Who are the most improved idols!!

Taemin and Giselle spring to mind

From my favs

Jisoo from BP

Shuhua from Gidle

Tzuyu from Twice

Sakura from LSFM

Lia from Itzy

Giselle from Aespa

Yeri from RV

Hina and magenta

Quote from StrawberryChaeng

Who remembers when Twice antis used to have a field day over Tzuyu's vocals and dancing, calling her a talentless visual.

Unfortunately they still do. The announcement of her solo album has really brought them crawling out of the woodwork in the usual places. Hopefully she can finally shut them up.

Quote from Suzakura

Hina and magenta

objectively the most correct answer

Shinee Taemin

RV Wendy

Snsd Sooyoung

NCT Jisung

Exo Suho, Xiumin and Kai

In terms of stage presence, Winter noticeably improved a ton.

Quote from Suzakura

Hina and magenta

Don't forget Chodan.

Tzuyu's improvement is really great to see and hear. Good for her.

i agree with Taemin.

I remember watched him in Hello MV back then and compare it with him now...wow..

Don't know why nobody not even onces mention her but Sana. She is just as good at singing as Tzuyu, if not better. Way better at dancing, MC-ing and as a songwriter.

Quote from vzal

Don't know why nobody not even onces mention her but Sana. She is just as good at singing as Tzuyu, if not better. Way better at dancing, MC-ing and as a songwriter.

Taemin is the only one that truly comes to my mind. Dahyun and Tzuyu to a lesser content.

i actually really liked tzuyus first solo performance. even though her singing isn't the best, i think she showed a lot of charm

Quote from vzal

Don't know why nobody not even onces mention her but Sana. She is just as good at singing as Tzuyu, if not better. Way better at dancing, MC-ing and as a songwriter.

I think because Sana was always recognised for her ayego, charm and variety skills so people always saw her as bringing something major to the group, she also was voted into the group not added by JYP like Tyuzu. Momo was the same but everyone recognised she was needed for her dance skills but people really looked down on Tyuzu for being added because shes pretty and from Taiwan (and considering all of Twice is pretty and the flag scandal some really think she was a filler member who didn't add anything to the group) so when they were all getting dragged for vocals and dance, to some extent Tyuzu had it worse because all people would defend her with is 'shes pretty' unlike the others where some skill or talent is always brought forward. Same reason why people didn't notice how much the others improved, people never really focused on their lack of skills in those areas because they were known to bring other things to the group. Tyuzu is more of a blank slate and her improvement in dancing is also more visible because she suffers from the Sunmi situation, long limbs and difficulty not looking awkward when dancing in a group.

But I have to say Sana really surprised me in Misamo, she really held it down as main vocal and I noticed she was taking some hard parts in Twice songs she'd never have gotten years ago. I'd also argue Jihyo, she really worked her butt off when it came to dancing and it really shows. Also Nayeon, she has that weak knee but despite the increased difficulty in choreo we haven't seen her struggle or fall over in years.

Quote from onwards

I think because Sana was always recognised for her ayego, charm and variety skills so people always saw her as bringing something major to the group, she also was voted into the group not added by JYP like Tyuzu. Momo was the same but everyone recognised she was needed for her dance skills but people really looked down on Tyuzu for being added because shes pretty and from Taiwan (and considering all of Twice is pretty and the flag scandal some really think she was a filler member who didn't add anything to the group) so when they were all getting dragged for vocals and dance, to some extent Tyuzu had it worse because all people would defend her with is 'shes pretty' unlike the others where some skill or talent is always brought forward. Same reason why people didn't notice how much the others improved, people never really focused on their lack of skills in those areas because they were known to bring other things to the group. Tyuzu is more of a blank slate and her improvement in dancing is also more visible because she suffers from the Sunmi situation, long limbs and difficulty not looking awkward when dancing in a group.

But I have to say Sana really surprised me in Misamo, she really held it down as main vocal and I noticed she was taking some hard parts in Twice songs she'd never have gotten years ago. I'd also argue Jihyo, she really worked her butt off when it came to dancing and it really shows. Also Nayeon, she has that weak knee but despite the increased difficulty in choreo we haven't seen her struggle or fall over in years.

Tzuyu was voted in by the fans. She was "added by JYP" in Sixteen, but that was a "reality" show. The sly bastard already knew what he was doing when he eliminated her & Momo.

Tzuyu is one of Twice's official lead dancers. People only think of her dancing as awkward because she has to go out of her way to "fit in" instead of just being allowed to do her thing like everyone else, which is totally unnecessary. They should've never made her height out to be an issue.