Alright its def sajaegi…. They did not outsell itzy like… no
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
If JYPE did sajaegi then Xdinary Heroes would be at least a certified double platinum album seller, they're not even a platinum certified album seller. It doesn't matter if they are a Band either because people are accusing JYPE of sajaegi so it doesn't matter what type of Idol or Artist they are.
The fact is, JYPE are too cheap to illegally buy albums and JYPark is against it to the point that he invited Auditors to check the Company a few years back.
NMIXX debut in 2023 meaning thier fan numbers will only increase dramatically and they have drawn attention from the Kpop Community for both positive and negative reviews. The worst thing for an Artist isn't flopping, it's when the Kpop Community are indifferent to an Artist's career
Whereas Itzy are a 4 year old group that is maintaining their fan numbers while improving at a slower rate. There are still people attacking them, just like there is for TWICE and BP which keeps them all relevant but the best they can all do is to maintain thier current levels of Sales.
-
-
-
-
Display More
If JYPE did sajaegi then Xdinary Heroes would be at least a certified double platinum album seller, they're not even a platinum certified album seller. It doesn't matter if they are a Band either because people are accusing JYPE of sajaegi so it doesn't matter what type of Idol or Artist they are.
The fact is, JYPE are too cheap to illegally buy albums and JYPark is against it to the point that he invited Auditors to check the Company a few years back.
NMIXX debut in 2023 meaning thier fan numbers will only increase dramatically and they have drawn attention from the Kpop Community for both positive and negative reviews. The worst thing for an Artist isn't flopping, it's when the Kpop Community are indifferent to an Artist's career
Whereas Itzy are a 4 year old group that is maintaining their fan numbers while improving at a slower rate. There are still people attacking them, just like there is for TWICE and BP which keeps them all relevant but the best they can all do is to maintain thier current levels of Sales.
Why would they spend that money doing Sajaegi on Xdinary Heroes (no offense)? Sajaegi is something you would only do sparingly as to not get caught, and only if the group absolutely needs the push. The group being their rookies or front runners, not groups like Xdinary Heroes where they hardly show interest in promoting as it is.
-
Why would they spend that money doing Sajaegi on Xdinary Heroes (no offense)? Sajaegi is something you would only do sparingly as to not get caught, and only if the group absolutely needs the push. The group being their rookies or front runners, not groups like Xdinary Heroes where they hardly show interest in promoting as it is.
Because a company that does sajaegi won't stop at just doing it once AND Idol Boy Groups have historically had higher Album Sales so doing it for XDinary Heroes wouldn't look out of place so it could be hidden
But accusing a company of doing sajaegi that had 2 GGs that were certified million album sellers before their debut is grasping for straws. TWICE had it's first certified million album in 2022, the same year Itzy had 2.
Both groups have since maintained their Album Sales while TWICE rose sharply with their last comeback due to Digipaks.
Additionally NMIXX debut in 2023, in a year with NJs and Le SSerafim that had zero history of big selling GGs as they were both their first under HYBE (Gfriend weren't under HYBE). Espcially NJ's whom beat TWICE and BP's debut career Album Sales in a month on the Circle Charts which are mainly Retail Pre-Orders, that is, purchases before they released their debut song.
BUT neither ADOR or HYBE did sajaegi because there were 6 Certified Million Albums released by GG's in 2022 so there was a huge upward trend by 2023
-
Display More
Because a company that does sajaegi won't stop at just doing it once AND Idol Boy Groups have historically had higher Album Sales so doing it for XDinary Heroes wouldn't look out of place so it could be hidden
But accusing a company of doing sajaegi that had 2 GGs that were certified million album sellers before their debut is grasping for straws. TWICE had it's first certified million album in 2022, the same year Itzy had 2.
Both groups have since maintained their Album Sales while TWICE rose sharply with their last comeback due to Digipaks.
Additionally NMIXX debut in 2023, in a year with NJs and Le SSerafim that had zero history of big selling GGs as they were both their first under HYBE (Gfriend weren't under HYBE). Espcially NJ's whom beat TWICE and BP's debut career Album Sales in a month on the Circle Charts which are mainly Retail Pre-Orders, that is, purchases before they released their debut song.
