If Big Bang faded in to irrelevance what's to stop BTS from doing so?

True, and will soon start witnessing it

I mean yes and no. Will some fangirl leave yes, but they were not real fans. But look at the beetles (not saying BTS is a big as them). In the 60 a lot of women loved them for their looks. Now look at Paull McCarthy he still selling CD and selling out tours, so who to say that BTS will not. Not to mention a large percentage of their fans are men, and older women so you can say that its only about looks. The last thing I want to say is that if Big Bang raised a new CD t would probably still sell good. The issue is the members wanting to move on to different things.

bigbang buried themselves with their scandals. i don’t think bts is anywhere near as problematic and seem like good guys.

Quote from sparrow9

I mean yes and no. Will some fangirl leave yes, but they were not real fans. But look at the beetles (not saying BTS is a big as them). In the 60 a lot of women loved them for their looks. Now look at Paull McCarthy he still selling CD and selling out tours, so who to say that BTS will not. Not to mention a large percentage of their fans are men, and older women so you can say that its only about looks. The last thing I want to say is that if Big Bang raised a new CD t would probably still sell good. The issue is the members wanting to move on to different things.

Not you seriously entertaining Seulgiabs

Quote from Jasmine_Waters

Not you seriously entertaining Seulgiabs

What can I say I'm bored, and I felt bad that this was going to be a flop discussion.

HYBE is much better at the hush money than YG.

Good point. Once the fan girls have move over 30s they are no longer fan girls but women fans.

As long as they don't commit crimes, they're safe.

Quote from DaisyTheGenuine

BTS has visuals

Yes but even visuals fade with age.

Quote from thebadguy

True, and will soon start witnessing it

We are witnessing a slight decline on BTS popularity but only very slight. I say it would still take quite some time. When Jin finished his military training and re-united with the rest of the members you see still 572K likes and 3.7 million views in 3 weeks, and we are talking about millions of likes and over 30 million views if we talk about Tiktok and Instagram, twitter too.

Me

Quote from ISaidISaid

HYBE is much better at the hush money than YG.

They have been in the industry for 11 years. Rest

Quote from YukiBTS

We are witnessing a slight decline on BTS popularity but only very slight. I say it would still take quite some time. When Jin finished his military training and re-united with the rest of the members you see still 572K likes and 3.7 million views in 3 weeks, and we are talking about millions of likes and over 30 million views if we talk about Tiktok and Instagram, twitter too.

Its a given since they're in the military and they can only promote on social media. BTS is still getting 12 millions likes on instagram when the group took a photo together after many months and 1.5 million likes on twitter. ARMYs became more active as well after Jin got back.

1.5m likes, 822k reposts, and 180k quotes...

When Jin came back from military, all media outlets from my country were reporting about it. Even when they just simply took a group photo.

Me.

Quote from Kitty_Saurus

Its a given since they're in the military and they can only promote on social media. BTS is still getting 12 millions likes on instagram when the group took a photo together after many months and 1.5 million likes on twitter. ARMYs became more active as well after Jin got back.

External Content x.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

1.5m likes, 822k reposts, and 180k quotes...

When Jin came back from military, all media outlets from my country were reporting about it. Even when they just simply took a group photo.

That itself is evidence that their popularity is still massive. I think because they show us they are still a family that gets in touch with eachother so people are happy to see them together and trust them.

I remember being a 1D fan and everytime I see people talk about 1D reunion I get fed up with their lies. They been talking a reunion since 2018 and even the latest talk about 1D reunion barely gets more than 5K likes and 60,000 views and thats in months. BTS did not take the path 1D which was lying about a reunion.

Quote from YukiBTS

That itself is evidence that their popularity is still massive. I think because they show us they are still a family that gets in touch with eachother so people are happy to see them together and trust them.

I remember being a 1D fan and everytime I see people talk about 1D reunion I get fed up with their lies. They been talking a reunion since 2018 and even the latest talk about 1D reunion barely gets more than 5K likes and 60,000 views and thats in months. BTS did not take the path 1D which was lying about a reunion.

