WHICH MEMBER LEAVING YOUR FAVE GROUP WOULD BE THE MOST DISASTROUS?

wonyoung leaving ive

Remove one member from BP & they won't be able to continue anymore

So literally any member leaving will effectively end the group

oh yeonjun for sure his stage presence is something else

anyone in bts imo maybe i'll give maknae line a small egde

not sure about my other faves

Probably Jungkook.

Quote from dryheat

Agree on Yeonjun

Hmmm... for BTS I think RM is the core so I'd go with him.

my first pick was RM but when i think of their chemistry they all play an important role

with regard to artistry def RM

also if the most popular bts members left it'd impact their overall popularity ig

damn it's complicated with bts

JHOPE OF BTS. He is the true definition of All Rounder. He does everything to perfection in BTS.

marked safe because that trend only happens to 4th gen groups

Hanni Pham leaving NewJeans would be disastrous for them. She gives that group that swag and signature vocal.

Quote from dryheat

As a non fan I only know the names/face of two members and she is not one of them

This ^ is the type of fucking stupidity I've been referring to here.

Any member of BTS. Their ot7 image and bond is also a big factor for their branding and image.

People expect BTS to change the status quo among boybands globally where a group has stuck together through everything

Quote from Afriyieau1

Any member of BTS. Their ot7 image and bond is also a big factor for their branding and image.

People expect BTS to change the status quo among boybands globally where a group has stuck together through everything

Let's be honest, you guys can do without V.

I honestly think Jihyo...

Jeongyeon would be a good leader but I think that when it comes to leadership, no one can really replace Jihyo.

She's an amazing leader and I feel like her leaving would be harder for everyone.

I better stop talking before I go into forbidden territory

Quote from burgerfling

Hanni Pham leaving NewJeans would be disastrous for them. She gives that group that swag and signature vocal.

Hanni is so talented and one of the main reasons why she's currently my favorite member!

I also think it's interesting how she's one of the few Vietnamese idols in the industry

RM is the pillar of BTS, Bang PD even made the group around him. But of course all 7 is important with their own individual strengths that give the most amazing synergy when together

If Jun leaves than A.C.E is dead, he is their leader

Bang Chan

RM

Baekhyun

Ryujin

Hanni. But I think NewJeans is very balanced in terms of importance in roles so far, so It might be debatable.

For BP any member would be disastrous. I don't think they'd continue as 3.

probably

At this stage, I think any of BTS leaving would be pretty disastrous. A huge reason for the main success is their synergy as a seven.

BUT, I will say that I think the absence of Namjoon or Jungkook would not be easily recoverable from. I don’t think the group would have become what they are without Namjoon’s particular cultural/artistic perspective. Also Jungkook gave them a stability and softer edge with the quality of his vocals and opened them up to different possibilities musically.

Lack of Hobi would have made things spin very differently too. You can see the relief that they all felt when he came back to rehearse with them for the Grammys after quarantine.

BTS have been around for almost a decade. They've always been 7. Anything less than 7 is no longer BTS.

1.jpeg

Most probably Jungkook.

All of them

For (G)I-DLE, it's definitely Soyeon. She's so heavily involved in the creation of their music that (G)I-DLE would not sound the same without her.

The other girls can and do make awesome songs (like Minnie's involvement on Change), but Soyeon touches every song these days. Her absence would change the entire group.

Quote from dryheat

people saying all don't know how to read...

I said MOST disastrous

That's how it always goes, lol. I've been around in kpop long enough that the "the group could not function without ALL of them" is funny to me. I've heard that about SNSD, Big Bang, Super Junior, EXO, Wonder Girls, 2PM, etc. And we see how that went.

It's just a fact that most groups get their sound from either an outside producer or a core member or two who drives the direction and/or sound of the group.

Like, FT Island is my first group I stanned, but being 100% honest, Hongki is the core of the group; his vocals are so unique that FTI would not be FTI without him. He's not my favorite member, but FTI can (and did) weather Seunghyun leaving. Hell, Bol4 was a duo and still weathered one of the members leaving.

I'd say Jungkook

Siyeon?

Quote from Jichu

Siyeon?

Who? who's that?