Is classy the proof that kpop fan don't care about music ???

I liked Shut down, but not but not hooked for the other songs

No

Shut Down was very disappointing to me, classy was just okay and their latest song is good but very age inappropriate for half of the group.

I mean aespa blew up with that weird noise of a song ofcourse kpop fans don't care about music

their music is not good so idg

Quote from thebadguy

I mean aespa blew up with that weird noise of a song ofcourse kpop fans don't care about music

gidle is a better example of kpop fans not caring about music

Quote from Aeicy

gidle is a better example of kpop fans not caring about music

bad music is still music

I dont know about the others but Classy is a literal SOTY contender so i agree at least in part.

I don’t like their music

Quote from SooYoung

did u listen tick tick boom ?

Yes, but i prefer "zealous" from this EP

Quote from pwswan

You misspelled Blackpink.

well bp could be good if any of them could sing

I thought you were gonna say their relative success is proof fans are only supporting groups cause of a survival show even if their music is not particularly better than other gg of the time

I already liked shut down. I finally listened to Class:y - Classy because I've heard it mentioned 3 times (now 4) in the last week alone on AKP as a best song or top song, I like it too and I can see why people say its top 10 or soty.

But tick tick boom has nothing redeeming for me.

*most of kpop fans

Quote from SooYoung

Because they are so underrated among Koreans and international fans , and their discography have been preetty much flawless so i don't understand why people don't talk more about them

External Content www.youtube.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

External Content www.youtube.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

External Content www.youtube.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

External Content www.youtube.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

Display More

I mean yes, in this case it's not about the music.

Class:y have some great music, but I can't in good conscience support a group with members that young. Plenty of other people also expressed distaste at the Grade 1 of My Teenage Girls' ages.

So yeah, you are right, in a way.

Quote from Aeicy

gidle is a better example of kpop fans not caring about music

Bold stance for for someone who's a fan of the 5th best NCT group, a group so terrible that pressing play on an NCT 127 song was recently ruled as a crime against humanity by the UN general assembly.

isn't that well known already, music only matter when 2 similar popular groups releasing a song in the same time, otherwise people, both kfans and ifans only care about popularity so if you are lucky to get hype and popularity, everything is gonna sell

they are lack luster I'm afraid

I'm sorry your point is getting derailed by people using it to take potshots at other groups.

I think Class:y's sound is not distinctive enough, perhaps?

They sound - to a casual fan - like a number of mid-tier to nugu gg. I think they are pretty solid for a nugu but if you put them in a room with Nature and Lightsum, I wouldn't be able to tell the difference, tbh. I don't hear a song and go "oh that's Class:y!"

Quote from Disevidence

Bold stance for for someone who's a fan of the 5th best NCT group, a group so terrible that pressing play on an NCT 127 song was recently ruled as a crime against humanity by the UN general assembly.

well nct 127 is for intellectuals only

Quote from SunnySun

isn't that well known already, music only matter when 2 similar popular groups releasing a song in the same time, otherwise people, both kfans and ifans only care about popularity so if you are lucky to get hype and popularity, everything is gonna sell

Do you think music matters when 5 middle bgs or ggs are coming back at the same time? I think it still makes a difference although the amount of people who know the group is more important

Quote from Help1

Do you think music matters when 5 middle bgs or ggs are coming back at the same time? I think it still makes a difference although the amount of people who know the group is more important

which is why i said that it matter when 2 groups with similar popularity comeback at the same time, if they have similar popularity, the amount of people which know the group is also similar, this is when music counts, the song which hit the casuals the most, is gonna chart higher

Quote from SunnySun

which is why i said that it matter when 2 groups with similar popularity comeback at the same time, if they have similar popularity, the amount of people which know the group is also similar, this is when music counts, the song which hit the casuals the most, is gonna chart higher

Oh ok I thought you meant 2 big 4 groups originally

Even among mid tier groups there are a lot that are in the higher or lower echleons, for example just recently there's TripleS, Alice, Nature, Class:y, I feel like only Alice and Nature are really in competition, TripleS is probably above them and Class:y is above TripleS

Quote from Help1

Oh ok I thought you meant 2 big 4 groups originally

Even among mid tier groups there are a lot that are in the higher or lower echleons, for example just recently there's TripleS, Alice, Nature, Class:y, I feel like only Alice and Nature are really in competition, TripleS is probably above them and Class:y is above TripleS

none of this are mid tier groups, what i would count as mid tier groups is WJSN, Loona, Dreamcatcher, maybe Kep1er for now and groups around there

this is just a personal opinion, but they have nothing special and their facial expressions in the first video are all over the place.

Their discography is quite bland. There's nothing about the group that really outstanding especially when they're not from big company. If you put them with other nugu groups like Pixy, Chebul, Bvndit or Gwsn, nothing makes this stand out. I can even say, they have the weakest discography among these group. Especially if you compare them with the nugu group that able to make it big like Mamamoo, GFriend and Oh my girl.

Quote from Aeicy

well nct 127 is for intellectuals only

Then why do you listen to them?

Quote from Disevidence

Then why do you listen to them?

why dont' u ?

Quote from Aeicy

why dont' u ?

Because there for people who believe their for intellectuals.

Quote from Clemon

what even is this thread

monalisalove get in on this sis

Wtf is this thread??? Why are people using it to shit on Class:y and others groups??

And that Psy fan with their weird obsession in hating BP: 2x (2).gif

Quote from Disevidence

Because there for people who believe their for intellectuals.

kay ur loss

Classy is the hill you'll die on, huh?

Actually I kind of dig some of their songs. They are fun. I don't often find myself wanting to revisit them though.

I'm not really feeling their music but they're talented girls

people don’t like them because most of their group is middle schoolers

I think their songs are good but most of the members don't fit their concept - actually the only member that fits their concept is Jimin imo-

Whenever I watch them, I feel like I'm watching kids wearing their mamas clothes and trying to act mature

its not like their music are super great