Would NMIXX be more successful than IVE, if they had IVE's songs

icy troll era

Would Icy be icy if she is Icy?

Question: Do both groups swap discographies, or do IVE just get pretty normal songs?

Quote from icyruios

Basically if IVE didn't exist, and NMIXX just get their songs

Oh, I see. I think so then. Nmixx would then haven incredible talent and good songs. I’ve seen literally countless people say that they’d stan them if they had better songs, and I trust them. Besides, debuting in a Big 4 company probably doesn’t hurt either with their popularity I imagine. Normally I’d hold back, because Wonyoung and Yunjin are insanely popular, but if they’re not in a group, or in a different one, and not being considered here as a result, then yeah. Besides, Nmixx also has some popular members, just not quite on their scale yet.

Nmixx stans are obnoxious enough without a strong discography

I saw a Video on youtube that claimed to objectively rank all 4th gen Vocalists and they had the Top 3 all NMixx members or maybe it was 3 of the Top 4 or something stupid like that

Either way my Eyes nearly rolled out of my Head, I had wasted like half an hour of my Life watching this clearly Biased Video and it wasn't the only time I saw that kind of thing regarding NMixx and their "fans"

I don't know. Nmixx are talented so they would prolly pull their songs well. But I really loved Ive's vibe in Love Dive so idk if Nmixx would give me the same vibe.

Quote from SleepingGiant

Nmixx stans are obnoxious enough without a strong discography

I saw a Video on youtube that claimed to objectively rank all 4th gen Vocalists and they had the Top 3 all NMixx members or maybe it was 3 of the Top 4 or something stupid like that

Either way my Eyes nearly rolled out of my Head, I had wasted like half an hour of my Life watching this clearly Biased Video and it wasn't the only time I saw that kind of thing regarding NMixx and their "fans"

And here I was thinking that most Nswers aren’t considered to be that bad. At least it was biased, but not toxic, it could be worse. Anyway, out of curiosity, do you have the link to the video? You piqued my interest and I want to check it out now and see why they say that and see how much sense they’re making.

Quote from icyruios

Ok maybe I'll rephrase a bit. Let's say NMIXX got IVE's songs, in that alternate reality would they be more successful than in our existing reality where IVE exists with IVE songs?

Coz you said if Wonyoung and Yujin are not in a group so I wanna rephrase a bit

I think maybe, but just barely, not by a HUGE amount or anything super crazy.

Everyone would say they are the 4th gen leader instead of denying because "its not clear enough" and downplaying them because of "kakao and izone" like it happens to Ive.

Quote from icyruios

Title as stated.

Would Eleven be able to chart well of not better if NMIXX released it?

Would Love Dive be as big if they comeback with it in a few weeks time?

Will NMIXX get a chance to earn their ROTY that every JYPE girl group managed to get?

Display More

Yeah they'd mostly have the same charting, with the exception of Love Dive's late boom, otherwise which it would be around tomboy level right now.

LD was dropping till the baseball appearance by Wonyoung, which gave it a bit of a 2nd life and boosted it a bit, but apart from that, basically same charting.

No Nmixx fits energetic better than elegant concept

Quote from YouChanDoThis

And here I was thinking that most Nswers aren’t considered to be that bad. At least it was biased, but not toxic, it could be worse. Anyway, out of curiosity, do you have the link to the video? You piqued my interest and I want to check it out now and see why they say that and see how much sense they’re making.

That was around a week ago I got no chance of finding it now

But I did a quick youtube search and found one very similar, it is not the same one I watched but the Top 2 are NMixx and looks like they included 4 NMixx members in the list or something like that (I haven't watched this one just skipped through and it looks very similar to me with them using all that "Music speak" stuff to pretend they aren't biased)

and as I was just quickly checking I noticed they had Bora of Cherry Bullet near the bottom of their rankings, I am on a completely different wave length to these people couldn't care less about their #A4 Registrars Bb4's or DD's nuts or whatever else they were talking about there is just no way Bora is one of the weaker Vocalists of 4th Gen

Ofc they would

Nmixx doesn't have an It Girl that Koreans will fall for. Throw Wonyoung into NMIXX and they'd be charting #1 with 0.0. But right now, they just dont have anyone that grabs your attention.

Quote from SleepingGiant

That was around a week ago I got no chance of finding it now

But I did a quick youtube search and found one very similar, it is not the same one I watched but the Top 2 are NMixx and looks like they included 4 NMixx members in the list or something like that (I haven't watched this one just skipped through and it looks very similar to me with them using all that "Music speak" stuff to pretend they aren't biased)

External Content www.youtube.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

and as I was just quickly checking I noticed they had Bora of Cherry Bullet near the bottom of their rankings, I am on a completely different wave length to these people couldn't care less about their #A4 Registrars Bb4's or DD's nuts or whatever else they were talking about there is just no way Bora is one of the weaker Vocalists of 4th Gen

Display More

This video will work as well, no worries! Thank you! I’ll give it a watch and see what I think.