BUT neither ADOR or HYBE did sajaegi because there were 6 Certified Million Albums released by GG's in 2022 so there was a huge upward trend by 2023
-
If JYPE did sajaegi then Xdinary Heroes would be at least a certified double platinum album seller, they're not even a platinum certified album seller.
STOP RUBBING IT INTO MY FAVES FACE
-
-
They are nice ladies, let them sell
-
-
It definetly is
-
-
-
-
-
Maybe we're just totally out of touch and NMIXX is actually huge in Korea?
Huge with this charting?
nopeExternal Content twitter.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy. -
Huge with this charting?
nopeExternal Content twitter.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.I was trying to give them the benefit of the doubt but yea...
-
The problem is that this just makes no logical sense. JYPE as a company isnt big enough to hide, say, 500k albums bought, that's 6 million in dollars that have to be accounted for in one quarter, that's probably the entire profit of the company in one quaarter.
JYP as a person COULD be doing this, 6M is probably something he can afford to lose, but boy oh boy, that would mean he has set up a vast network of buyers willing to buy hundreds of albums each. Possible, but just very unlikely.
Album sajaegi is dumb cause no one cares about this. Folks want to see songs charting high, that gets GP talking. GP dont give a rip about Hanteo sales, only Kpop groupies do. If i'm gonna be spending 6M or more on sajaegi i would much rather use that huge pile of dough for something that can truly get my group more popularity,.
-
-
Album sales have nothing to do with popularity these days.
All you need is rich fans.
But why would JYPE do sajaegi for NMIXX and not ITZY if they were going to do sajaegi? That makes no sense. Why wouldn't they also do sajaegi for Twice, ITZY, NiziU, and Xdinary Heroes. Like...
Ya'll sound dumb.
It would also make them look crazy when NMIXX can't actually tour to support those numbers, and you think that would fly with their investors? NMIXX numbers are definitely...something, but I'm more inclined to believe it's an outside force rather than JYPE.
-
I agree this part makes no sense either. Like why? And then what? They have just some enormously wealthy fans? Richer by far than other groups? NGL - every explanation for this just seems a bit sketch.
-
-
Yeah, I don't know.
But their numbers have been huge since even last comeback. Like BlackpinkHouse mentioned, it would be weird for JYPE as a company to throw away millions of dollars for sajaegi on these two comebacks. And now, they have to maintain those numbers going forward, or it would be all for nothing. So, how much money would JYPE lose overall pushing NMIXX as a physical group if there was actually nothing supporting those numbers? They would lose much more than they would gain.
And, honestly, I wouldn't say NMIXX's fans are richer. I think the numbers for a lot of 4th gen groups are kind of sketch. But, it's not like we as the audience will ever find out. Hanteo and Circle are not going to release a holistic break down of where these sales are coming from. According to Hanteo and Circle, JYPE is a public company that cannot commit sajaegi due to regulations, and despite numerous people bringing this up about NMIXX in Korea, JYPE has yet to be investigated by Hanteo or Circle. Which means, that if JYPE were getting away with blatant sajaegi like this, it's being supported by said companies.
But, then again, if they are enabling JYPE, they have to be enabling everyone else too.
-
-
-
-
Huge with this charting?
nopeExternal Content twitter.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.Maybe their fans are just sleepers
-
-
-
-
-
Oh, i'm sure it's good and groundbreaking but it just never really bloomed for me. Great British Bakeoff, however, THAT'S cinema
-
Why would it not make sense ?
Itzy and Twice doesn't need to have sajaegi for their album because they can easily surf on their past success and have build a strong enough fanbase thanks to all their previous hit to make them 1M seller
Xdinary heroes is a band, band group never sale as much than BG or GG even a Band as big than Ftisland or Cnblue never had big sales so it would have look too suspicious if xdinary heroes who doesn't have a very friendly music and are a band sales like a Bg
-
Honestly i can't find any explanation
They aren't doing well in china or in japan , neither internationally if you look at their spotify stream or youtube view ( they couldn't enter youtube chart with 4M view in the week)
Their numbers on instagram and twitter in term of engagements is low compare to other 1M seller GG
They struggle to fill their showcase tour
it just make no sense at all that Nmixx is selling like this while doing so poorly everywhere else
-
Participate now!
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!
