Newjeans success vs Nmixx talent: Which is more impressive?

newjeans obviously

the fact that you can be bang average and earn that much just by debuting is a huge shock

I didn't even know enhypen reached 2 billion streams that fast if it wasn't for this thread lol I don't know for me overall streams is still more impressive but yes success is in general more impressive in KPOP

Good singing technique is useless if your songs aren't good

Yes

NJ.

Lena Park has impressive vocals. Nmixx ok for kids.

both groups are talented and popular. What is this comparison hahaha

Do you mean N’Jeans brand and marketing machine? They do have a more sophisticated one behind them.

Both groups could make a mark on the game if their teams maintain a certain level of quality.

I think your talent in making bait threads is most impressive!

Quote from bbb988

Newjeans is successful but are often considered untalented and lackluster performers.

This is only a common sentiment on that NJ hating echo chamber subreddit you did us all the displeasure of linking here.

Don't try to misrepresent the words of insecure and jealous girl group stans as the consensus opinion on the quality of NewJeans as performers and talents.

They literally just did two massive music festivals this summer, and both were universally praised by anyone not hiding an agenda.

Do better. Be better.

Quote from YamaChwan

This is only a common sentiment on that NJ hating echo chamber subreddit you did us all the displeasure of linking here.

Don't try to misrepresent the words of insecure and jealous girl group stans as the consensus opinion on the quality of NewJeans as performers and talents.

They literally just did two massive music festivals this summer, and both were universally praised by anyone not hiding an agenda.

Do better. Be better.

Display More

What is this NJ hating echo chamber subreddit you speak of and why havent i heard of it?

Quote from BlackpinkHouse

What is this NJ hating echo chamber subreddit you speak of and why havent i heard of it?

Quote from bbb988

there’s not many idol groups that are as impressive as Nmixx in vocal/performing skills, so they could be considered more impressive.

EXO? Mamamoo? WSJN? Seventeen? NCT 127? BtoB? Apink?

That's not even counting second generation which was stacked with great vocalists. SM vocalists were extremely strong back then

Not saying Nmixx are not incredible but there was no shortage in good vocalists in kpop groups before them

nmixx's high notes make me feel more than all of the sucess newjeans has had

Quote from BlackpinkHouse

What is this NJ hating echo chamber subreddit you speak of and why havent i heard of it?

It's just r/kpopthoughts

Quote from ThePhantomThief

It's just r/kpopthoughts

that sub-hate every popular group (BP, BTS, Twice, and now it is NJ's turn)

If you getting hated on that sub, then you the group is at least popular

NJ success >>>

lots of groups can do what nmixx can do

no one is doing it like NewJeans

New Jeans, One of the most successful debut. And becoming top artist since day 1.

coming from Hybe with big resources, why would I be impressed?

New Jeans. JYP can make use of NMIXX talent with better songs but they can’t.

Quote from Panpriyah-lice

coming from Hybe with big resources, why would I be impressed?

So BP success is not impressive too since they are from yg with big resources too? Agree tho.

Quote from Panpriyah-lice

coming from Hybe with big resources, why would I be impressed?

You arent even aware that you just said that bp success isn't impressive because they come from a big company lol

And nmixx are also from big 4, why are you acting like they are from a nugu company

Quote from doesitneedsaying

And nmixx are also from big 4, why are you acting like they are from a nugu company

the mysterious million seller nugus

Quote from KpopJop

the mysterious million seller nugus

yasss, you going for the NSWERS, I see... Don't know if they bring much akorns, but anyways

Quote from Catgirl

yasss, you going for the NSWERS, I see... Don't know if they bring much akorns, but anyways

i'm sure they're out there, given these sales numbers

Quote from KpopJop

i'm sure they're out there, given these sales numbers

Do NSWERTaglist you guys think NMIXXs album sales are legit? I think they are all bought by Jay Why Pee himself

Quote from Catgirl

Do NSWERTaglist you guys think NMIXXs album sales are legit? I think they are all bought by Jay Why Pee himself

NOOOOOOOOOO omg

Quote from KpopJop

NOOOOOOOOOO omg

so excited for this one I have 136 akorns already!

Quote from Catgirl

so excited for this one I have 136 akorns already!

i've been really getting into NMIXX lately so sadly i cannot argue with heart against them lol

Quote from KpopJop

i've been really getting into NMIXX lately so sadly i cannot argue with heart against them lol

I love them too, but I don't believe that they sold 4m albums without any scam

Quote from KpopJop

the mysterious million seller nugus

this part is accurate tho

1m sales, how?!

Eta: I'm not saying they aren't legitimate, I'm asking where is the taste lol

success matters more than talent

results matter!!!

(FYI I'm nore saying NJ is untalented)

Quote from KpopJop

the mysterious million seller nugus

This is the answer: endless fansign, luckydraw,videocall events

2 months after release, they are still doing events with new photocards, almost every few days. Yesterday had something new too. This is totally on another level.

For reference, all photocards so far for Midsummer for 1 member:

For comparison (take Ive last release for example)

You can see how nmixx doubled the amount of IVE (which is already a lot)

The first time i see UP TO SIX rounds of fansign at 1 store ONLY (soundwave 6, makestar 6 etc.) Crazy how much JYP is pushing for the sales