Quote from BlackpinkHouse

Nmixx doesn't have an It Girl that Koreans will fall for. Throw Wonyoung into NMIXX and they'd be charting #1 with 0.0. But right now, they just dont have anyone that grabs your attention.

Sullyoon went viral for her visuals

I'd love to hear Nmixx sing After Like or Eleven

Is that necessary?

Quote from icyruios

Would Eleven be able to chart well of not better if NMIXX released it?

yes. jyp stan is quite numerous

Quote from icyruios

Would Love Dive be as big if they comeback with it in a few weeks time?

idk, since wonyoung part's in the chorus is perfect. It used her charisma to emphasied that self-loved feeling.

also LD could be big because of several other reason that maybe not achieved or be achieved but with different situation with nmixx

Quote from icyruios

Will NMIXX get a chance to earn their ROTY that every JYPE girl group managed to get?

Yes, the only flaw that they had is the jpye itself.

Quote from catzi

Everyone would say they are the 4th gen leader instead of denying because "its not clear enough" and downplaying them because of "kakao and izone" like it happens to Ive.

say the truth!

Is that necessary?

Quote from Disevidence

Yeah they'd mostly have the same charting, with the exception of Love Dive's late boom, otherwise which it would be around tomboy level right now.

LD was dropping till the baseball appearance by Wonyoung, which gave it a bit of a 2nd life and boosted it a bit, but apart from that, basically same charting.

It wasn’t only the baseball event

It was the baseball event+Yujin‘s variety show+Dream Concert

Quote from SleepingGiant

That was around a week ago I got no chance of finding it now

But I did a quick youtube search and found one very similar, it is not the same one I watched but the Top 2 are NMixx and looks like they included 4 NMixx members in the list or something like that (I haven't watched this one just skipped through and it looks very similar to me with them using all that "Music speak" stuff to pretend they aren't biased)

External Content www.youtube.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

and as I was just quickly checking I noticed they had Bora of Cherry Bullet near the bottom of their rankings, I am on a completely different wave length to these people couldn't care less about their #A4 Registrars Bb4's or DD's nuts or whatever else they were talking about there is just no way Bora is one of the weaker Vocalists of 4th Gen

Display More

Okay, this video is incredibly biased, or at least it seems like that to me. I can see why you’d be annoyed. No offense, Nmixx are great vocalists, but putting two of them in a tier by themselves with no one else is very biased and doesn’t sit right with me . Also, I don’t understand a lot a lot of the technical stuff, but some of it makes no sense at all. “Bad mouth shape”? Excuse you? What does that matter? Also, I kid you not, I forget where, but at one point, they put the exact same thing for both a positive and a negative for an idol. Like, make up your mind, is it good or not?

ive rock everything hit by hit(they fit elegance like they re all elegant dancers)

I dont think nmixx can did that since they re stronger dancers and singer [they fit well in mamamoo concept ver teenager]

Starship is suck ,wonyoung have great taste For the music

I don't think nmixx suits that's young love image

I actually like their strong image and just hope they get better songs that suits it

if they had the abilities and skills

They do lack a wonyoung for itgirl factor

All I know is that IVE would have flopped with 0.0.

The only group that could have saved 0.0 is Black Pink, their fans would have called it the greats song of all time and it would have broken all kinds of records.

But who knows, maybe even BP would not have been able to save that song.

Quote from BEG4DAWIN

All I know is that IVE would have flopped with 0.0.

The only group that could have saved 0.0 is Black Pink, their fans would have called it the greats song of all time and it would have broken all kinds of records.

But who knows, maybe even BP would not have been able to save that song.

Display More

O.O is a pure blackhole

More successful i doubt. As successful most probably.

Also i don't understand why people think a it girl is so important for charts? Especially for a big3 gg.

It is diffocult to imagine because nmixx image is more girl crush. I think nmixx will chart well but not as good charting or sales like ive because ive has wonyoung and izone fans

nah wonyoung and yujin to an extent played a part in their success in general. ive members also fit the ive concept well especially wonyoung.

if nmixx had ive's discog, the songs would still chart high but not like ive's charting.

Eleven will smash, but not sure about the longevity.

For Love Dive, a big maybe. Again, it might smash but also not sure with the longevity and virality.

For After Like, might do the same as it's doing now or much better.

In the international climate, all will be smashing big time outright; including the sales.

Quote from kpopace26

Eleven will smash, but not sure about the longevity.

For Love Dive, a big maybe. Again, it might smash but also not sure with the longevity and virality.

For After Like, might do the same as it's doing now or much better.

In the international climate, all will be smashing big time outright; including the sales.

Display More

Eleven Longest charting debut group GG song broke the record of 2ne1 Still Chart in top 20 & 30 all chart

love dive for 20 weeks in top 10

what does longevity mean to you?

Quote from Jabiral

Eleven Longest charting debut group GG song broke the record of 2ne1 Still Chart in top 20 & 30 all chart

love dive for 20 weeks in top 10

what does longevity mean to you?

What I meant is I'm not sure if the longevity will be the same if the three will be NMIXX's songs.