Lip-syncing deceives people" China to ban celebrities lip sync" + knetz react

Wow

ah yes the country no one can promote in anyways, such is a loss for kpop

Lmao

Lmao. Looking at these comments. They really are malicious people who tries to drag popular people so they'll feel better with their loser life

Damn, china, you've been on the roll lately! Are they really going to do it?

A nod to the person who knows what LAR is

Wow. OK. Good luck to Chinese idols

Gosh I need coffee

Has any top kpop groups ever perform in China?

Quote from Marmaladeheart

So the idols are supposed to dance difficult choreographies, not breathe loudly into the microphone, not sweat at all and perfectly sing their songs?

Some people have too many demands.

*flashbacks to when bts got attacked for audibly breathing while singing live* yeah the expectations are...a lot

760939436287459348.png

Y’all really think y’all favs don’t lip-sync ? Lmaooo€:&:&€:

Quote from Armedryu

Has any top kpop groups ever perform in China?

Not that many 3rd-4th bc the ban happened when 3rd gen was just really getting started

Gotta say, that's one way to stop oversaturation...

Quote from penguinsgg

ah yes the country no one can promote in anyways, such is a loss for kpop

Yeah, especially for Lee Sooman!

Remember, "China is the future"

Yeah. People who doesn't sing live are so bad. There should be a law regarding this.

Quote from Marmaladeheart

So the idols are supposed to dance difficult choreographies, not breathe loudly into the microphone, not sweat at all and perfectly sing their songs?

Some people have too many demands.

Read comments on youtube, twitter, here too, people really do believe that it's possible to sing whole songs and sound perfect while doing hard choreos. If idols sing live they still need a backtrack to cover the parts they aren't able to sing because it's humanly impossible. Total playback is obvious even tho fans refuse it to acknowledge it. but what makes everything confusing and is deceiving fans is LAR and "it's live, you can hear them breathing". Kpop companies did their job well

Those 256 downvotes on that comment are well deserved

Quote from doesitneedsaying

Read comments on youtube, twitter, here too, people really do believe that it's possible to sing whole songs and sound perfect while doing hard choreos. If idols sing live they still need a backtrack to cover the parts they aren't able to sing because it's humanly impossible. Total playback is obvious even tho fans refuse it to acknowledge it. but what makes everything confusing and is deceiving fans is LAR and "it's live, you can hear them breathing". Kpop companies did their job well

but kpop groups used to sing live just fine, with a backtrack sure but you could still hear their live singing very clearly. It's just that now there is 1- an obsession with the illusion of perfection, that's why LAR was introduced to begin with, and 2- too much emphasis on difficult choreography. kpop groups are (supposed to be) singing groups primarly, the main focus should be on singing while choreographies should imo be just an accompaniment to help sell the songs (that's why most of the time viral hits are ones that have easy to follow catchy choroes like Sorry Sorry, Gee, Nobody, Cheer up, TT, Gangnam Style) but nowadays kpop groups, especially BGs, are looking more and more like dance crews and choreographies became a hindrance to the singing instead of complimenting it.

I think some people in this thread are getting confused. The only reason people expect perfect vocals with no breathing in live vocals is because of how obsessed kpop has become with using backtracks and pre recorded vocals which some fans don't realise aren't live (MY who think aespa sing live on music shows). If these kpop companies didn't make their groups lip sync in the first place then there wouldn't even be a problem.

Quote from icyruios

For real. Last time even if you sound like a dead donkey, you still need to sound like a dead donkey with a half ass backtrack because that backtrack won't be loud enough to save you.

Nowadays, you can belt the entire fking song and the backtrack is still louder than you

And fans nowadays have ridiculous standards because of the false image LAR sells, they expect everyone to sound like the CD with the casual breathing here and there just because that is how LAR performances sound like and they think those are live lol. So now, they drag idols for showing the smallest sign of shakiness when singing TRULY live.

i remember when this performance happened

they got dragged by delusional kpop stan twitter who probably have never heard their faves sing truly live and LAR misled them into thinking their faves can hold a candle to Super Junior's live skills

Quote from chounim

And fans nowadays have ridiculous standards because of the false image LAR sells, they expect everyone to sound like the CD with the casual breathing here and there just because that is how LAR performances sound like and they think those are live lol. So now, they drag idols for showing the smallest sign of shakiness when singing TRULY live.

i remember when this performance happened

External Content www.youtube.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

they got dragged by delusional kpop stan twitter who probably have never heard their faves sing truly live and LAR misled them into thinking their faves can hold a candle to Super Junior's live skills

Display More

wow did heechul car accident effect him that badly? he left midway

Quote from ohpuhlease

Hul China bans lip-syncing

I think we should do this too

original post: pann

1. [+286, -98] Seriously SM.. Don’t TVXQ, BoA, Super Junior, EXO, and Red Velvet all sing live well? But I don’t think I’ve ever watched their live performance

2. [+155, -43] Looking at the singer list of year-end concert, only BTS, TXT, BTOB, iKON, WINNER, GFriend, Mamamoo, BLACKPINK and trot singers sing live. It’s a fact that only Mamamoo, BTOB, groups of HYBE and YG sing live

3. [+150, -256] Only HYBE and YG will survive

4. [+41, -0] I think all handsome idols will be ruined if Korea bans lip syncing

5. [+39, -10] Wow, to be honest, I think Korea should ban lip syncing. Live AR is really fooling viewersㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

Display More

BTS don’t even need China

Hybe groups? Only BTS sings live and live well.

Bruh HYBE artists lipsync the most........

Quote from kidsgonestray

Stray Kids would be safe as hell. Their sing live on every music show and end of year performance.

yeah people need to talk about it more

funnily enough they were also on the sheet that was referenced in the op post but the commenter just ignored them to fit the agenda lol

There would be at least someone that will bash TWICE.

And they haven't looked at TWICE's concert and Japanese performances.

Some people misunderstand what it means to sing live. No one expects top tier vocal performance when you are live compared to in the studio.

But it’s the way some of these idols even lip sync during ballads