Which girl group had best debut song

NJZ and it's not even close

The Attention/Hype Boy combo is the best opener to a K-Pop career we have literally ever seen.

Le Sserafim from these choices

Overall it's Blackpink

Aespa

BABYMONSTER with their hit debut song 'Sheesh'

Quote from Taemin-Identity

Aespa

Quote from Tru-Multistan

BABYMONSTER with their hit debut song 'Sheesh'

Both of these responses trigger me so much

Aespa

does best mean most successful?

or does best mean best subjectively from a personal preference?

Out of those choices? IVE Eleven or (G)I-DLE Latata

Outside of those choices?

newjeans

itzy

Latata is unbeatable!

New jeans by far.

I voted for IVE simply because I personally preferred the song over NJZ. But I agree that success wise, NJZ takes the cake.

from list, NJ

Overall my fav Izone

New Jeans for me too.

Quote from dsc

from list, NJ

Overall my fav Izone

External Content youtu.be

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

My thoughts exactly.

Can someone post the links to them?

Out of these: (G)I-DLE

Overall: Blackpink

Babymonster and it's not even close

Quote from Jasque-O-Part2

Babymonster and it's not even close

You unironically think Batter Up is a good song?

My top 3 in poll:

1. Latata

2. Attention

3. Magnetic

Quote from Yama-Chan

You unironically think Batter Up is a good song?

Ofc

Quote from Jasque-O-Part2

Ofc

I'm so sorry

Quote from Yama-Chan

You unironically think Batter Up is a good song?

pre-debut release

Ive and its not even close.

Ugh.

I didn't notice Gidle until I had already voted for Babymonster.

Now I want to vote for gidle instead but I can't.

I can't choose, but the 3 superior to me are Black Mamba, Attention and Magnetic.

Overall BP

NewJeans

ARTMS

If must choose from the list I would say Babymonster - Batter Up, even if it was not a great song, it at least was a bit of fun and good ending of the song.

It's not even close

Only ones I listen to from this list are Meow and Eleven.

I originally chose Eleven, but changed it to Meow since Meovv is being done dirty on this poll.

Edit: NVM, can't change it. Lesigh.

NewJeans Attention and Hype Boy shook up the whole industry. They made such an impact because they were so different from what we heard before AND were addictive hits at the same time. The other groups are 1)different but don't sound great (e.g. NMIXX, aespa), 2)not different but sound good (e.g. IVE, ILLIT), or 3)not different and don't sound great (Babymonster Sheesh and Meovv).

Don't hurt me this is just my opinion. I think most stans of these groups would agree the debut song is not the best and their bias group had to grow into their sound to make it big, like aespa and NMIXX. Meovv Toxic and Body were so much better than their debut, and I can see them releasing a banger soon. Aespa's releases for the last two years are experimental AND sound good (Whiplash, Supernova), and they're now easily one of my top groups.

Quote from jklsjlkh

NewJeans Attention and Hype Boy shook up the whole industry. They made such an impact because they were so different from what we heard before AND were addictive hits at the same time. The other groups are 1)different but don't sound great (e.g. NMIXX, aespa), 2)not different but sound good (e.g. IVE, ILLIT), or 3)not different and don't sound great (Babymonster Sheesh and Meovv).

Don't hurt me this is just my opinion. I think most stans of these groups would agree the debut song is not the best and their bias group had to grow into their sound to make it big, like aespa and NMIXX. Meovv Toxic and Body were so much better than their debut, and I can see them releasing a banger soon. Aespa's releases for the last two years are experimental AND sound good (Whiplash, Supernova), and they're now easily one of my top groups.

Are you saying Black Mamba isn't a great song?? Omg, it's literally still one of Aespa best songs!! and tbh I see the Aespa quality went up within the years, but this doesn't mean it was bad, since debut they had bangers...

Quote from monalisalove

Are you saying Black Mamba isn't a great song?? Omg, it's literally still one of Aespa best songs!! and tbh I see the Aespa quality went up within the years, but this doesn't mean it was bad, since debut they had bangers...

Honestly if I had to objectively rank aespa's songs:

SS-tier: Supernova, Whiplash, Spicy

S-tier: Drama, Armageddon

A-tier: Savage, Next Level, Illusion

B-tier: Better Things, Thirsty, Dreams Come True cover

C-tier: Black Mamba, Girls (subjectively I would put it in B-tier cause Ningning became my bias during this era <3)

D-tier: Forever cover

This is in context to the rest of kpop; aespa has higher quality songs across the board and amazing B-sides, which is why there's no F-tier. Black Mamba isn't awful or unoriginal but it's in the bottom compared to the rest of their discography.

Quote from jklsjlkh

Honestly if I had to objectively rank aespa's songs:

SS-tier: Supernova, Whiplash, Spicy

S-tier: Drama, Armageddon

A-tier: Savage, Next Level, Illusion

B-tier: Better Things, Thirsty, Dreams Come True cover

C-tier: Black Mamba, Girls (subjectively I would put it in B-tier cause Ningning became my bias during this era <3)

D-tier: Forever cover

This is in context to the rest of kpop; aespa has higher quality songs across the board and amazing B-sides, which is why there's no F-tier. Black Mamba isn't awful or unoriginal but it's in the bottom compared to the rest of their discography.

Display More

The hate

BM queen!!