Discussion: IF twice doesn’t renew , who will be more affected Twice or JYP

Both? I mean unless they all leave and all resign at another agency (which i think is unlikely because at that point, just stay at JYP).

I guess the question is who it would hurt more and in the long run, maybe the girls. JYP has already milked a lot for them and has many new projects already in the works Nizu, JP BG, Loud BG, Itzy, New package GG.

This isn’t factoring in touring money, which is why i think some members will stay. Because like i said, unless they all sign to another agency, group activities will probably be dead, which would mean a HUGE drop in their tour revenue (when tours are allowed again).

So my best guess is Twice hurting the most (assuming they sign to different agencies/switch to solos), but if they stay as a group, then JYP

JYP. What girl groups of his have had a hit as big as Cheer Up aside from ITZY's Dalla Dalla

Both?

Twice girls have enough money to live i guess, but I don't think all will have a successful solo career so their loss will be in achieving as much as they did with Twice or 50% at least.

JYPE have enough groups and they seem promising, but Twice still sells a lot and are still a huge part of their financial support. Their loss will stop when they hit big again with another group the same way they did with Twice in the sense of: National Girl Group impact..

In conclusion: both will lose something, but JYPE have a better chance of reviving again.

JYPE is already preparing themselves for it

I would say both but more Twice because JYP still haven't give the member a chance to established their own solo career. What I think what JYP want

Anyways look at this

Twice. The members have no individual relevancy in the industry

Both

Jyp has Itzy, Skz, NiziU, Boy Story, Jp bg, Loud bg, New package gg and Day6 (I don't think that they're going to renew). That's a lot of groups to get money from. I think if Twice doesn't renew it would affect Jyp to some extent but not that much.

For Twice if they don't renew the members are probably going to different companies. It doesn't seem like Twice is going to get any solo debuts and that's the only problem for them. If they sign with different companies the members would go solo and they wouldn't have that much experience prior.

JYP will be definitely be affected about twice we don't know if they want to continue being idols some might want to try other things.

another thing twice gave JYP status and weren't they called national girl group?

would JYP even have that again? it's not all about money

JYP can make people buy their group albums without even knowing the group line up, faces and even less their music so I think they will be ok.

Probably TWICE, unfortunately. JYP will be hurt, but will survive. Twice... one or two girls might still get a career but that's the end.

Quote from Slayurfaves

JYP will be definitely be affected about twice we don't know if they want to continue being idols some might want to try other things.

another thing twice gave JYP status and weren't they called national girl group?

would JYP even have that again? it's not all about money

This exactly! JYPE would definitely be affected as they would lose their biggest group and the face of the company but as for TWICE, they've already made enough money to last their life times and we don't even know if most of them want to continue pursuing individual careers in the industry.

Onces

Quote from miuhiae

This exactly! JYPE would definitely be affected as they would lose their biggest group and the face of the company but as for TWICE, they've already made enough money to last their life times and we don't even know if most of them want to continue pursuing individual careers in the industry.

yeah exactly twice is the face of JYP. and tbh there was a time people used to question JYP's big 3 status but it was thanks to twice that made JYPE rise again.

Twice obviously. JYP can simply debut more groups. They're a company so they have more than one route of income. Meanwhile most members of don't have a strong solo career to lean back on too keep them on the same level as they are currently if they leave

I'll never understand why twice girls especially nayeon and tzuyu were bared from solo promos. Very dumb of jyp. They could have had a huge idol in Korea and internationally. The girls r big but never reached full potential.

Twice is a ace group. They have hits, sales and tours. But we never know the new groups may be top groups. Overall jyp is ready for anything. People forget they have niziu.

Twice girls r also set for life with their earnings. I don't think all will have successful solo careers but they'll be fine anyways. Overall no one is that affected like we believe but twice members will be more.

If Twice leaves, JYPE will lose all the money Twice brings from albums, digitals, merch, tours etc. JYPE stock will dive and I don't think that investors would be pleased by it.

The group

Whenever some members or even the whole group doesn't renew it will always be the group that is most affected. JYP still has NiziU, itZy, this blind package group for their girlgroup rosters. They will survive

If Twice members voluntarily leave or retire, i wouldnt consider them to be negatively effected. This would have been their choice, and they would probably end up happier because of it.

I think if some members leave, the remaining members and JYP would both be equally negatively impacted as their album sales would likely drop, at least a little. If one or more of the most popular members leave, the hit on sales could be significant.

Quote from BlackpinkHouse

If Twice members voluntarily leave or retire, i wouldnt consider them to be negatively effected. This would have been their choice, and they would probably end up happier because of it.

I think if some members leave, the remaining members and JYP would both be equally negatively impacted as their album sales would likely drop, at least a little. If one or more of the most popular members leave, the hit on sales could be significant.

This!! I especially agree with the first statement in which I don’t consider them to be negatively effected if they voluntarily leave or choose not to resign. But for the members that want to stay in the industry then yeah.

Neither.

I think the best way to look at it is like a high school or university. Do the schools need the student or do the students need the teacher? In the end, it's neither. The school will not be affected, they just shift their focus on the next set of students who are to graduate. The students will not be affected because they have already gotten the education and tools they need to move on.

Quote from th17e

Anyways look at this

External Content twitter.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

This is my favorite clip of Sana and Nayeon together!!! So precious.

Twice is way too good, JYPE sucks without them

depends if they can continue to use the name Twice and continue as a group even if they don't all renew....

JYP is a big company. They will take a blow but they will somehow survive with remaining lineup

I’d say twice they don’t have solo promotion so it will hurt them a lot jyp still got gg niziu and stray kods

A product can't be affected, it's always the manufacturer

Just came to tell you that this thread got featured and promoted by AKP

Quote from gg-mouthpiece

Just provide your points

JYP, they need Twice because they have been using them as cash cow for years. Since they announced a new girl group in 2022, it looks to me that they might now Twice are disbanding or just adding a new artists to their company will see.

Quote from jdpm12021991

JYP. What girl groups of his have had a hit as big as Cheer Up aside from ITZY's Dalla Dalla

Miss A's Bad Girl Good Girl and WG's triple hits? lol Actually Dalla Dalla is lower beside this hits, Itzy still don't have a national song, i heard Niziu is also doing well in Japan

As for the question, the girls will hurt more in the long run, JYP will suffer for short term but will be fine in long run

obviously them.. Jyp should invest in niziu and bring them to sokor .

If Twice were to disband completely then they will retire as legend, one of kpop greatest acts while JYP will go back to their days of mediocrity pre-Twice.

So, JYP for sure

JYP, Twice carries JYPs brand without them they will take a major hit despite Itzy and SKZ having their own success

Both will be affected, but Twice will have it worse. JYP created Twice, they can create Twice again if they want to. Maybe it will take a while, but they have the resource to bounce back. While for Twice, I doubt any of them can even have 1/5th of the opportunities and money JYP created for them. Group activities with JYP >>>>> solo with any other company.

If Twice are done with idol life or sign with a new company as a whole, JYP will be the affected one and probably will struggle again, not as bad as Twice pre debut but sill. If some members decide to renew and others sign with different companies then is hard to say, don't get me wrong but individually they are not as popular/relevant as other group's members... if they only had individual activities JYP would be the one being affected regardless Twice decision.