Which are better visually between these 2 3rd and 4th gen ggs

i think 3rd gen wins but i'll leave yujin out of this

Quote from versatile

Yujin>>> Irene/mina-tzuyu/jisoo?

probably not irene and tzuyu but i think she can hold her own against jisoo and mina

3rd gen easily, twice alone has more visuals than aespa and newjeans combined

Mop goes brrrr.

i mean

the jisoo/tzuyu/irene is godlike in itself

Quote from versatile

When you say it like that this Thread is a bit mean.

Maybe I should add le ssafamr too

Add gidle and itzy too so each 3rd gen has to fail 2, it will make it more even

Everbody knows we have a lot of good looking girls in pretty much all kpop groups so not really any point voting on this.

But only me that think NJ gives away a bit lolita vibes sometimes? Just something in their looks and styling.

Quote from patrik-k

Everbody knows we have a lot of good looking girls in pretty much all kpop groups so not really any point voting on this.

But only me that think NJ gives away a bit lolita vibes sometimes? Just something in their looks and styling.

Well is expected for the group made by hardcore lolita fan min heejin.

Quote from patrik-k

Everbody knows we have a lot of good looking girls in pretty much all kpop groups so not really any point voting on this.

But only me that think NJ gives away a bit lolita vibes sometimes? Just something in their looks and styling.

They look like aliens to me

Since it's a visual thread, I'll let pictures speak for themselves.

pasted-from-clipboard.pngpasted-from-clipboard.pngpasted-from-clipboard.png

pasted-from-clipboard.png

pasted-from-clipboard.png

pasted-from-clipboard.png

pasted-from-clipboard.png

Haerin alone ends all of 3rd gen

20240204_024134.jpg

Quote from versatile

I understand this comment now.

Bruh this is how your favs look

Quote from versatile

I understand this comment now.

Well... a pretty alien.

Quote from thebadguy

Bruh this is how your favs look

I would let Jihyo abduct me with a spaceship and do weird experiments on me.

3rd gen

BP carried them hard in visuals

Quote from versatile

Jihyo is god tier better off going for nvm

I can't nvm, now you gotta tell

we need our saviors, teshub and drew_b to make the judgement!!!111

I don't care about red velvet, sm visuals aren't my type, but twice and bp's visuals are insane. They are so pretty, I'm actually annoyed lol

3rd gen. 4th gen groups look good as a group but individually 3rd gen wins.

Just from one look you can tell Irene is red velvet’s visual

Third Gen has 6 bottom tier visuals.

Fourth Gen has 4 bottom tier visuals.

Third Gen has 3 top tier visuals (face).

Fourth Gen has 5 or 6.

Third Gen has 3 top tier body proportions.

Fourth Gen has 5 top tier body proportions.

Fourth Gen has the edge.

3rd gen has more members in the mentioned groups that I REALLY do not like visually at all.

But 3rd gen also has members that are absolute walls that most of 4th gen can't reach.

4th gen doesn't have anyone I'd consider... well really do not like visually tier.

But it also has fewer outright walls.

Tough choice.

Twice and Blackpink

Unless you’re Karina or Wonyoung. Visual position is even important since most 4th gen gg are pretty and I found sometimes the non visuals much more prettier.

I don't care about cute teens trying hard to be sexy. I prefer REAL WOMEN!

Also, most Idols (male and female too) are literally looking the same, I mean, seriously, carbon copy of each other.

3rd gen visuals to me will always be the most beautiful. With 4th gen I feel like everything is very plastic (?) like 4th gen idol's faces are heavily touched up and even more insanely perfect, it just feels like their not really real people, everything has to be perfect, with 3rd gen I feel like we had more genieunly beautiful idols like companies actually scouted naturally beautiful people instead of making them get 15 procedures pre-debut.

Plus nobody can top Tzuyu/Irene/Jisoo visual line, sorry.

Quote from versatile

Moobyul is there only redeeming visual

Well, visuals is all about personal taste. I love Mamamoo because they look real, not fake, like most Kpop groups. Basically, 95% of the groups (male and female) are like GQ top models. Nothing special.

I mean, sure I'm biased, like everyone else, but in this MV, they look INSANE, especially Wheein! I don't think I've ever seen an Idol with red hair who looked better than her. Also, they're effortlessly sexy and cool.

But, I prefer their natural look, btw:

There is a reason why BP and Twice are doing massive concert tours recently.

The discerning simps choice

FbApWwYagAYM52g.jpg

Quote from versatile

Who's this

Dreamcatcher

I love 4th gen visuals!! Yuna, Wonyoung, Karina, Sullyoon, and literally all of newjeans!!

4th gen visuals are better, but If we remove Twice then RV/BP are more visually appealing