name groups that have more vocal line than their dance line

leinadluzd · Apr 13th 2022

i am so tired of recent girl groups that have only 1 or 2 members as the vocal line

kpop is shifting towards performance-focused path rather than vocal-focused group

as for the thread, can you name any groups that has more than half members with vocal line than dance line

for example, if the group is 5-membered, then at least 3 of them are in the vocal line

or if the group is 12-membered, then at least 6 of them are vocally capable

i can think of some groups that fit the description such as,

red velvet - wendy seulgi joy

iz*one - yuri eunbi yena chaeyeon chaewon yujin

loona - chuu haseul jinsoul kim lip heejin yves choerry

what do you guys think ? is there any more groups that fits the description ?

MissBehave · Apr 13th 2022

Exo

MyZen-L · Apr 13th 2022

EXO, aespa(?), Red Velvet, i think there are more vocalists in NCT than there are dancers, TVXQ, Super Junior(?)

sorecer · Apr 13th 2022

SNSD (OT9)

Taeyeon, Jessica, Tiffany, Seohyun and Sunny

but honestly if u put SNSD dance line to sing can beat a lot of vocal lines of the 3rd and 4th gen lol

the101 · Apr 13th 2022

I don't think kpop is shifting towards performance based vs vocal based - it's always been that way. The biggest groups are not necessarily the strongest vocalists.

To name specific groups, EXO, NCT (all units, esp NCT 127), Purple Kiss, Mamamoo, The Boyz. I'm sure someone who's a bigger multi can probably go on for quite a bit - I don't think it's an anomaly at all. It's not every group certainly, but I don't think there's a decline there.

quarkie · Apr 13th 2022

Quote from the101

I don't think kpop is shifting towards performance based vs vocal based - it's always been that way. The biggest groups are not necessarily the strongest vocalists.

To name specific groups, EXO, NCT (all units, esp NCT 127), Purple Kiss, Mamamoo, The Boyz. I'm sure someone who's a bigger multi can probably go on for quite a bit - I don't think it's an anomaly at all. It's not every group certainly, but I don't think there's a decline there.

I agree. Even in a group like Ateez which is often labeled as a performance group... they only have 5 in the dance/performance line, but 6 members who vocalists. (Funnily enough, 4/5 of the performance line? They're also vocalists!)

I feel like it's more of a case where they're getting more rappers and vocalists who are also very capable dancers so we're seeing bigger dance lines sometimes.

Like in the past, I feel like it's mostly a case of the vocals/rappers and the dancers being different people (especially in groups of 6+) outside of that one (or two) members who could do both, but as kpop has grown I feel like it's more common to find almost the whole group as a high level dancer.

xoxoshawol · Apr 13th 2022

~~[insert SM groups]~~

EXO, SHINee, TVXQ, BTOB and Super Junior are some of them.

MAMAMOO is basically a vocal group.

centen · Apr 13th 2022

#cheating but all bands. Their dance lines are non-existent.

novemberrain · Apr 13th 2022

Exo; chen baekhyun kyungsoo suho

Xiumin can be counted as well

shiguri · Apr 13th 2022

The ones that come to my mind are Mamamoo (Solar, Wheein, Hwasa), Dreamcatcher (JiU, SuA, Siyeon and Yoohyeon) and Purple Kiss (Goeun, Swan, Chaein).

neonanton1 · Apr 13th 2022

Gfriend?

4d-maknae · Apr 13th 2022

Upcoming girlgroup Classy from MBC survival show, 4 out of 7 are vocalists, and the maknae line is this good predebut

External Content youtu.be

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

into-the-new-wor · Apr 14th 2022

Girls' Generation

icyruios · Apr 14th 2022

Day6, 4/5 are vocal line and 0/5 are dance line

dsc · Apr 14th 2022

bts, originally:

Vocal line : 4 members

Dance line : 3 members

Panpriyah-lice · Apr 14th 2022

MAMAMOO 4/4

russianvelvet · Apr 14th 2022

Golden Child:

Vocals: 7/10

Dance: 4/10 (I think, could be 5)

Lovelyz:

Vocals: 8/8

Dance: 4/8

Onf:

Vocals: 6/6

Dance: 3/6

aznboy-x2 · Apr 14th 2022

. . . technically NCT, Kingdom and BTS before they put V in the dance line 2018 . . .

name groups that have more vocal line than their dance line

Participate now!

Share

Similar Threads

How unusual is for boygroups to have strong vocal lines?

The best possible (mostly realistic) lineup for Queendom S2

Why does Solar have the least succesful solo career out of mmm vocal line?

Do you stan more vocalists, dancers or rappers?

[THEQOO] Kai's song that has more dance cover than actual performance video