I can't think of any other 4th gen GG who had 2 members at the same time have a big success for their visual since debut, there's usually only one member standing out as the visual for people and koreans and gets a lot or praise as the visual of the group and overshadow the other members but Aespa is one of this rare case where 2 members stand out as the visual and gets lot of praise from everybody.
SM really hit the jackpot when they decided to put both of them in the same group
StayC are about the prettiest GG I've seen,I'm surprised the GP hasn't birthed an it girl out of any of them yet.
i didn't say it means that they aren't pretty
but usually one members of the other GG get all the praise and attention for their visual
while meanwhile Aespa seems to be one of the only GG recently where 2 members got a huge support and attention for their visuals which is pretty unusual in kpop
But yeah I agree Karina & Winter are stunning, both in different ways too. Karina has more chic, video game character-like visuals while Winter has more cute, girl-next-door, puppy-like visuals.
It reminds me of the contrast between Krystal & Sulli's visuals
The GP seems to like them alot. They're probably the most popular 4th gen female idols in Korea after Wonyoung.
If SM plays their cards right they could be the second coming of Yoona & Taeyeon.
Not when the entirety of STAYC exists
like i said , they are all pretty
but people never hype the visual ofthe other members like they do with Yoon, and none of the other members got a huge attention for their visual like Yoon, and she's also the only one mention when there's subject about the strongest visual of 4th gen
J, sieun and isa were starting to get some attention at some point but it quickly died
i remember J was even chose as the face of a cosmetic brand during their debut era
Not being popular doesn't mean there isn't a visual line 
Not being popular doesn't mean there isn't a visual line
I’m confused about this logic too
like i said , they are all pretty
but people never hype the visual ofthe other members like they do with Yoon, and none of the other members got a huge attention for their visual like Yoon, and she's also the only one mention when there's subject about the strongest visual of 4th gen
J, sieun and isa were starting to get some attention at some point but it quickly died
i remember J was even chose as the face of a cosmetic brand during their debut era
I see people hyping up the visuals of multiple members all the time.
Xiaoting, Chaehyun
That's just to name a few.
I really think that saying a group doesn't have a "visual line" because the mainstream hasn't super-hyped them is putting too strict of a definition on that term.
Izone had like six visuals worshipped by Koreans. Here are the three that didnt even make the official visual line but are still considered bigtime visuals by Koreans.
Display MoreI see people hyping up the visuals of multiple members all the time.
Xiaoting, Chaehyun
That's just to name a few.
I really think that saying a group doesn't have a "visual line" because the mainstream hasn't super-hyped them is putting too strict of a definition on that term.
Well if you like at korea it's not really the case
most of the people you mention are only hype by international fans and never reach the potential to be it girls, so aren't really hype
Yeji and Ryujin are never part of the discussion about top 4th gen GG visual besides on International forum where only yeji get mention a lot, meanwhile Yuna is the only member who comes often on international forum and korean discussion
Miyeon is the only one getting hype for her visual, there's like 3-4 people hyping yuqi and shuhua visual and even this they are never mention in 4th gen GG visual
same for Kep1er they only get hype internationally but their visual doesn't seem to be acknowledge by a lot of people in korea, and even internationally chaehyun doesn't get lot of hype , i remember during GP999 people were saying how they don't understand why koreans are voting for her because she's not that pretty
Same for Aisha, only Yiren gets mention a lot next to other 4th gen GG top visual
and same for NMIXX, 90% of subject about NMIXX visual are mentionning Sullyoon, and she's the only one who's already mention next to the other 4th gen idols. Jinni is mostly hype by international fans, but she doesn't seem to stand out in Korea in contrary of sullyoon
Display More
Izone had like six visuals worshipped by Koreans. Here are the three that didnt even make the official visual line but are still considered bigtime visuals by Koreans.
well i say " IS" not " was"
Izone is no longer active that's why i didn't count them, i even made a line about how i think the only GG who come in my mind was Izone
but then erase it because i thought that they were no longer active so it was not needed
imo Karina is more popular for being a visual and Winter for her “charisma” I don’t think she’s hyped as much as Karina when it comes to visual.
