Why the big 3 ggs failed to outsell (G)I-DLE?

I think it's because after big 3 and bighit cube's the biggest company and (g)i-dle makes good music

Idle fans getting brave now huh

aespa still haven't released an album yet. let's talk after their first album sales

Are you setting (G)I-dle up?

Itzy sold the same as (G)I-dle.

Aespa didn't release an album yet.

YGNGG didn't even debut.

Nope. Itzy leads 4th gen girl groups by far

What YGNGG hasn't even debuted yet wtf. Look, I love (G)I-dle and I'm so happy they're doing well but lets not get cocky and respect other group's achievements, ok?

til wannabe flopped

despite being rookies, aespa already outsold them in China digitally. check your facts hun

Thread

Aespa is the biggest 4th gen Group in China !!!!

Knowing that they did this with their debut
aespa already seems to be the 4th group who will dominate china

and Chinese are the biggest buyers in term of physicals and are very loyal fan
i can't wait to see how their popularity in China will impact their Physicals

twitter.com/aespachartsdata/status/1361622924218793985

SooYoung

Feb 16th 2021

Quote from idleaccess123

Good luck with those sales you speak of

Thanks hun. Our physicals are already secured

Thread

Aespa Chinese fandom is SCARY !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

they paid 40K yuan to avoid that the second batch of gifts for Karina birthday is delayed

40K yan = 6K dollar

and it's just for the delivery which means it doesn't count all the money they put to buy Karina her gifts

here is the price of the first batch of gifts
and there's a second one who's coming , and this is just what's KarinaBar can do

twitter.com/aespastyles/status/1381184934803501057

and they also paid for the most expensive screen for Karina birthday ads …

SooYoung

Apr 11th 2021

Quote from glowello

What YGNGG hasn't even debuted yet wtf. Look, I love (G)I-dle and I'm so happy they're doing well but lets not get cocky and respect other group's achievements, ok?

I agree with this.

Plus let’s mention that while G-Idle is my fav gg at the moment they are currently laying low. The stuff with Soojin was bad and I’m just worried about they next comeback.

Edited cuz my phone is as stupid as it’s owner 😂

Okay

Quote from idleaccess123

YG's new gg: they haven't debuted yet and already FLOPPED.

plssss 💀💀

plot twist: bighit buys cube

but weeekly never flopped so thats fine if everyone else does

I was gonna bring up IZONE, then i realized they're technically not Big 3. But then i thought, shouldnt an MNET group be counted like a Big 3? Produce groups sell like Big 3 groups (W1, X1, and Izone sales were insane).

acepa  @Artemosia don't feed the troll besties OP wants us to drag idle and start fanwars

After Soojins scandal does Gidle even have a career anymore? Their reputation in Korea has tanked resulting in Hwaa dropping out of Melon top 100 faster than any of their previous releases. I’d worry about your favs than other 4th Gen GG’s because I can assure you they’re doing just fine.

I am 200% sure not shy sold more than anything gidle ever did. Why u setting them up? Lol

wow it's been a long time since i saw the sparks of a fanwar happening...

#soojinbestgirl

Yikes, why can’t people just make normal threads? I really don’t see how this can be entertaining. It’s annoying if you ask me.

why are people obsessed with outselling other ppl's faves?

anyway, gidle is my number 1 group, but I'm finding it really snobbish of you to be saying that gidle is outselling aespa and itzy when they're in the most jeopardy right now

aespa only has two songs and ygngg hasn’t even debuted yet💀 i wonder if the scandal will affect gidle’s next cb tho

Quote from SooYoung

LMAOOO didn't everything after Latata flopped too

damn Neverland got some guts now to act like nothing happened between Latata and Hwaa x)))

at least Itzy and Aespa haven't been cancel yet

Bestie don't fall for the bait

Quote from acepa

Idle fans getting brave now huh

aespa still haven't released an album yet. let's talk after their first album sales

it’s another YG or SM gg stan again posing as a YG or SM gg anti

I can't believe people are falling for this troll.

