minji from NJ is the perfect example of visuals > everything

we have so many specimen for this, talent barely matters anymore

Minji is a perfect example of perfection

Now let’s see how long you last with that mediocre trolling

she's pretty good as a singer tho??? and is a decent dancer too???

Go Minji Go

OP is a perfect example of "need a life"

Quote from Bpsosoro

And it’s always nmixx stans blabbing about talent. Y’all have nothing else to stan for I guess. Please shut your fucking mouth up and pray to god your favs get a single good song before you speak

And what's the correlation between songs and talent? Your subjective song quality does not change your general level of talent. It's the fault of those who make the songs as the way they are but has nothing to do with talent. I'm pretty sure we can all admit that the girls are talented but I don't see how songs composed with shouty rap and vocal lines and lyrics and beat drops that make absolutely no sense and don't flow well, show how good or bad group members are. If they've already showcased what they could do, then I don't see any sort of correlation.

gosh, I don't even know anything about NewJeans to add on, I dont even know what lines are hers

She did great in this

This thread reeks

Quote from jinaland

we have so many specimen for this, talent barely matters anymore

Maybe it's just me or my language but the word choice with specimen is we are talking about human beings, that you think like OP that they aren't talented is partly your opinion. And talent does matter in the long run, but the industry is a lottery and visuals do have a big place in it.

Quote from Anpanromane

This thread reeks

Maybe it's just me or my language but the word choice with specimen is we are talking about human beings, that you think like OP that they aren't talented is partly your opinion. And talent does matter in the long run, but the industry is a lottery and visuals do have a big place in it.

english is not my first language, i have just used the word specimen as "example", didnt know its not used for human, if it was offensive i am sorry

opinion? i dont think talent is that subjective thing. And its okay, because majority of the idols have mediocre talent to barely have talent. But at least I appreciate the ones who work hard for improvement. There are only few stand out talents. Idk if talent does matter in the long run, I have never seen most talented ggs being on top since 3rd gen.

"everyone is untalented except my faves" yah right. You guys should go stan Beethoven or Mozart or something.

Quote from Disturbia

and you stan the lack of talent, so i guess we both goobers

External Content www.youtube.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

A random youtube video that fishes for views with clickbait titles..be serious

Lack of talent when they have one of the best kpop dancers, the best female rap line in kpop and a vocalist that has been praised by everyone and their mamas even if she's not ~objectively~ the best. But you wouldn't know anything about vocals anyway cause i did see you in another thread saying Chaewon is better than Yunjin

And i don't know what you're even talking about. She's a good dancer and charming on stage and her voice is NEEDED in NewJeans. She sounds good.

No one has rapped in the group, so why even bring up rapping.

It was so random and unprovocked.

Anyway, Minji legend.

Minji was selected by So Sungjin, the former owner of GFriend, and was a source trainee until So sold his company and Minji was trasferred to Ador.

Even So realized visuals were more important than talent, after his experiences with Yuju (Umji was an early investor so she is a different story).

Nmixx is the perfect example that Company Name > song quality

I swear it's always the uglies being bothered by idols visuals

Quote from WhyKnock

Minji was selected by So Sungjin, the former owner of GFriend, and was a source trainee until So sold his company and Minji was trasferred to Ador.

Even So realized visuals were more important than talent, after his experiences with Yuju (Umji was an early investor so she is a different story).

Are you saying his "negative experiences" with Yuju that she looked average so she did not become more famous despite her stand out singing? or his "positive experiences" that she is one of the most traditionally attractive members and became the most famous?

Clean out your mouth before talking shit on my Minji

Why so angry OP? Or do you just hate successful women being successful?

I would add company name, music and styling to be more important for an idol group success, talent is just a nice bonus to have, but not really necessary to any outstanding degree.

Even though, I don't think, she's any worst or better than the majority of idols. Especially because K-pop fans just bring the talent card o when they hate or like a group.

man on forum lashes out in response to the success of others

more news at 11, Jan

also NMIXX deserves better Stans lol

Quote from Help1

Are you saying his "negative experiences" with Yuju that she looked average so she did not become more famous despite her stand out singing? or his "positive experiences" that she is one of the most traditionally attractive members and became the most famous?

I really truly believe that if Yuju had fit traditional beauty standards, she'd have been an It Girl. GFriend got dragged far too much for being "ugly"

Quote from Derpcatcher

I don't even know NJ nor its members so have little context to go on, so instead of jumping on OP as a person noone is proving them wrong by showcasing why they are wrong

Op didn't prove their wrong take either and what's there to prove to a hater?

Edit: people did more than op, they shared a video of her dancing no?

Wow the lashings here

Quote from KpopJop

also NMIXX deserves better Stans lol

I do not stan NMIXX but they got like 4 fans here lol why are you acting it’s million people.

Quote from killthisfenty

Wow the lashings here

I do not stan NMIXX but they got like 4 fans here lol why are you acting it’s million people.

I’m not talking about those 4 other fans

Quote from Help1

Are you saying his "negative experiences" with Yuju that she looked average so she did not become more famous despite her stand out singing? or his "positive experiences" that she is one of the most traditionally attractive members and became the most famous?

The former. GFriend was always short on visuals and Yuju, unfortunately, was the worst

So Sungjin probably realized visuals win the day for GGs, not talents

Quote from Golden_Wishes

I really truly believe that if Yuju had fit traditional beauty standards, she'd have been an It Girl. GFriend got dragged far too much for being "ugly"

Nah, there's none GFriend's members have that personality or aura to fits in the It girl title. Hwasa didn't have that traditional beauty standards too, but she know how to carries herself and make her one of the It girl. Sowon and Eunha have that chance at the peak of GFriend career but as I said, they don't have that personality in them.

Quote from WhyKnock

The former. GFriend was always short on visuals and Yuju, unfortunately, was the worst

So Sungjin probably realized visuals win the day for GGs, not talents

It's Umji who got the harshest critiques for her visual. She was called as one of the ugliest idols ever debuted before

Quote from Bananapple

Nah, there's none GFriend's members have that personality or aura to fits in the It girl title. Hwasa didn't have that traditional beauty standards too, but she know how to carries herself and make her one of the It girl. Sowon and Eunha have that chance at the peak of GFriend career but as I said, they don't have that personality in them.

Yuju was the one that ended up blowing up over the falling fancams that put GFriend on the map. Plus she was known for being an amazing vocalist and a hit OST. Hwasa wasn't a traditional beauty but she appealed to women and Mamamoo as a whole did as well, GFriend was catered more to men.

Plus GFriend was hilarious wydm

what is this nonsense

Quote from Bananapple

It's Umji who got the harshest critiques for her visual. She was called as one of the ugliest idols ever debuted before

Umji is another case since her dentist father was a probable investor to GF