KBS Gayo List of Idols who actually sing Live

People often target aespa or Sm artists because they are known for having good vocals it’s a shame aespa can’t showcase their talent.

Lipsync is okay but aespa really got no freedom they can’t even post covers or they have the same prerecorded audio.

I want miss singsing to show how it’s done

So this is not confirmed, just your own analysis/assumption?

Quote from killthisfenty

People often target aespa or Sm artists because they are known for having good vocals it’s a shame aespa can’t showcase their talent.

Lipsync is okay but aespa really got no freedom they can’t even post covers or have the same prerecorded audio.

I want miss singsing to show how it’s done

this is so dumb bc they rlly can sing live

when all idols sang together Winter was so loud you could hear her in a sea of idols

Quote from godkingteshub

So this is not confirmed, just your own analysis/assumption?

Yeah I don't trust what's basically guesses

STAYC live queens!

the cue sheet showed svt sang MR, and i could hear their voices pretty clearly, idk how loud the backtrack was though

Tbh I don't think you need to have golden ears to hear that most of them were pre-recorded vocals.With some groups you could even hear them barely sing over it because the backing track is so loud.

Quote from KangK

Yes, and how do you officially confirm this?

sometimes people leak a sheet that has the audio set up for each performance. also doing MR Removed if someone knows how to do it

The Boyz did Candles live cause I could hear the raw voices..

but tbh these days you can never be sure.. everyone is singing over loud backtracks only.. no one is actually enough live to be considered live..

Quote from KangK

Lol. I'll let chounim handle this one. He/She has already went over this. And Mr Removed is not accurate.

from what i could tell, it gets it right more than it gets it wrong

I saw tweets with cue sheet s so you can confirm from there who sang live

svt and txt backtrack was not really loud for me

Heard their voices pretty clear

I think stayC had medium loud backtrack , same level with oh my girl

tbz slow song was probably live

Stray Kids sang live it was the most obvious among every group I saw lmao

if yall need a cue sheet to determine what live vocals are you either 1. need ya ears checked or 2. stop huffing copium that your favs dont sing live

Quote from keaji

Kaikat I don't think it was live tbh, it was a bit too smooth and to me it didn't seem like vocals and movements aligned. (it doesn't matter if you hear their raw vocals, those can be prerecorded)

But they surely can sing like that live, I just wish they would heh..

yep prerecording is a possibility for sure.. but then again we wouldn't know..

I am honestly a little sick of this new trend of loud backtracks kpop artists do these days.. either sing live significantly or just lipsync if not in condition.. but well thats how things will be from now on and we can't help it ig

evcen artists who used to sing live so well years ago and using loud backtracks these days smh its kinda sad to see..

Stray Kids was clearly live. You could hear their vocals very live with rap line or doubled, because of backtrack.

not one person sang completely live from the performances ive watched anyway

Quote from KangK

You think this is live?

External Content youtu.be

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

That does sound live in most parts but maybe im just fooled from all the pre recording tricks idols use nowadays

Quote from Minazuki

Stray Kids was clearly live. You could hear their vocals very live with rap line or doubled, because of backtrack.

It's more like Live Recorded. There's multiple camera takes, so it can't be truly live. But I don't know how they actually record the sound in these scenarios.

Quote from omnimorphism

It's more like Live Recorded. There's multiple camera takes, so it can't be truly live. But it also isn't the studio version. It's hard to categorize.

But I don't know how they record the sound in these scenarios.

I'd say they're live during the recording, It's visible for me, but KBS probably cleaned the audio, like when you sing live for Sketchbook and Immortal Songs, but you can't hear the imperfections.

Quote from Minazuki

I'd say they're live during the recording, It's visible for me, but KBS probably cleaned the audio, like when you sing live for Sketchbook and Immortal Songs, but you can't hear the imperfections.

The songs starts at daytime and ends at nighttime, so it wasn't recorded in a single take. There's also teleportation at some camera cuts.

The audio clearly isn't the studio version, but we don't know under what circumstances it was actually recorded.