As someone who used to love 1D and a Zayn stan, I already gave up on that reunion. Since BTS members are all signed in the same label, they'll most likely release music as group. Its annoying everytime they compare the hiatus of both groups.

Didn't we learn in American Horror Story that when a new Supreme rises, the old one fades away

earlier this month, the delulu antis were still crying aboit too many BTS threads

Thread

There should be a BTS mega thread or something like that, armys are just spamming the front page

forum.allkpop.com/suite/attachment/290185/
forum.allkpop.com/suite/attachment/290186/
forum.allkpop.com/suite/attachment/290187/
forum.allkpop.com/suite/attachment/290188/
forum.allkpop.com/suite/attachment/290189/


More than half of the front page (12/20) is covered by very similar bts threads being spammed by armys. Just make a mega thread or something instead

Edit:- now there are 14 bts threads on front page

thebadguy

Jun 12th 2024

Quote from ISaidISaid

HYBE is much better at the hush money than YG.

Not everyone is as problematic as your faves

Armys giving seulgisabs done to death thread topic another hit rerun

Maybe because they are on different levels of success and unless some fuck up things happen line seungri or diddy level bts can comfortably maintain a top spot worldwide for at least another decade, on kpop they are arguably still the biggest act even from hiatus so just get accustomed at them being #1 atp. Bigbang would still be big even today if seungri never happened.

Quote from Petrified

Not everyone is as problematic as your faves

They’re just men. That too famous ones. They’re guilty until proven innocent by default.

Quote from SeulgisAbs

Nothing. The answer is; not a damn thing.

Once you're thirty and over, fangirls will move on to the next pretty oppa regardless.

Even the biggest of music acts of all time like Michael Jackson, Whitney Houston, Mariah Carrey, etc lost or had their relevance decline at some point in their careers. When they couldn't sell out stadiums anymore, it affected them mentally etc. A decline always happens one way or another.

But bb last ever cmb did well, they may not exist anymore bc the group can't go on bc the seungri burning sun scandal

Musical acts go through decline but acting like being in 30s is gonna end their career is stupid. Also I dont get why people are acting like BTS is super old. JK is just the same age as Stray Kids BangChan..

More like op's referring to gg stans.

Quote from YukiBTS

Yes but even visuals fade with age.

Their music will carry on for a long time though.

Quote from SeulgisAbs

Once you're thirty and over, fangirls will move on to the next pretty oppa regardless.

then they are safe. Armys are in kindergarten, there's a lot of time left till we are 30 and over

As for bts jin and suga are already 30, jhope and rm are about to be thirty and they are fine. Armys has supported all of their recent releases.

Bigbang never faded into irrelevance though, did you see the ULs for their last comeback?

900k ffs lol. With zero promo, zero effort.

Bigbang self destructed.

BTS wont do that.

BangPDs actual gravy train will be back next year and will bring untold billions.

Quote from Kitty_Saurus

Its a given since they're in the military and they can only promote on social media. BTS is still getting 12 millions likes on instagram when the group took a photo together after many months and 1.5 million likes on twitter. ARMYs became more active as well after Jin got back.

External Content x.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

1.5m likes, 822k reposts, and 180k quotes...

When Jin came back from military, all media outlets from my country were reporting about it. Even when they just simply took a group photo.

This. Armys are not even experiencing true "hiatus" like no appearance, activity or music at all. Can you imagine if army's are starving? Lol

Quote from versatile

BTS is already not what they were. They haven't had a bit since butter. I think it will be the solo era. Justin Timberlake, Beyonce etc.

So charts are more important than money for one's success

After butter they released two english singles: permission to dance, that is used in collab with despicable me 4, we'll get bts minions toys;

and my universe with Coldplay that has almost 1.3 billion on Spotify (no idea how to check ptd numbers).

Yet to come and take two, both korean songs, are "we are closing this chapters, see you in chapter two" songs, take two doesn't even have mv. Not bad for the band that's not what they were.