Now that Korean Produce saga finally ended who do you think was the most impactful/successful?

Wanna One

Imapact - ioi and wanna one

Success - wanna one

Wanna one had the album sales and hits.

x1 they got their 15 minutes of fame with that rigging scandal

but in all seriousness, w1. i think ioi could of been as big or bigger than izone if they got the same contract time

Well, izone were around for much more time than any other produce group so they had more time to make many achievements and break many records, gain a lot of success so I'd say izone. If x1 didn't disband right after debuting I'm pretty sure now everyone would have been saying their name

wanna one i think

but it should be interesting to compare the sales and charting of all four groups

IZ*ONE definitely, but if X1 was still around, they probably would have had the biggest impact overall on the Produce groups.

But in a way, all the Produce groups brought some impact

Most impactful - Wanna One

Most successful - Iz*one (for GGs standard)

Impactful - IOI

Successful - Wanna One

if IOI wasn't such a hit, then the other seasons would never have happened.

most succesful izone

There re weird ioi fans dislike izone and being delulu...lucky i know great ioi stan( i remember of hate of lineup izone and they has jump on them in 2018)smh izone is perfect lineup

IZ*ONE have 2 millions for gg in 2,5 years with ioi has short time without true bond chemistry like izone ....but ioi is the first produce group

#izone isn't great production music cause their company is trash so the girls deserve better like world tour and last song

I only remember Daniel Kang's name.

Wanna One by a large margin. Easily the biggest. Forbes writing for clicks.

Wanna One, period.

who do you think?

20201203_004608.jpg

20200506_144533.jpg

20201203_003247.jpg

W1 >> IOI >> Izone >> X1

Wanna One easily, their songs were the biggest hits and they sold the most despite lasting less time than IZ*ONE. IOI gets credit too for being so massive domestically and for kick-starting the whole phenomenon.

Quote from redcurtain

Wanna One easily, their songs were the biggest hits and they sold the most despite lasting less time than IZ*ONE. IOI gets credit too for being so massive domestically and for kick-starting the whole phenomenon.

Wanna one is boy group

Thing

#izone is girl group

There re difference

Quote from izoniee

Wanna one is boy group

Thing

#izone is girl group

There re difference

boy groups don't have an edge when it comes to digitals tho (quite the opposite), and their songs did much better in the charts than IZ*ONE's did.

Quote from redcurtain

boy groups don't have an edge when it comes to digitals tho (quite the opposite), and their songs did much better in the charts than IZ*ONE's did.

Izone songs is bad im wizone i know

I hate producer and compositer

Quote from redcurtain

boy groups don't have an edge when it comes to digitals tho (quite the opposite), and their songs did much better in the charts than IZ*ONE's did.

its because izones music was noise like nct

Quote from redcurtain

Wanna One easily, their songs were the biggest hits and they sold the most despite lasting less time than IZ*ONE. IOI gets credit too for being so massive domestically and for kick-starting the whole phenomenon.

Agree IOI gets credit too for their first impact

Wannaone.

They competed with top boy groups in both digitals and albums.

wanna one without a doubt

Quote from willybilly

I mean you still have to give some credit to Izone, they set the new standart for GG' album sales.... after izone's numbers went up like crazy other top GGs followed

Not really. Twice and bp were selling more than izone before disbabdment scare. They pulled those numbers as solo stans opened their wallets out of fear.

Quote from izoniee

most succesful izone

There re weird ioi fans dislike izone and being delulu...lucky i know great ioi stan( i remember of hate of lineup izone and they has jump on them in 2018)smh izone is perfect lineup

IZ*ONE have 2 millions for gg in 2,5 years with ioi has short time without true bond chemistry like izone ....but ioi is the first produce group

#izone isn't great production music cause their company is trash so the girls deserve better like world tour and last song

Omg are you that one name123 on the forums? You type just like her. You CAN use a single “.” you know that right? You don’t have to “…” after everything . It makes it hard to read and it comes off as confusing and condescending

Quote from willybilly

I mean you still have to give some credit to Izone, they set the new standart for GG' album sales.... after izone's numbers went up like crazy other top GGs followed

They did, but it's also because of the Japanese fandom.

I just feel wannaone had more impact since they threatened existing top groups and excelled in all areas.

Wanna One most successful, their album sales were only behind EXO and BTS back then, right?

Izone most impactful though, literally the biggest GG outside of Twice and BP.

Most impactful: IOI

Most successful: W1

W1 likely generated the most revenue, but IOI certainly received the most love from the GP by the end of their run and their individual member impact was far greater in terms of general public relevance than the others. On top of that, they basically set the template for the whole franchise and groups.

iz*one >>>>

Izone because I’m biased. But it’s not fair to compare the boy groups to the ggs so for produce bgs its W1. For the ggs it’s Izone.

Wanna One had the most success. They easily generated the most revenue, had the IT boy in Kang Daniel, album sales, and the absolute enormous fanbase.

IOI easily had the most impact. They were the sensation, Pick Me was known by everyone, the PAKs in Veryx3 and Downpour. They also guested on every show on the planet, breaking ratings record. On top of that, they had the most GP support and relevance of each individual member out of the Produce Groups.

Each one of them were successful but for most impactful i would say ioi

wanna one by far

Quote from Anon813

They did, but it's also because of the Japanese fandom.

I just feel wannaone had more impact since they threatened existing top groups and excelled in all areas.

You re stupid im.sorry...you re not fan of izone

This is china and korea

Do you know the kwizone used 3 millions won for relaunch of izone members on futur company after their disband.

They re hella Rich korean wizones

There re Many k-YouTubers buy 100 albums for each izone comeback

The japanese buy only their jp albums and hi-touch

We know their power

Quote from quantumphysics

Wanna One

No doubt

Quote from willybilly

From what i see ioi was strong in digital they had PAK before also the members are incredibly popular within GP. W1 were strong in both physical (700k average) and digital (all kill chart) also popularity within GP with bunch of cfs. Now i can't say anything about x1 since they disbanded early but they were strong in physical also youtube view i think? While izone's digital is great, their physical even beat twice at some point. So what do you think?

that's what i thought so

it would be wanna one

izone

ioi

w1 then in that order

based purely on sales and charting and cfs

the advantage of the first two groups is that they had more time to establish themselves comapred to say ioi

now if ioi or even w1 had greater time to establish themselves then maybe the rankings might have changed

Quote from atropos

Not really. Twice and bp were selling more than izone before disbabdment scare. They pulled those numbers as solo stans opened their wallets out of fear.

Quote from Anon813

They did, but it's also because of the Japanese fandom.

I just feel wannaone had more impact since they threatened existing top groups and excelled in all areas.

Doesn't matter what caused it, they still created a boom in the gg physical market.

Before that Twice was on top alone with no competition.