I disagree there's tons of subject on koreans community gettings +100K views talking about which hairstyle winter is the prettiest, or which makeup winter look the best with , and praising her visual
she's getting a lot of attention for her pure and innocent visual in korea, and looking at koreans reactings to aespa MV, i see a lot of boys especially saying how they fell in love with Winter visual
and i think they are neck to neck because i think they have two very distinctive type of visual
Karina is the type of cold beauty, classy that SM likes to push since Krystal with Irene etc...
while Winter is more the cute, charming , innocent, warm visual that GP also like and is closer to the aura what Yoona have, in comparison of other SM visuals
Display MoreWell if you like at korea it's not really the case
most of the people you mention are only hype by international fans and never reach the potential to be it girls, so aren't really hype
Yeji and Ryujin are never part of the discussion about top 4th gen GG visual besides on International forum where only yeji get mention a lot, meanwhile Yuna is the only member who comes often on international forum and korean discussion
Miyeon is the only one getting hype for her visual, there's like 3-4 people hyping yuqi and shuhua visual and even this they are never mention in 4th gen GG visual
same for Kep1er they only get hype internationally but their visual doesn't seem to be acknowledge by a lot of people in korea, and even internationally chaehyun doesn't get lot of hype , i remember during GP999 people were saying how they don't understand why koreans are voting for her because she's not that pretty
Same for Aisha, only Yiren gets mention a lot next to other 4th gen GG top visual
and same for NMIXX, 90% of subject about NMIXX visual are mentionning Sullyoon, and she's the only one who's already mention next to the other 4th gen idols. Jinni is mostly hype by international fans, but she doesn't seem to stand out in Korea in contrary of sullyoon
They're part of my discussions and many others I see.
I agree with what was said above. This is putting way too much emphasis on the opinions of others, on the opinions of the masses.
In the end, it's probably more about popularity than it is about actual looks or charisma.
I'd like to ask though, what is the point behind your initial question? Are you trying to prove that Aespa is somehow better than the other groups? Are you looking for validation that Aespa members are more popular? Are prettier?
It just seems to me that a better way to approach this topic would be acknowledging that they are hyped for their visuals (which I am not denying), instead of trying to exclude other groups from that as well.
At first you didn’t say: in korea
Well in this case you have struggle to read because i clearly mention Koreans in my OP
and no, not only in Korea, because Winter and Karina seems to have also a pretty big hype for their visual internationally. they are with people like Yuna, Wonyoung etc.... the only visuals who are always part of the discussion about 4th gen GG whatever it is in korea or internationally
In comparison of some visuals that some of you mention who only get some hype mostly internationally and aren't that much hype in korea or the contrary.
Display MoreWell if you like at korea it's not really the case
most of the people you mention are only hype by international fans and never reach the potential to be it girls, so aren't really hype
Yeji and Ryujin are never part of the discussion about top 4th gen GG visual besides on International forum where only yeji get mention a lot, meanwhile Yuna is the only member who comes often on international forum and korean discussion
Miyeon is the only one getting hype for her visual, there's like 3-4 people hyping yuqi and shuhua visual and even this they are never mention in 4th gen GG visual
same for Kep1er they only get hype internationally but their visual doesn't seem to be acknowledge by a lot of people in korea, and even internationally chaehyun doesn't get lot of hype , i remember during GP999 people were saying how they don't understand why koreans are voting for her because she's not that pretty
Same for Aisha, only Yiren gets mention a lot next to other 4th gen GG top visual
and same for NMIXX, 90% of subject about NMIXX visual are mentionning Sullyoon, and she's the only one who's already mention next to the other 4th gen idols. Jinni is mostly hype by international fans, but she doesn't seem to stand out in Korea in contrary of sullyoon
I agree in principle, i think international fans are too liberal with the term "true visual". There are plenty of cute idols but only a select few reach the highest tier reserved in the past for idols like Tzuyu and Irene. Except for Izone, which had like half the group that could be counted.
