SNSD, because im biased

Well SNSD has poppy pop songs and hearbreaking ballads as their bside. SNSD has Taeyeon, one of my favorite voices in the world. Their voices blend together seamlessy. Their harmonizing is top of the top.

They have Paper plane, One more time, Complete, Trick, Etude, Chocolate love...

RV b sides are amongst the best in all Kpop imo

RV still has the best discography in Kpop.

I hope Aespa in 6 years will have the depth they do. They are on the right track so far.

SNSD doesn't have the depth in their b-sides but that's also possibly partly due to recency bias and their songs not having aged as well, being that 2nd gen kpop.

RV because

1. I've only listened to them and Aespa

2. they have more bsides and thus ceteris paribus - it means they should have more enjoyable bsides than Aespa

RV of course, but I would probably vote f(x) if it was an option. The whole Red Light album is a NO SKIP.

SNSD for me., mostly because I like going back to their discography and because it is one of my favorite in kpop. And as my username implied, I'm SNSD biased.

My interest for Red Velvet has been thinning for years now to almost nonexistent levels.

And I don't care about aespa enough to even check their title tracks.

My love for Red Velvet started with liking their album songs.

I'm going with Girls' Generation...... because I'm biased.

And because I've listened to their music so much that I tend to go back to it occasionally when I'm in the mood.

Compared with aespa, I listen to GG more.

I never listened to RV's music so I have no opinions on it.

Red Velvet

Why wasn't f(x) included in this? They have the best discography in K-Pop history

To be honest neither, I am not really the biggest fan of their bsides.

I haven't listened to all of SNSD's b-sides, but I do like quite a few.

Between Red Velvet and aespa, I could say either. There are a larger number of Red Velvet songs I enjoy, but percentage-wise probably favors aespa.

Quote from Yama-Chan

Why wasn't f(x) included in this? They have the best discography in K-Pop history

Not even close. They don't even have that many good singels. I mean thay have at least 4-5 2nd generation groups that have better songs.

Quote from patrik-k

Not even close. They don't even have that many good singels. I mean thay have at least 4-5 2nd generation groups that have better songs.

I don't care about your bad opinions, and you should know you're not going to change mine.

Hating on the best discography in K-Pop history automatically disqualifies you from having any valuable input in this conversation.

I should smack you with the Pink Bible for even thinking you could quote me with this sacrilegious nonsense.

Haven’t heard SNSD but between aespa and rv b sides it’s rv for me

Quote from Yama-Chan

I don't care about your bad opinions, and you should know you're not going to change mine.

Hating on the best discography in K-Pop history automatically disqualifies you from having any valuable input in this conversation.

I should smack you with the Pink Bible for even thinking you could quote me with this sacrilegious nonsense.

I doubt many agree with you that the have the best discography.

Quote from patrik-k

I doubt many agree with you that the have the best discography.

Sure, if you live 20,000 feet beneath Mount Everest maybe.

Red Velvet

Red Velvet

red velvet has the best b-sides in all of kpop

Quote from patrik-k

Not even close. They don't even have that many good singels. I mean thay have at least 4-5 2nd generation groups that have better songs.

f(x) has the best 2nd gen discography and by a mile

RV and it's not even close

Quote from butterbutterfly

f(x) has the best 2nd gen discography and by a mile

Hell no. How singles do they have? 11 if my information is correct. How many of them are acctually good? Three.

Hot Summer, Electric Shock and Nu ABO. Okay, let add one more, let's say they have four good singles even if I can't rember a fourth good one.

T-ara has around 20 I think only counting korean ones, half of them is all better or at least as good as the best f(x) singles. T-ara is miles ahead of f(x). Add to that Girl's Generation, 2NE1, SISTAR that I would say have better and I not even brought up KARA and Wondergirls yet.

Quote from patrik-k

Hell no. How singles do they have? 11 if my information is correct. How many of them are acctually good? Three.

Hot Summer, Electric Shock and Nu ABO. Okay, let add one more, let's say they have four good singles even if I can't rember a fourth good one.

T-ara has around 20 I think only counting korean ones, half of them is all better or at least as good as the best f(x) singles. T-ara is miles ahead of f(x). Add to that Girl's Generation, 2NE1, SISTAR that I would say have better and I not even brought up KARA and Wondergirls yet.

well agree to disagree. I find 2nd gen in general trash and poorly aged, only f(x)'s music has actually survived the test of time and manages to still sound fresh. in my opinion, that is.

I voted Red Velvet, after analising it for a bit.

SNSD is my ultimate favourite group together with Twice, but I've always had a slight preference towards their Korean title tracks, rather than their bsides. Some of their bsides are among my favourite songs of all time, but it's mostly from their japanese albums and Forever 1. For their earlier albums, I do prefer title tracks, with some exceptions.

Then aespa - I do love a lot of their bsides, but not all, like with SNSD. But they're still growing as a group and if their future music will be just as good, I'll be super happy. (and this year they gave me Flowers which is easily in my top 10 bsides of all time )

But for Red Velvet, their bsides have been my favourite right from the first mini and I think they have aged really well. They also have a lot of variety, which I love. Out of all three groups, I follow them the least (I'm a fan, but don't follow their sm or news super closely), but their music is always impeccable, so I check it every comeback.

If we included solo work of the members, I'd have to change my vote to SNSD purely because of Taeyeon, but considering the group only, it's RV.

Quote from sveznalica

To be honest neither, I am not really the biggest fan of their bsides.

Same. There are bops here and there. But also trash songs, and songs that ruin cohesiveness.

red velvet

aespa

snsd

tbh if aespa keep on releasing quality albums for the next few years they may be able to challenge rv's discography

Quote from DoraemoNobita

Same. There are bops here and there. But also trash songs, and songs that ruin cohesiveness.

And most importantly most of their bsides are just... there. I prefer their title tracks, I love almost all of them.

Quote from sonemariam

Fx wasn't as promoted as the rest of the ggs.

Well, that maybe the case, but don't really have any thing to do with if their discography is the best or not but effect their overall success. I don't like speaking bad about a group with a member that you know what, but I feel f(x) is one of the more overrated groups compared to the attention the group got. Sure I kind of like their style and some of their songs are good, but they are not that speciall compared to other 2nd generation groups. They mabye would have been if they as say was promoted a bit more and was not in the shadow of Girls' Generation, at the same time they probably where popular just because they where from SME.