Tomboy is a massive hit
My bag is a mid tier hit, pretty good actually
World tour
Solid album sales
Can we already claim that G-idle is the top 4th gen group?
-
Yes, I like (G)I-DLE.
-
-
Tomboy is a massive hit
My bag is a mid tier hit, pretty good actually
World tour
Solid album sales
Fake Idle fans, always setting them up.
Idle will be Idle, and go their own path. Stop using them for silly "best of x, y,x" games.
-
Everytime a group have a comeback that group becomes the new 4th gen leader
-
-
Lol nope
-
-
-
this is such a set-up.
-
-
i love gidle but saying that is a stretch lol. i feel like they need to put out more and people need to consistently see how they do. they were thrown off because of the scandal, and def were becoming 4th gen "leaders" before that, but things have really changed since then. regardless, the girls are talented and deserve love.
-
They deserve to be in the conversation, that is for sure.
-
I don't even think we can get people to agree that they're a 4th gen group (which they are) so I doubt people will agree on this.
They should at least be up there though. Debut song was a hit, OMG and Lion were hits, Hwaa was huge before the Soojin scandal and now Tomboy is a big hit.
They're at least a contender lol
-
-
yes they are
-
Tomboy is a massive hit
My bag is a mid tier hit, pretty good actually
World tour
Solid album sales
They don’t have solid album sales.
-
Everytime a group have a comeback that group becomes the new 4th gen leader
Anticipate Fansamy and the Frogs be 4th gen leaders next week
-
They don’t have solid album sales.
I possess many of their albums, and they're undoubtedly solid.
-
-
I possess many of their albums, and they're undoubtedly solid.
Idea of liquid album seems interesting
-
-
-
-
-
-
I think they're the moment, the biggest GG sweeping Korea right now. They've already overtaken BB, RV, Ive, and all the dusty balladeers and musty trottists on the charts.
External Content www.youtube.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy. -
-
I possess many of their albums, and they're undoubtedly solid.
They’re solid but not for a “top”group
-
-
-
200k are solid... in 2018
-
-
-
I think they're the moment, the biggest GG sweeping Korea right now. They've already overtaken BB, RV, Ive, and all the dusty balladeers and musty trottists on the charts.
External Content www.youtube.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.this comment made me laugh
-
They’re solid but not for a “top”group
They're definitely solid, I can grab them with my fingers.
-
They're definitely solid, I can grab them with my fingers.
I didn’t understand the joke lol
But now I get it
-
To help aid in your determination, here is the complete ranking of Gaon+Oricon physical sales for Fourth Generation girl groups (data compiled by halfdavid on Twitter):
IVE – 907,179
(G)I-dle – 825,919
StayC – 602,810
Aespa – 602,214
Loona – 503,802
NMIXX – 476,772
Fromis_9 – 424,587
Kep1er – 389,542
Everglow – 235,581
Weeekly – 220,204
Billlie – 112,340
Purple Kiss – 110,049
Rocket Punch – 103,081
Cherry Bullet – 68,713
Lightsum – 41,143
GWSN – 40,201
Nature – 37,975
UNI.T – 25,741
Woo!ah! – 24,228
Tri.be – 23,032
Loona yyxy – 21,079
Secret Number – 19,156
DreamNote – 12,769
ILY:1 – 11,133
Cignature – 10,960
Saturday – 7,870
Bvndit – 7,515
bugAboo – 6,481
Pixy – 6,250
Lunarsolar – 4,360
Honey Popcorn – 3,182
Purplebeck – 3,076
Pink Fantasy – 1,836
XUM – 1,834
Redsquare – 1,731
3YE – 1,500
Rolling Quartz – 1,476
WeGirls – 1,047
Ariaz – 1,027
Fanatics Flavor – 1,020
G-reyish – 966
Blackswan – 671
Botopass – 620
NeonPunch – 582
Girlkind XJR – 541
-
200k is not even remotely solid and automatically removes them from any conversation about being a top group.
The only time album sales will take back seat for a discussion about being a top group is if they’re able to tour bigger than all others without the album sales which isn’t really relevant here.
-
In order to tour, you need to have an actual song repertoire, which automatically rules out most of the other groups you could come up with for the title of "top 4th gen group".
-
Display More
To help aid in your determination, here is the complete ranking of Gaon+Oricon physical sales for Fourth Generation girl groups (data compiled by halfdavid on Twitter):
IVE – 907,179
(G)I-dle – 825,919
StayC – 602,810
Aespa – 602,214
Loona – 503,802
NMIXX – 476,772
Fromis_9 – 424,587
Kep1er – 389,542
Everglow – 235,581
Weeekly – 220,204
Billlie – 112,340
Purple Kiss – 110,049
Rocket Punch – 103,081
Cherry Bullet – 68,713
Lightsum – 41,143
GWSN – 40,201
Nature – 37,975
UNI.T – 25,741
Woo!ah! – 24,228
Tri.be – 23,032
Loona yyxy – 21,079
Secret Number – 19,156
DreamNote – 12,769
ILY:1 – 11,133
Cignature – 10,960
Saturday – 7,870
Bvndit – 7,515
bugAboo – 6,481
Pixy – 6,250
Lunarsolar – 4,360
Honey Popcorn – 3,182
Purplebeck – 3,076
Pink Fantasy – 1,836
XUM – 1,834
Redsquare – 1,731
3YE – 1,500
Rolling Quartz – 1,476
WeGirls – 1,047
Ariaz – 1,027
Fanatics Flavor – 1,020
G-reyish – 966
Blackswan – 671
Botopass – 620
NeonPunch – 582
Girlkind XJR – 541
Izone is literally the third greatest GG of alltime. Only BP and Twice can claim to be above them.
-
-
Display More
If we're talking about physical sales, don't forget that both Girls' Generation and Kara have higher totals as well:
Twice – 11,503,291
Girls' Generation – 5,356,042
Kara – 3,717,781
Blackpink – 3,112,890
After about 1241 years of activity though. Izone did it in two years. If they had a full run, they coulda hit 10 million easily.
-
Participate now!
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!
