Is Stayc on the same level as Itzy vocal wise?
-
-
-
-
It’s obviously a set up but they are great live. They literally sound stable and are most of the time singing live. Why do people always expect rookies (they are not even 1 year old) to sound like their seniors who have had more experience and training?
Also why do you need to drag Itzy? They sing live good and their choreos are hard as fuck
-
SAVE ME
External Content youtu.beContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy. -
It’s obviously a set up but they are great live. They literally sound stable and are most of the time singing live. Why do people always expect rookies (they are not even 1 year old) to sound like their seniors who have had more experience and training?
Also why do you need to drag Itzy? They sing live good and their choreos are hard as fuck
THANK YOU!
They're seriously good with stamina.
It's just a setup to get bashed.
-
-
Yeah, I was so impressed with their Loco stages. The choreography is really tiring even though it lookes easier than their older ones but their singing has been improving a lot. Imo, the newest gen is full of idols who can easily sing stable while dancing to the most difficult choreographies
-
ITZY has always been stable live despite their choreographies. It's a similar case to StayC, imo, both don't have that powerful vocalist(s) to make K-pop stans satisfied with the main/lead positions, but they are competent enough.
So I don't know why ITZY is so dragged to be honest. Maybe since they can't come for their dancing, they thought about some other skill just to have a token to come for their talent.
-
-
-
STAYC doesn't have vocalists as strong as Purple Kiss but that doesn't take away from the fact that they're still good singers. I think STAYC deserves to be praised because their live vocals are extremely stable. Not only that, each member has a unique singing voice that manages to compliment the others.
ITZY has insane choreography, so I would personally be more lenient about their vocals. Even then, they do great.
-
-
-
-
-
-
That subtle bashing ugh against both the groups.ugh.
-
-
-
-
A lot of people here talking about hard choreo here but what has hard choreo got to do with singing, songs are pre recorded anyways.
-
A lot of people here talking about hard choreo here but what has hard choreo got to do with singing, songs are pre recorded anyways.
These groups sing live very often
I hate these kinds of threads, this is certainly not true at all.
-
These groups sing live very often
I hate these kinds of threads, this is certainly not true at all.
Even those lives aren't 100% live, they still have some sort of back track playing
-
-
Not to defend OP but they've actually replied to a lot of aespa and red velvet threads especially last year lol or earlier this year forgot but I do remember them replying
-
Lia isn't the weakest main vocal I can name several worst than her..
-
Not to defend OP but they've actually replied to a lot of aespa and red velvet threads especially last year lol or earlier this year forgot but I do remember them replying
Ye maybe he/she have used that acc more before like you see it have 5k posts, but I feel like this acc is just left for baiting. The user has just done it a long time here, so the person knows how to avoid getting bans.
-
-
Lia is miles better than StayC’s best vocalist because she at least knows how to support. None of StayC support because BEP didn’t want them to get vocal training.
I admire their commitment to singing live even with a lack of proper vocal training, but if they keep going like this, their voices are going to get seriously damaged. I especially worry for Sieun since they have her screeching notes she just can’t support in a healthy way.
-
-
-
-
Lia is miles better than StayC’s best vocalist because she at least knows how to support. None of StayC support because BEP didn’t want them to get vocal training.
I admire their commitment to singing live even with a lack of proper vocal training, but if they keep going like this, their voices are going to get seriously damaged. I especially worry for Sieun since they have her screeching notes she just can’t support in a healthy way.
I can't listen to J sing knowing shes forcing her voice that deep it makes me physically uncomfortable like Park Bom like I feel the pain in my throat..
-
-
I think itzy is better overall. Watch the clip below for StayC and judge for yourself. They are not bad singer and clearly can sing live. I don't have much knowledge about singing techniques but I can clearly see they are screaming here. I think I stated my opinion about this before. At high note, you really feel nervous for them. It seems like their voice is thinning out and extremly high pitch when they try to reach it.
YouTubewww.youtube.com -
-
-
Lia is pretty good, contrary to popular belief.
There is probably no difference between them as a group. -
-
She's not forcing it, actually she likes to sing. There was even video when someone said I like J's rap
and she said that she don't have rap part, and she didn't even know she is a rapper :)
you should watch some of those videos where STAYC members are bickering and making fun of J's deep voice
they know she is good... and it's all much better than trying to hit high notes when you clearly can't lol like some other groups are doin high pitch whatever
-
She's not forcing it, actually she likes to sing. There was even video when someone said I like J's rap
and she said that she don't have rap part, and she didn't even know she is a rapper :)
you should watch some of those videos where STAYC members are bickering and making fun of J's deep voice
they know she is good... and it's all much better than trying to hit high notes when you clearly can't lol like some other groups are doin high pitch whatever
J's deep voice do feel overdone, she has a low voice but not as much low as she does in their songs. Her low parts don't feel natural.
-
Participate now!
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!
