Posts by Vermnd15
-
-
Yeah I'm not a fan of rose either. Her tone can grate
-
-
He's the guy who left stray kids and stays continue trying to make him a bad guy and spread false rumours and shade with no evidence
-
Inspired by a thread a few days ago by MissBehave - only this time instead of idols who's vocal tones you love - ones who ruin songs and give you headaches.
I'll start with a current one that's annoying me
1. YOON FROM STAYC. Who told this girl that screaming the notes counts as singing. Beautiful monster is a decent song but she absolutely ruins it for me. She's really just awful and gets progressively worse with successive title tracks - I thought she couldn't top run to you but here she is again!
Black eye pilseung needs to have a word with her.
2. Mingi ateez - awful. constantly sounds like he has a hot potato in his mouth. I love answer but I would like it a lot more if I could delete his parts.
-
-
Jeez what are you saying. I have no skin in this game but Winter and Ning Ning are much much MUCH better vocalists than Jihyo and nayeon.
And even if you are going by averages - all 4 members of aespa sing well. In twice - only 3 people out of 9 sing well and have some range. When you make statements like this - you just set up the group to be dragged because it's too much. The exact opposite of objectivity.
-
Display More
Dance /10
Gidle: 5/10
Twice: 9/10
RV: 7/10
BP: 7/10
ITZY:8/10
Aespa: 5/10
NMixx: 5/10 ( not enough info)
le sserafim: 6/10
IVE: 7/10
Vocals /10
Gidle: 6/10
Twice: 7/10
RV: 9/10
BP: 6/10
ITZY: 5/10
Aespa: 5/10
NMixx: 8/10
Le sserafim: 7/10
IVE: 7/10
Rap /10
Gidle: 9/10
Twice: 5/10
RV: 4/10
BP: 9/10
Itzy: 7/10
Aespa: 5/10
Nmixx: 5/10 ( not enough info)
Le Sserafim: 4/10
IVE: 5/10
Average
Gidle: 6.6
Twice: 7
RV: 6.6
BP: 7.3
ITZY: 6.6
Aespa: 5
Nmixx: 6
Le Sserafim: 5.6
IVE: 6.3
Ranking
1) BP
2) Twice
3) gidle/ RV/ ITZY
4) IVE
5) Nmixx
6) Le Sserafim
7) Aespa
So from these calculations, BP is the most talented. They are helped in that each member has a specialization which brings their grade up in each category.
Ya! you are doing too much. How are you going to rank twice vocals 7/10 and give aespa 5/10
-
3rd gen - lured in by BTS and twice
-
SNSD m8
Damn I only wanted 10 options. Anyway let's say they are legendary tier and don't need to be in polls like this.
-
Title says it all - Vote for the currently active top girl group you feel on the balance of things is most talented - This should include considerations of vocal talent, rap ability and performance capability.
I personally don't weigh dancing as high as vocals/rapping so a group like itzy won't get my vote but feel free to measure how you like but do try to be objective.
I did a recent similar post for boy groups and a common comment was being allowed to vote for more than one - hence you get 3 options.
-
The songs are good and they are singing without hybe autotune/vocal processing.
They already won in my books
-
The rest yes but I think BTS has a better rapline than SKZ
-
-
-
I didn't know i could do that.
If you go to the Kbs YouTube account and look through the latest music bank episode posted performances (they post each group separately) - you can definitely get a sense of who's popular. Chungha sadly seems to have fallen off.
-
current active boy groups
Very Successful - BTS, SVT, NCT, SKZ, TXT, Enhypen
Midrange Successful - the Boyz, Ateez
Low range Successful - ONF, CIX, ab6ix, Wei,
Nugu - cravity, bae173, dkb, kingdom, tan
Very Successful - twice, blackpink, RV, aespa, Itzy, ive,
Midrange Successful - stayc,
Low range Successful - fromis 9, wjsn, Loona, everglow , weeekly
Nugu - cherry bullet, lightsum, bandit, PIXY,
-
-
No stand out bg among these who has exceptional talent over others. Maybe give a none of the above option.
Bitter ExoL
-
This is super cute though!
