Nmixx vs Aespa: Best vocal

I'll say nmixx because I haven't heard a single live note from aespa yet and nmixx are having concerts with flawless vocals in the waiting room for mcountdown

Bae is even weaker than Giselle...

I prefer Aespa’s vocal line personally but lily and Haewon are really amazing (Jinni and Sullyoon too)

Quote from billlie-outsold

I’m genuinely curious on your opinions don’t cancel me

Cancel, blocked, and reported

Aespa for the listed reasons, I agree with you. The thing nobody can deny is that Purple Kiss, Aespa and Nmixx has some of the strongest vocal lines of 4th gen.

Quote from killthisfenty

Bae is even weaker than Giselle...

I prefer Aespa’s vocal line personally but lily and Haewon are really amazing (Jinni and Sullyoon too)

For me I'd say Bae and Giselle are just on the same level

Quote from SooYoung

Aespa

All the members are great

While Nmixx have some members who are much more weaker than giselle like bae and jinni

I think Jinni is actually better than Giselle, but Bae, Jiwoo and Kyujin are weaker

Lily m and haewon are really good but every member in aespa is better than sullyoon, bae, jiwoo and jinny so I'd go with aespa as a whole

It definitly aespa, they might not singing live during their promotion but there tons of them singing live where all 4 actually have strong vocal. But hey for me atm, aespa, nmixx, stayc & purple kiss is the best gg with vocal.

I believe in sm choosing good vocals, they never disappoint on that note, even though aepsa hasnt really sung live yet.

my vote goes to aespa.

NMIXX sing live

I prefer nmixx

Quote from QueenMaknae27

Cancel, blocked, and reported

uhhh where's the flower pot throwing?

gotta throw them flower pots!!!!

I hav heard plenty of Aespa

but i havent listened enough to NMIXX to give an opinion yet

Quote from lialve

Lily m and haewon are really good but every member in aespa is better than sullyoon, bae, jiwoo and jinny so I'd go with aespa as a whole

youve never listened to nmixx if you think giselle/karina are better than sullyoon

idek i am not vocal expert or sm

but i think aespa they have advantage of having less members

Quote from penguinsgg

youve never listened to nmixx if you think giselle/karina are better than sullyoon

no I did. she sounded good in their debut songs but giselle and karina can do more with their voice from what I've seen. It's not like she got a lot of lines that it would be hard for her. If I hear giselle and karina sing live more, maybe I'll change my mind. But this is my opinion now

.

Yes, I like powerful women.

Quote from lialve

no I did. she sounded good in their debut songs but giselle and karina can do more with their voice from what I've seen. It's not like she got a lot of lines that it would be hard for her. If I hear giselle and karina sing live more, maybe I'll change my mind. But this is my opinion now

yeah thats true, they prob around =. its just hard to tell when SM doesnt let anyone sing live anyone for unknown reasons, cause it makes their "live" stages shittier alltogther

Quote from penguinsgg

yeah thats true, they prob around =. its just hard to tell when SM doesnt let anyone sing live anyone for unknown reasons, cause it makes their "live" stages shittier alltogther

It was shitty move from SM , however this statement wasn't entirely true there were at least 3 stages from aespa that I'm 100% sure it was live

In Aespa, Ningning and Winter Main Vocal, Karina and Giselle are at the lead vocal level. Aespa is more advantageous as there is no weak member vocally. There are vocals that I like in Nmixx; Lily M, Haewon and Bae. But some are probably at the sub vocalist level. Most of SM's rappers are at the lead vocal level. Some people don't admit it, but people are surprised to hear how well they sing on their solo debut, I'm not even surprised because Sm's vocal is prioritized.

Nmixx have a decent amount of members with good vocals they are also really stable while peforming, Aespa on the other hand well we haven't gotten live vocals from performances yet but all of the members are good vocally giselle may be a decent rapper but she does have good vocals. As for the main vocalists I believe it comes down to preference for me I like Ningning's technique more and I believe she has a good vocal range, but Lily also has a good technique I also find her voice mesmerizing.So in my opinion I prefer Aespa's vocals and think that they are the best.

Stupid comparisons made by eggspa fan 4 members vs 7 members how about whos better dancer plus singer and overall talented what matters not this 4 member groups to 7 members group so stupid comparisons

BP is better

Aespa.

Quote from itiswhatitisss

i mean karina alone could easily be a main/lead vocalist in another group so def aespa

not in nmixx tho but I get what you mean

all I'm gonna say is that ninging anf lily aren't that much different from each other vocally so I think they both groups have good vocals. It's all a matter of preference at this point.

Karina ->Ning Ning -->Lily----->the rest

No hate but all members of Aespa can outsing NMiXx..

Lily, Haewon

(gap)

Ningning, Sullyoon

(gap)

the rest

Ningning has very few live clips to actually make an argument, I think. Lily ate D5 and have a decent F5 and sometimes G5, her mixed voice is better as well. Ningning hasn't sung any notes that high live, or prove me wrong, please! Karina's best supported range is around B4. So please stop overrating her, lmao.

So far Lily>Ningning>Haewon=Winter>Sullyoon>Karina

Quote from verallia

Ningning has very few live clips to actually make an argument, I think. Lily ate D5 and have a decent F5 and sometimes G5, her mixed voice is better as well. Ningning hasn't sung any notes that high live, or prove me wrong, please! Karina's best supported range is around B4. So please stop overrating her, lmao.

So far Lily>Ningning>Haewon=Winter>Sullyoon>Karina

no bias answer

Quote from alexS

This thread is just what ifs and what nots.

Can we compare their live vocals?

External Content youtu.be

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

External Content youtu.be

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

Now you can judge

Display More

Excellent....

The arrangement of NMIXX's Kill This Love would arguably go down as the best Cover of a Kpop Song because it allowed the Vocal Tone and Flavor of each member to shine.

Whereas the arrangement for aespa's Savage comes across as generic as they typically just use the Main Vocals for the large part of the Song.

I mean Aespa don't sound like they are dying trying to reach a note so i guess Aespa