I still neutral about them.
Yes i'm still wondering where the hell their AI members are...
I thought the AI concept would be heavily ingrained in their videos and so forth but it hasn't come to fruition yet
I heard that their main purpose is to fill in for them when they're not in the certain place. They have made a few cameos in their mvs.
Always love them 
I heard that their main purpose is to fill in for them when they're not in the certain place. They have made a few cameos in their mvs.
I guess so
well i used to not like the group. not because of the girls but i hated black mamba with my whole heart, i didnt really have an opinion on the girls because i didnt care for them. ig i was just disappointed for a sm gg?
now, i think the girls a pretty cute and i really like forever. i also LOVE ningning and think bm is okay, but i dont stan the girls
i stil dont really like the A.I thing or whatever
Display Morewell i used to not like the group. not because of the girls but i hated black mamba with my whole heart, i didnt really have an opinion on the girls because i didnt care for them. ig i was just disappointed for a sm gg?
now, i think the girls a pretty cute and i really like forever. i also LOVE ningning and think bm is okay, but i dont stan the girls
i stil dont really like the A.I thing or whatever
Kind of the same for me
This
I want an album to know if they worth to stan 
still waiting for ae-winter
Yes i'm still wondering where the hell their AI members are...
I thought the AI concept would be heavily ingrained in their videos and so forth but it hasn't come to fruition yet
in contrary i think they did the best move
they knew that the AI concept wouldn't be easy to understand for a lot of people
and that their debut should focus on the members first, that's why we don't see them a lot in BM
and after BM they introduce the AI quietly
you can see them on twitter Ae-Karina leaving a message to karina
you can see they appear at the end of forever
they appear in their christmas video on Aespa channel
they appear in their SM the stage debut
etc....
I never really payed attention to that stuff
When they first got announced, I didn't really care TBH. Only thing I though was how concerning the AI concept was and how weird people would take advantage of it to do weird things to the AI versions of them. So far nothing has really eased this concern for me, so no, my opinion hasn't changed.
Also really didn't like black mamba (lets be real it was a crap song) and wondering why SM spent all these years training them to not allow them to sing live once, even on the radio shows. Also kinda concerned at how good SM is getting at making those faked live pre-recordings of vocals....
So yeah, despite the rumours never really had any negative thoughts about the members just concerns about how the company is managing them and how that could effect them in the long run.
Yes I love them more 
I am not saying a bully tho 
That's just not true though
Can you send me a video link of them singing live since debut then? No hate just genuinely curious and wanting to listen.
All I have heard since they debuted is they have always had a variety of pre-recorded vocals and even when they went on radio shows they weren't allowed to sing. I personally don't really trust MR removed videos etc.
Can you send me a video link of them singing live since debut then? No hate just genuinely curious and wanting to listen.
All I have heard since they debuted is they have always had a variety of pre-recorded vocals and even when they went on radio shows they weren't allowed to sing. I personally don't really trust MR removed videos etc.
aespa sing live often
External Content youtu.beContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
Thanks, they sound really good but seemed quite nervous. I guess that's what you get when you leave it 4 months after debut. Is there any video of them performing one of their songs whilst singing live?
aespa sing live often
External Content www.youtube.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
External Content www.youtube.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
Thanks for the links, I had genuinely never heard anyone ever say they had seen them singing live or had found any videos post debut of them singing live. But not to be mean or anything but I wouldn't call (by my count) 4 radio shows and couple videos of their own content in 6 months often. Not saying its their fault, just that I wouldn't call that often. Especially for a rookie group when they are in the first huge promotional push. And especially when they are from SM which grants them lots of shows and publicity.
Do you have any videos of them performing whilst singing live? I want to hear them singing the whole song (despite my dislike for both songs, I mean Jesus SM I know you have better songs locked away)
SM which grants them lots of shows and publicity
since when SM give a lot of show to their rookies ???????????,
did you already follow the activities of any sm rookies ? -_-
Need more songs
They are still the best thing since slice bread for me 
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!
