where would you put FIFTY FIFTY on the current rank for 4th gen girl group ?

A Guess purely from my suspicion not backed by any data

IVE

NewJeans

Aespa

LeSserfim

ITZY

Kepler

NMIXX

StayC

FIFTY FIFTY <- HERE

Billlie

Weeekly

Woo!Ah!

Viviz

H1Key

Purple Kiss

Secret Number

Everglow

TRI.BE

TripleS

Lightsum

Rocket Punch

CLASS:y

Cherry Bullet

Limelight

CSR

ILY:1

Fanatics

Cignature

Irris

Ichillin

Pixy

Mimirose

Lapillus

Hot Issue

Rocking Doll

others I cannot think of right now

I wouldn't rank them till the next CB. And I think is pretty bold to put them next established groups like ITZY, I wouldn't say they are even Stayc for now.

Maybe if they can get into hot100 top10, koreans will start to pay attention on them out of pride, and it would make their career big. Int GP is just listening a good chill song, they hardly will be searching the next one and hyping the members, so I wouldn't say they're polular in the west, the song is. SK GP is the one who can hype them and really pay attention tothe members, like Brave Girls who success seemed bigger because they had lots of gigs.

let's wait for their next comeback before judging. The song went viral but at this point they're just one-hit wonder. We are not sure about stickiness of listeners

Tier nugu

One thing for sure is that their records will be hard to break for the 4th gen. So that says something.

Their next comeback is a pitchfork for them, either they continue to be successful globally or nugudom again.

The way I see it, if their company is smart, they can sustain a NJ level globally, they captured their niche, they found a sound surely ALOT like, so really smart strategic moves and they will stay on the map. Dumb moves will move them back to Stay C/Weeekly level globally, their niche is there but not enough.

Depends on if they end up being a one-hit-wonder or not. So I reserve judgment until that is clear.

The group so far is giving pure one hit wonder vibes.

Let’s discuss this later after their 2nd comeback

They still have to be able to compete with the top10 in sales and kcharts, so far they are still far from reaching that.

Quote from Cashmere-Rose

One thing for sure is that their records will be hard to break for the 4th gen. So that says something.

Their next comeback is a pitchfork for them, either they continue to be successful globally or nugudom again.

The way I see it, if their company is smart, they can sustain a NJ level globally, they captured their niche, they found a sound surely ALOT like, so really smart strategic moves and they will stay on the map. Dumb moves will move them back to Stay C/Weeekly level globally, their niche is there but not enough.

Yesss, if their sound happens to appeal to locals again, they can build a solid career. But that's very tricky, considering how it happened to Exid and Momoland.

Quote from BlackpinkHouse

Are you saying Fifty doesnt deserve to be next to Itzy? Or that they deserve to be above Itzy?

I put them on the same tier as Itzy but there are distinctions within tiers. Like at the top, it's Ive, then NJ, then Idle.

No, youre buts because you are putting them on the same tier. 50-50 is a one hit wonder. It's like when people started putting iKon as the third biggest Boygroup after Love Scenario, only to be disappointed about how, just one year later, they were still stucked as 70k albums and releasing a song that could not outchart Love Scenario on its 50th week

Quote from Michael-6

Tier 1 = Ive, NJ

Tier 2 = Idle, Itzy, LSRFM, Aespa,

Tier 3 = NMIXX,, Fifty Fifty, STAYC

Tier 4 = Triple S
Tier 5 - Alice

Alice is a Third Generation group, having debuted in 2017.