OP obviously just wants you to drag Idle and you're all falling for it...

Anyone who falls for this obvious bait just doesn't like gidle and will use this opportunity to trash them.

Quote from Skyliv

Anyone who falls for this obvious bait just doesn't like gidle and will use this opportunity to trash them.

Words of wisdom

MYs please don't bite the bait ik we're tired of people always shading us and we have to protect the girls but the OP never posted about G Idle before and he or she is dragging big 3 groups cause they know big 3 fandoms will attack g idle who's smaller fandom

Quote from reiusagi

MYs please don't bite the bait ik we're tired of people always shading us and we have to protect the girls but the OP never posted about G Idle before and he or she is dragging big 3 groups cause they know big 3 fandoms will attack g idle who's smaller fandom

The trolling was so weak, that it's cute

The life of a YG GG - not even debuted yet and people already pre-emptively flopping them

Latata is literally GIDLE's one and only hit, and that's not even a huge hit when you compare it to songs like DDDD, Cheer Up, Me Gustas Tu or Red Flavor. Their physical sales were also average until they received the queendom boost. I honestly feel the 4th generation is very dry and there is a lack of top girl groups. Oh My Girl or Gfriend aren't treated like 1st tier ggs but their peaks were much bigger than ITZY and GIDLE who are considered the "top" groups of this generation. While I say peak I mean digital performance and the level of being known with the public.

Quote from livingbarbiedoll

Latata is literally GIDLE's one and only hit, and that's not even a huge hit when you compare it to songs like DDDD, Cheer Up, Me Gustas Tu or Red Flavor. Their physical sales were also average until they received the queendom boost. I honestly feel the 4th generation is very dry and there is a lack of top girl groups. Oh My Girl or Gfriend aren't treated like 1st tier ggs but their peaks were much bigger than ITZY and GIDLE who are considered the "top" groups of this generation. While I say peak I mean digital performance and the level of being known with the public.

So I guess 6 music show wins for Dumdi Dumdi and 10 for HWAA don't mean anything.

Anyway, artistic relevance is not only about sales.

Quote from Alex_Murphy

So I guess 6 music show wins for Dumdi Dumdi and 10 for HWAA don't mean anything.

Anyway, artistic relevance is not only about sales.

Wins do not mean a song is huge, some boy groups fall out of melon in a week but swipe everything on music shows thanks to physical sales and voting. By that logic Apink's "Luv" with 17 wins is the biggest female idol song ever released.

Digital charting gives us decent detail about who is more known with Korea's public. I never said GIDLE is flopping, they are sure doing well. But yea the only "huge" song they released was their debut song.

Quote from livingbarbiedoll

Wins do not mean a song is huge, some boy groups fall out of melon in a week but swipe everything on music shows thanks to physical sales and voting.

Well, ok then. What I see is it's always possible to find one particular metric which a group is not the best at and say "there! you see, they not doing so great".

What I see is (G)I-DLE is one the most important gg of the 4th gen, the success of HWAA shows they keep growing and they receive an amount of respect from professional seniors of the industry that other groups don't necessarily get. So OF COURSE sales and charts wise they're not Blackpink level but who tf cares?

Quote from Alex_Murphy

Well, ok then. What I see is it's always possible to find one particular metric which a group is not the best at and say "there! you see, they not doing so great".

What I see is (G)I-DLE is one the most important gg of the 4th gen, the success of HWAA shows they keep growing and they receive an amount of respect from professional seniors of the industry that other groups don't necessarily get. So OF COURSE sales and charts wise they're not Blackpink level but who tf cares?

Some people are just bitter. Dumdix2 is their worst song for me and they still did great in Korea. If people are just so bitter about new gen just abandom kpop all together

Quote from SooYoung

LMAOOO didn't everything after Latata flopped too

damn Neverland got some guts now to act like nothing happened between Latata and Hwaa x)))

at least Itzy and Aespa haven't been cancel yet

She’s definitely not idle fan. If anything she’s a hater. Everyone knows the situation idle is in rn so their fans wouldn’t create fanwars from nothing.