disband in 2023?

loona

21. Fandom that is hanging on for dear life to a hopeless cause?

loona/orbit

22. The quality of mid-tier girl groups was better pre 2017 than it was now, argue or agree with proof.

yes

proof : loona had all their GOATest releases in 2017

23. Name a member that should be kicked out of a group

shuhua from idle

24. Name a member that you wish you could bring back to a group

chuu to loona

25. Name a soloist that you believe a company mishandled (I'll make this one easy, YG mishandled Lee Hi after giving her the best release ever by locking her up)

none

26. Why do you think Korean rap (namely Jay Park) has fallen off so hard after peaking in 2016/17?

never was good

korea blindly follows trends for a short time

27. Inactive soloists you miss dearly?

all bad

28. Groups that always said they were coming back but never did? (looking at you Orange Caramel)

exo

29. Groups that had amazing Japanese releases and aesthetics? (two right answers here if we're talking 2nd gen girl groups)

izone's suki to iwasetai

30. Eff, Marry, Friend, Kill: SM, YG, HYBE, JYP

rather die than marry any of them

31. (BONUS) A song from your faves that you wish you could burn from existence?

none, probably

they have some boring ones but no trash

Display More

glad we can agree on 22. don't speak 20 into existence good lord. i have so many questions what did shuhua do and when did exo say they were coming back but never did

Quote from unbannBLACPINK

20 is written in stone

i have accepted it and its not sad anymore

there's tons of loona songs out there anyway

shuhua did nothing and thats exactly why she dont belong in the group

she never contributes anything

btw i assume this is not a super serious discussion

exo keep saying they are 9 but where ot9?

Display More

i mean i think they'll be apart for some time but come back together. and dayum.

and i believe chanyeol literally just got discharged at the end of september so the mans is resting. they're probs coming back early 2023 or 2nd quarter 2023.

alr i call in the big guns to help

Ves

aclassyteaparty

Violanah

@dummi

YouChanDoThis

@zuzuhhaa

Quote from Ves

I'm a big gun? I'm touched. I'm sorry you missed out on the Black Friday offer - a free custom for any AllKill member who requested it!!

WHAT THE FUCK NO NO NO WAS IT A GIF CUSTOM?!

TAKE A CHANCE ON ME I'LL BUY AKORNS I'LL TRADE MY LIMITEDS I'LL DO ANYTHING PLEEK PLEEK PLEASE.. PLEASE

-> -> -> ->

NO I'M A AKP LEGEND.... PLEASE I'M A AKP LEGENNDDDDD🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️

Quote from Help1

Momoland is also the group I predict will disband in 2023

unfortunately i can see this.

Quote from YouChanDoThis

I’m too sleepy to do this now, I’ll try and do it later, if I remember to.

please do bc now i NEED my custom wandavision gif badge fr fr. like i would be willing to trade some of my limited just for the option

Quote from trollacc

There's so many questions.. if I respond to these it might become the longest post in AKP history

please do (also you don't have to choose all of them)

Quote from YouChanDoThis

Well, my custom badge hasn’t been made yet. If it hasn’t been started, is it possible to give it to you?

though i appreciate the offer i would feel bad

OMG PAGE TWO GUYS MAKING PROGRESS #TWICE

Quote from YouChanDoThis

Don’t feel bad! Consider it an early Christmas present.

still it's yours i'd feel like a thieving thief

Quote from YouChanDoThis

You aren’t! How could you be? I’m offering, so it’s not stealing.

i'll think about it. i wanna try this first. i posted late in the night so we'll see what type of interaction this gets during the day

Quote from YouChanDoThis

Sounds good to me. Also, sorry for derailing this so much.

ur fine icon i appreciate it sm

Quote from Ves

I support this!

rolling on the floor screaming crying