GIDLE "I Want That" : BOP vs FLOP

It's okay, there is still I DO

is this the title track?

Quote from Rarami

is this the title track?

Unfortunately, yes.

Not my taste at all but I appreciate that they're doing something different. Sounds like runway music and look like it was inspired by Eve, The Bluebeard and whatever song by Lsf. Don't like it. Miyeon's part is good... Maybe it will grow on me. Blop.

its not that good

Quote from catzi

Miyeon's part is good...

Her part is really really good

And when they put only that part on the highlight medley, I thought I will love this song..

bop its sexy for sexy ppl only

oh I really like it!

it seems very Beyoncé’s Renaissance album inspired.

very much like a fast paced club banger.

Miyeon shines on the album. I'm glad her vocals are actually used well.

It is okay but I like ‘I do’ more. Vocals sounded great but the song is a bit repetitive flat etc Blop!

Listening to the EP now and yikes. I hate Flip It lol once is enough

Keeping: I do, Eye Roll, Tall Trees

Quote from catzi

Not my taste at all but I appreciate that they're doing something different. Sounds like runway music and look like it was inspired by Eve, The Bluebeard and whatever song by Lsf. Don't like it. Miyeon's part is good... Maybe it will grow on me. Blop.

exactly my thoughts

not a fan of the chorus or the rest of the song but I really like miyeon's part as well

so overall not bad for me

flop

As much as I love miyeon's part in this song, she couldn't save the song for me. Gonna give this a few more listen maybe this would grow on me.

Flop. I’m a huge Gidle fan, but this may be the worst title track they’ve ever had.

Yall tasteless this is a bop

It’s not gonna do better than queencard due to how barren and unconventional the hook is as far as mainstream kpop goes, not to mention it’s in english and the mv isn’t exactly high budget or extraordinary, but this still hits pretty hard as a club banging voguing anthem I see it like a spiritual relative of xg’s tgif which is another voguing galore spectacle

....Minnie just shot a dude in the head lol. Weird as hell.

It sounds like Bluebeard's cousin, how are y'all gonna hype up that song and then shade this one? They're literally the same song omg.

This time is unfortunetly a flop for me.

It gave me a whiplash

Flop for now but idk lol

Flop..

I think it’s a bop, the chorus is a bit flat but Miyeon’s part makes up for it.

the funny part to me is the WHAT HUH???

Is this their English debut?

Too western, obviously since 88 Rising produced it. It's good, but [I feel] it is not true to the G-(I)dle brand, all their songs are about confidence and inner beauty how is this relatable? BLOP because I love idle but can't stand the bust-down American cheap club version.

sounds strange

floo

Quote from desdesdes

Unfortunately, yes.

Yikes.

Flop I am afraid. This talking/ rapping was too much and it was annoying.

wow, a g-idle title track i actually like? i am stunned issa whole bop

don't get the lsrfm eve blue beard blabla comparisons tho

Who the hell approved those horrible lyrics?

No hate to Idle...but the song has bombed on every platform. The song fucking sucks.

950+ on Melon, less than 1m views in 10 hours lol? No one likes this song clearly...so it begs the question...

Why do people keep giving Lindgren work? He fucking sucks ass.

Quote from barnaby

Who the hell approved those horrible lyrics?

Horrible lyrics don't seem to bother you when you listen Twice. What's the worst between "yes or yes" and "i'm gonna be a star" i still wonder

It's a blop/bop for me but I'm glad it's just a side project and I hope a real comeback with the members involved is coming. (G)I-dle without members composition credits just doesn't feel (G)I-dle to me

It's always weird to hear music from (G)I-DLE that doesn't come from them originally. I mean, because they're one of the very few self produced groups, we fans have grown used to their music identity. Even when jumping from one genre to another, there's always something familiar enough that make you say "it's new but it's Gidle still". So when they release songs that are obviously composed by a third party, something sounds off. Which is why I don't know what to think of it, though I can say this album makes a better use of the members' vocals than what Last Dance did back then, especially Miyeon's.

As for the title track, it's curious they went with that song. It's kinda bold stylistically, but not that great all things considered.

tons of english

awful pronunciation

no meaning

very shallow

classic post-covid IDLE

Quote from unbannBLACPINK

tons of english

duh, it's an English language EP, you shmuck

Gigantic bop, they’re on such a giant streak

Quote from TheBotter

No hate to Idle...but the song has bombed on every platform. The song fucking sucks.

Why would Idle care? This is a side release and has no credits for any of the members.

Neverlands dont' even like it.

People talking about charting for this is weird. Does anyone care when JP releases don't chart on Melon etc? This song was never going to do anything in Korea, it's not designed for that. I don't think it's going to go well on Spotify either, such a strange decision by 88 rising and Cube to completely drop Idle's sound for some b-grade western producer cuts.

Luckily it's out of the way and we can look forward to the Full Album KR release next.