Idle - Miyeon
Itzy - Yuna
Everglow - Yiren
Kepler - no one
Nmixx - no one
I'm not familiar with the smaller groups like Purple Kiss, Secret Number, Wooah, Weeekly, Pixy, etc but i dont remember any news about Koreans making any of the girls from these groups going viral for their visuals.
Display MoreI agree in principle, i think international fans are too liberal with the term "true visual". There are plenty of cute idols but only a select few reach the highest tier reserved in the past for idols like Tzuyu and Irene. Except for Izone, which had like half the group that could be counted.
Idle - Miyeon
Kepler - no one
Nmixx - no one
At least something understand, like half of the answer in this thread doesn't even understand the difference between their own taste, and some visuals who are truly consider as top visual by people
But i have to disagree for some name
StayC have Yoon who appear a lot in discussion about 4th gen top GG visual since predebut
Kep1er mostly have fans internationally, so it's mostly int fans who hype the members like xiaoting
and Nmixx have Sullyoon who's already getting a tons of people talking about her being part of the top visuals of 4th gen
and for IVE i think it's difficult because i don't think Yujin is even 20% as hype than Wonyoung for her visual so i don't really think they are in a Winter/Karina situation where they get a fair amount of hype
but I think IVE might be in the Aespa type of situation in the future considering how Leeseo hype gets
because she gets a fair amount of attention during their debut week, but she doesn't come close to Wonyoung hype yet, but i think based on how they'll promote and style her.
She have better chance to get a fair amount of hype for her visual in comparison with Yujin
I'm not familiar with the smaller groups like Purple Kiss, Secret Number, Wooah, Weeekly, Pixy, etc but i dont remember any news about Koreans making any of the girls from these groups going viral for their visuals.
i think one of the member of Wooah did get some discussion about her visual , i think her member was Nana
but even if she got a little attention in korea, she never got any hype internationally
and even in korea she was never part of the top visual discussion
I can't think of any other 4th gen GG who had 2 members at the same time have a big success for their visual since debut, there's usually only one member standing out as the visual for people and koreans and gets a lot or praise as the visual of the group and overshadow the other members but Aespa is one of this rare case where 2 members stand out as the visual and gets lot of praise from everybody.
SM really hit the jackpot when they decided to put both of them in the same group
lmao thanks dr kim
Display MoreAt least something understand, like half of the answer in this thread doesn't even understand the difference between their own taste, and some visuals who are truly consider as top visual by people
But i have to disagree for some name
StayC have Yoon who appear a lot in discussion about 4th gen top GG visual since predebut
Kep1er mostly have fans internationally, so it's mostly int fans who hype the members like xiaoting
and Nmixx have Sullyoon who's already getting a tons of people talking about her being part of the top visuals of 4th gen
and for IVE i think it's difficult because i don't think Yujin is even 20% as hype than Wonyoung for her visual so i don't really think they are in a Winter/Karina situation where they get a fair amount of hype
but I think IVE might be in the Aespa type of situation in the future considering how Leeseo hype gets
because she gets a fair amount of attention during their debut week, but she doesn't come close to Wonyoung hype yet, but i think based on how they'll promote and style her.
She have better chance to get a fair amount of hype for her visual in comparison with Yujin
Yujin might not be as hyped as WY, but she’s trending on Pann and theqoo quite often for her visuals
She’s literally trending right now lol
External Content
twitter.com
Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.
Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
It’s just not a well known fact to internationals because they don’t acknowledge her in general, for some reason
I think Aespa is currently the only group where there's 2 members that are insanely popular with Koreans and where their visuals get praised abundantly.
Usually it's only 1 group member that becomes a top trending popular girl and visual icon, and the others lag behind.
I'd mention BP, where both Jennie and Jisoo are very popular and praised for their visuals by Koreans, but they're a 3rd gen group.
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!
