Most talented top girl group

I.O.I

SNSD m8

Nmixx and Gidle

RV and blackpink

Quote from Vermnd15

Damn I only wanted 10 options. Anyway let's say they are legendary tier and don't need to be in polls like this.

They said it themselves

pasted-from-clipboard.png

I vote for my fav

Dance /10

Gidle: 5/10

Twice: 9/10

RV: 7/10

BP: 7/10

ITZY:8/10

Aespa: 5/10

NMixx: 5/10 ( not enough info)

le sserafim: 6/10

IVE: 7/10

Vocals /10

Gidle: 6/10

Twice: 7/10

RV: 9/10

BP: 6/10

ITZY: 5/10

Aespa: 5/10

NMixx: 8/10

Le sserafim: 7/10

IVE: 7/10

Rap /10

Gidle: 9/10

Twice: 5/10

RV: 4/10

BP: 9/10

Itzy: 7/10

Aespa: 5/10

Nmixx: 5/10 ( not enough info)

Le Sserafim: 4/10

IVE: 5/10

Average

Gidle: 6.6

Twice: 7

RV: 6.6

BP: 7.3

ITZY: 6.6

Aespa: 5

Nmixx: 6

Le Sserafim: 5.6

IVE: 6.3

Ranking

1) BP

2) Twice

3) gidle/ RV/ ITZY

4) IVE

5) Nmixx

6) Le Sserafim

7) Aespa

So from these calculations, BP is the most talented. They are helped in that each member has a specialization which brings their grade up in each category.

i really like stayc members' voices

Quote from Vermnd15

Ya! you are doing too much. How are you going to rank twice vocals 7/10 and give aespa 5/10

Jihyo and Nayeon bring up Twice vocal score. There are no such members for Aespa. Twice has at least two vocal stand outs and Mina as a strong back up. Aespa members don’t have that

Quote from Teudungi21

So from these calculations, BP is the most talented. They are helped in that each member has a specialization which brings their grade up in each category.

Are songwriting, composing, and arranging not talents?

Mamamoo if they were there or Red Velvet.

I don't know much about 4G at all lol. So from that list probably RV? Great stable singing, decent enough dance.

Buuuuuut since SNSD are back it would easily be them. The best singing group of the lot and the best dancing group too and best of all they can do both at the same time. They blow everyone else away

Their only weakness as performers is lack of rap but not many of their songs were created with rap in them so there's less need for one than other ggs which heavily implement rap.

Quote from hokiedood

Are songwriting, composing, and arranging not talents?

I just did it on those three skills. Of course adding those things would change the order

My faves

Quote from Teudungi21

Vocals /10

Gidle: 6/10

Twice: 7/10

RV: 9/10

BP: 6/10

ITZY: 5/10

Aespa: 5/10

NMixx: 8/10

Le sserafim: 7/10

IVE: 7/10

Rap /10

Gidle: 9/10

Twice: 5/10

RV: 4/10

BP: 9/10

Itzy: 7/10

Aespa: 5/10

Nmixx: 5/10 ( not enough info)

Le Sserafim: 4/10

IVE: 5/10

Display More

Gidle and Blackpink's vocals below LSF, IVE and Twice. Twice - the girl group infamous for some of the worst encore vocals in history, has better vocals than Rose, or Miyeon, or Minnie, or Yuqi? Shit Jisoo ain't all that to write home about vocally, but she's still better then about 4 of Twice.

Twice above Itzy in Dance. Just hilarious.

Blackpink on the same rap level as Soyeon. Detached from reality.

I needed a good laugh to start the day. Glad you provided.

G-idle

(G)I-DLE

Quote from Roses-are-Rosie

My faves

but are your favs the same as my favs??

Quote from Disevidence

Gidle and Blackpink's vocals below LSF, IVE and Twice. Twice - the girl group infamous for some of the worst encore vocals in history, has better vocals than Rose, or Miyeon, or Minnie, or Yuqi? Shit Jisoo ain't all that to write home about vocally, but she's still better then about 4 of Twice.

Twice above Itzy in Dance. Just hilarious.

Blackpink on the same rap level as Soyeon. Detached from reality.

I needed a good laugh to start the day. Glad you provided.

Display More

Gidle aren’t that good singers. I’m sorry that’s the fact. You can like them more of course though.

Twice have one of the best dancers in Kpop with momo and several good dancers in Mina, Jihyo l, and Nayeon.

Judo and Rosie are not better than Jihyo, Rosie levels more with Nayeon and Josip with Mina. So yes vocally Twice has better people.

I could see BP being at an 8 on rap but I thought it made sense that it takes two BO rappers to equal Soyeon.

Twice is great at dance, in fact I think it’s their best skill hands down. ITZY is great as well.

You can hate twice but you clearly your attitude gets in the way of accurate judgment

gidle, blackpink, nmixx

Quote from selfmate

but are your favs the same as my favs??

Maybe or maybe not

Quote from Roses-are-Rosie

Maybe or maybe not

that begs the question of who are your favs?

Quote from selfmate

that begs the question of who are your favs?

Display Spoiler

I said favSSSSSS since I know one - are there others?

You already know :

TWICE.

They may not have powerhouse vocalists like Wendy, NingNing and Winter or Yunjin but 3mix are good enough vocalists. Mina and Chaeyoung are also good as sub-vocals, better than most sub vocals of the groups listed in the OP.

Dancing, I feel TWICE only comes second to Itzy here. Momo is a better dancer than Yeji Chaeryoung but Mina isn't. Sana, Tzuyu, Nayeon and Jihyo are all strong dancers but I would rank them below Itzy's dance line.

Rapping - TWICE are pretty weak here but Chaeyoung is a good rapper who writes her own raps. Dahyun isn't the best lead rapper but gets the job done.

Stage Presence - Between TWICE and BP for me. I know Itzy is hyped alot as the best 4th gen performers but I honestly don't see it.

Also, they can write, choreograph, and compose. They are the big 3 GG with the most credits.

Overall, TWICE wins.

Quote from icyruios

In this list?

Soyeon

Then the rest

I don't know this group

Quote from icyruios

She transcends groups

Why don't I know this transcendental group?

holy shit the standards are so rock bottom

Nmixx wins this easily followed by red velvet

the people in the poll are mental

Quote from Teudungi21

Gidle aren’t that good singers

G-Idle aren't technically the best singers around, i'm well aware. They lean on vocal colour more than pure skill.

But that said, they're still better on average, by FAR then Twice. Someone also pointed out Aespa being under Twice which is equally laughable. I mean they barely sing live, but they can sing well.

It's not about twice hating, it's about you, the deluded stan, completely overstating your faves. I mean you sort of proved it with the Twice > Itzy in dance. Twice are good dancers, no doubt. But they are not as good as a whole at Itzy, who even I can realize, are probably the strongest dance group around (along with Lightsum).

That's why I found it hilarious. You just outright admitted to completely biasing your faves, so mad respect in a way. Shamelessness in just being completely deluded is almost admirable.

Quote from Roses-are-Rosie

You already know :

Display Spoiler

Display Spoiler

Display Spoiler

Display Spoiler

Display Spoiler

Display Spoiler

Itzy

Display Spoiler

Display Spoiler

Display Spoiler

Le Sserafim

Display Spoiler

Display Spoiler

Display Spoiler

Twice and Aespa

Display More

we share four favs then which is not bad not bad...lol

The two groups I voted for are leading.

Quote from selfmate

we share four favs then which is not bad not bad...lol

That just shows that you have some taste 🤠

Quote from Roses-are-Rosie

That just shows that you have some taste 🤠

well I'm only (semi) tasteless