where would you put FIFTY FIFTY on the current rank for 4th gen girl group ?

Tier 1 = Ive, NJ, Idle

Tier 2 = LSRFM, Aespa, Stayc

Tier 3 = NMIXX, Itzy, Fifty Fifty

Tier 4 = Kepler, Weeekly, Billlie

Tier 5 = Nugu

I don't care about Korea as its insignificant in terms of profit, <1%, for a successful group

So for all groups, since I don't want to exclude the more successful ones:

Equal #1 and #2 globally - BP and Twice

#3 globally - FIFTY FIFTY

The rest are still playing around in the minor leagues in Korea and Japan.

Quote from BlackpinkHouse

Tier 1 = Ive, NJ, Idle

Tier 2 = LSRFM, Aespa, Stayc

Tier 3 = NMIXX, Itzy, Fifty Fifty

Tier 4 = Kepler, Weeekly, Billlie

Tier 5 = Nugu

You're nuts to put 50-50 next to Itzy

League of their own

they RANK last PLACE in my TIER! love them THOUGH.

Current state they're second, next cb if successfully enough they're tier 1.5 (gidle and NMIXX here), if their cb fail they're tier 3 (billie or XG). If their next cb also land on Hot 100 they're still behind BP but rest above every 4th gen easily.

Tier of their own. They have the biggest global hit from a kpop female act.

It’s hard to compare and not comparable given other 4th gen ggs have massive multiple hits (ive, nj, lsrfm etc) in korea with moderate international success.

Quote from Icaro_Ribeiro

You're nuts to put 50-50 next to Itzy

Are you saying Fifty doesnt deserve to be next to Itzy? Or that they deserve to be above Itzy?

I put them on the same tier as Itzy but there are distinctions within tiers. Like at the top, it's Ive, then NJ, then Idle.

Nugu

they obviously are doing something that’s mind blowing but they’re still pretty nugu. hope they aren’t a one hit wonder

How do we know it's not a one hit wonder? For now i place them just before the nugus and after kepler, nmixx, weekly etc .. imo doesn't make sense to rank them among the popular groups just because of one song.

Tier 1 = Ive, NJ

Tier 2 = Idle, Itzy, LSRFM, Aespa,

Tier 3 = NMIXX,, Fifty Fifty, STAYC

Tier 4 = Triple S
Tier 5 - Alice

Quote from icyruios

Honestly?

Not high

We have to see first.

It might just be a Crayon Pop Bar Bar Bar moment

Y'all have recency bias

Display More

Crayon pop should be Tier 1 tho.

At this very moment, they are in tier 1 on a global stage.

Globally, they are most in demand now and making waves.

They can sink quickly if their next comeback doesn't do much.

Nowhere simply because they didn't cement themselves yet but it's hard to rank them because their success comes from international listeners