Who's the least talented member of your favorite groups?
-
None, my faves are all the epitome of talent
-
None, my faves are all the epitome of talent
Mine too
-
i love the provocative thread title
(like actually) -
-
Does not exist, everyone in A.C.E is great
-
You should answer first so ppl reply
-
snsd - yoona
-
-
-
-
NewJeans - Minji
-
She is my fave in NewJeans
actually I like NewJeans music more than the members and then I like Minji more than the members... -
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Are we talking about overall talent, right? That's why CL.
-
-
Also, just for fun, to everyone see, I'm not biased, I will rate Mamamoo as well.
Wheein, Solar, Moonbyul, Hwasa.
Hwasa is stronger as a vocalist, but she's not the best dancer, and she hardly does rap anymore, even tho she's great.
I will save this comment for the rest of my life, so I can show it to clueless people, who think I'm obsessed and biased.🤣
-
Display More
Also, just for fun, to everyone see, I'm not biased, I will rate Mamamoo as well.
Wheein, Solar, Moonbyul, Hwasa.
Hwasa is stronger as a vocalist, but she's not the best dancer, and she hardly does rap anymore, even tho she's great.
I will save this comment for the rest of my life, so I can show it to clueless people, who think I'm obsessed and biased.🤣
Hand in your moobong.
-
cuz there's no least talented members in it they are all completing each other weakness
giselle is a rapper and singer and the only member who's able to write and produce in aespa
while karina is a rapper and dancer but who don't write rap and don't produce. but she's a better dancer than giselle
nigning and winter are both singer and dancer but winter can't write or compose' only ningning can
aespa is a really well balance group so there's no least talented member
but i'm waiting for your least talented members or nj and mamamoo
-
-
-
Display More
cuz there's no least talented members in it they are all completing each other weakness
giselle is a rapper and singer and the only member who's able to write and produce in aespa
while karina is a rapper and dancer but who don't write rap and don't produce. but she's a better dancer than giselle
nigning and winter are both singer and dancer but winter can't write or compose' only ningning can
aespa is a really well balance group so there's no least talented member
but i'm waiting for your least talented members or nj and mamamoo
I mean, technically you're right, but what you just said, proves that there are weaknesses in Aespa, because not all of them can sing, dance or rap in the same level. So you can do a rating already. They are well-balanced, but that doesn't mean we can't do rating.
Like: Winter, Karina, Ning, Giselle.
There isn't much difference, but still, this is my ranking.
-
-
JUST DO IT!
-
-
Yama stop being a pussy and give us your ranking
-
Yama stop being a pussy and give us your ranking
-
-
Minji and Moonbyul, that's my bet.
-
-
-
Wheein and Haerin then!
-
Haerin for New Jeans.
Shuhua for Gidle. (i am close to putting Idle in the "no weak links" category though, Shuhua really rising due to her variety show charms.
Anyone not named Karina tbh for Aespa.
Eunchae for LSRFM.
Dahyun for Twice.
Blackpink and OMG are the only groups that dont have a "least" talented member since all the members have similar levels of talent (blackpink) or there are no weak links (OMG).
-
The multiple mentions of Yoona in the thread single handedly triggered me out of a month long hiatus.
Lol.
How are we defining "talent" here?
It seems to me the way "talented" is often employed in these sorts of arguments is either a very narrow framing that limits it solely to unabashed vocal prowess, or alternatively a weight on the scales activist euphemism for a certain type of diva stage persona.
Yoona is neither. She is not a stand out vocal. And she is not a CL style diva archetype that so many attribute multitudes of claimed depth to.
But... Yoona shines.....
She serves as an archetypal example of the pinnacle of what traditional idols as multi dimensional entertainment and role model figures can be.
Yoona sings beautifully within her range and on modest fare, with heart moving results, just see her string of releases in Mandarin like Red Bean or her When the Wind Blows.
Her dancing is strong and a highlight of SNSD's performance line. See nearly their History of performance releases and stages.
Yoona is the quintessential kpop girl group center, anchoring the visual and performance vibe of Kpop's most storied girl group in SNSD.
Beyond mere performance talent, she excels at so many other touchstones of the multi dimensional idol as jack of all trades archetype that seem to be lost in these kinds of discussions.
She acts. Slowly building her talent from very modest ability to one that can hold her own in high profile dramas and movies, going on to a string of extremely successful movies like EXIT and dramas like King The Land. She's no Oscar winner, but I find she is perfectly suited for breezy romantic comedy and lighter fare. She shines in these roles.
She hosts. Leveraging her immense charm and likeable friendly personality to host countless awards and shows and other venues.
She models. Her radiant and deer like youthful beauty has allowed her to ascend to the heights of CF and product representation, making her one of Kpop's most successful product models.
Also, she possesses a rare quality of genuine genuine kindness and humility. A warmth of character that is out of style in today's edgy culture. Countless testimonials from understaff and anyone who has had the privilege of meeting or knowing her attest to her unassailable goodness. This may seem like "not a talent" but when combined with her immense work ethic and motivation in her career and endeavors, it combines to make her one of the very best examples of an idol as role model. She is someone you can look up to, admire, try to emulate and be more like.
In my opinion her multi faceted career, personal achievements, role as performer and singer, and as all around entertainment figure and role model, make her far from "least talented".
It's insulting in my eyes for her to be characterized as so.
In terms of what being an idol traditionally meant. Yoona is a rare find.
-
You first
-
Participate now!
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!
