We can officially declare that Nayeon's solo is the most successful solo among 3rd gen ggs

another win for the success stans

maybe because of TWICE fandom
and
among the 3rd gen soloist she still active

or late into a soloist so she got the award this time
compared to Somi, Chungha on inactive list for now?

pepe eyeroll.gif

It's like you want blinks to drag Nayeon so you can have ammo for dragging BP/blinks=hit thread.

Congrats to my wife

Quote from Dreamer95

Somi and Chungha technically are solo artists, not group solos. Yes, they were once in a group for entire 3 months, but I wouldn't count that.

So you guys do afterall realize that blinks have unprovoked anger issues and unreasonably attack others, huh? Because other than that I don't see how would blinks attack this, I am 100% correct on this. She's the only one who checked all boxes.

I've been knew but does Nayeon being dragged have to prove this point? If you just said "one of" and they still bite that's at least on them.

such a nice thread and everyone malding in the replies

in Korea it was definitely Jennie I know you are trolling but let's be real

and if we are talking about album sales that's Lisa

Quote from Derpcatcher

pepe eyeroll.gif

is this new? we need it pepe emojis NOW

She was more successful than her own group. So i guess u can have this one to feel better.

Quote from killingtime1934

is this new? we need it pepe emojis NOW

I asked for it ages ago but fell on def ears so I just attach it every time i wanna use it

Congrats to Nayeon but still a no.

International charting, Rosé and Lisa did better(BBH100, Spotify, BBGLobal 200 & BBGlobal exl. US).

Domestic charting, Jennie and Rosé did better(more streams, harder chart and competition for Rosé so I'll give this one to her).

Album sales, Rosé and Lisa did better. In fact, Rosé is still selling even after 2 years.

Awards, I think Rosé and Jennie got more music show wins. Jennie had a Bonsang. Rosé won Best Dance Performance in MAMA.

So technically, BP girlies still did better than Nayeon. But definitely, Nayeon did better than Twice in 2022.

no

Quote from Dreamer95

Sold half a million albums, strong international charting, strong domestic charting and finally awards. She checked all the boxes possible. She loses to some in one metrics or another but overall, everything combined, there is no arguing this is the most successful solo

Yes in Korea but internationally Lisa's Money did too well.

Quote from proud-fan

Congrats to Nayeon but still a no.

International charting, Rosé and Lisa did better(BBH100, Spotify, BBGLobal 200 & BBGlobal exl. US).

Domestic charting, Jennie and Rosé did better(more streams, harder chart and competition for Rosé so I'll give this one to her).

Album sales, Rosé and Lisa did better. In fact, Rosé is still selling even after 2 years.

Awards, I think Rosé and Jennie got more music show wins. Jennie had a Bonsang. Rosé won Best Dance Performance in MAMA.

So technically, BP girlies still did better than Nayeon. But definitely, Nayeon did better than Twice in 2022.

Display More

I agree with some points but no offense to Rosé I think Jennie should get the credit for this one on the domestic aspect though her song was a viral son in Korea

I don't know why people are discrediting how big she was back then

Thats a bold statement

And the people who are responding him y’all are bunch of lame people idc. He just wants to piss off you.

I feel like it would be Hwasa as she's had multiple successful songs not just one. Everyone else that's been named (Nayeon, Jennie, Rose, Lisa) has only had one successful song.

The jabs at TWICE as a group just shows what some people are really here for (same for most dreamer threads tbh)

okay minion we all know its still jennie but nayeon has the better song

Quote from Dreamer95

Somi and Chungha technically are solo artists, not group solos. Yes, they were once in a group for entire 3 months, but I wouldn't count that.

So you guys do afterall realize that blinks have unprovoked anger issues and unreasonably attack others, huh? Because other than that I don't see how would blinks attack this, I am 100% correct on this. She's the only one who checked all boxes.

no, we just know Lisa is bigger. You know it too, just in denial

Rose did the best if we're talking about "checking all the boxes". She did get that best dance performance award and yeah okay that's not as big as solo artist of the year award but she did sell a lot more and get more streams than nayeon and those are more important metrics

Quote from Dreamer95

That's the point, we're talking about the whole package. Sorry, all of your faves did well, but not universally. Nayeon was the only one who did universally well.

That's not a real fucking metric, be real.

Are yall from the same school of "stupid arts"? What part of did well in everything you don't get?

Jennie - no album sales

Lisa - flopped in Korea

Rose - didn't get any serious awards

Display More

i swear some posters here have a humiliation fetish

Quote from SooYoung

Well considering that even non kpop fans i know were bopping to "Money" without even knowing that the singer was a membeer of a kpop gg

i would say Lisa is by far the most successfull 3rd gen solo

Same scenario for me

Quote from Slayurfaves

in Korea it was definitely Jennie I know you are trolling but let's be real

Display Spoiler

and if we are talking about album sales that's Lisa

Display More

bro op said overall can you please read

If lisa didnt almost reach 700 million streams on Spotify for money and 1 billion for her album them yes

Quote from Dreamer95

We're not talking about who's bigger, ffs sake are you blinks completely numb because of the noise music? It is about the success of their solo release, who tf cares if Lisa is bigger or not?

Hold your horses big boy, Rose in her first year sold less than Nayeon, it's 516k against 544k as per Gaon.

써클차트 - CIRCLE CHART, 글로벌 케이팝(K-pop) 음악차트

As for Spotify streams it is 154.9 million against 144.7 million in Rose's favor in the first year, just a little more.

But lets also take into account that Rose's solo came out in the beginning of the year while Nayeon's in the summer, so with less time Nayeon had more album sales and almost the same amount of streams. Currently Pop is sitting at around 160 million, so it actually does beat Rose's OTG

And dance performance is bs a award, considering her songs didn't even have a proper choreography.

Display More

okay? but now theres a 200k difference in sales and nayeon sales aren't growing at all so its safe to say rosé sold more. same with spotify. its not just title track vs title track even rosé's bside has more streams. nayeon debut did alright initially but longevity wasn't that good.

Quote from icyruios

That means Gaeul is mine good job now go away

Naur she's mine

Quote from Roses-are-Rosie

Naur she's mine

You're an even worse homewrecker than I thought

Quote from Dreamer95

Sold half a million albums, strong international charting, strong domestic charting and finally awards. She checked all the boxes possible. She loses to some in one metrics or another but overall, everything combined, there is no arguing this is the most successful solo

I dont see how Nayeon is considered strong international charting when Lisa clearly outdo her in that region + Youtube views + WW charts. Nayeon wins in Korea but she losses in almost everywhere. Also, dont get me started when LaLisa outsold IM NAYEON by large margin

Unless your weightage is Korean 80% +international charting/physical 20% then maybe Nayeon has chance

Quote from Wench

You're an even worse homewrecker than I thought

Don't be jealous my niece

Quote from Dreamer95

Hold your horses big boy, Rose in her first year sold less than Nayeon, it's 516k against 544k as per Gaon.

써클차트 - CIRCLE CHART, 글로벌 케이팝(K-pop) 음악차트

As for Spotify streams it is 154.9 million against 144.7 million in Rose's favor in the first year, just a little more.

But lets also take into account that Rose's solo came out in the beginning of the year while Nayeon's in the summer, so with less time Nayeon had more album sales and almost the same amount of streams. Currently Pop is sitting at around 160 million, so it actually does beat Rose's OTG

And dance performance is bs a award, considering her songs didn't even have a proper choreography.

Display More

Rosé solo album is still selling well till these day (last week she sold 15k of it) and im not sure why you would want to compare 1st year sales - which is not comparable to Nayeon like what u pointed out.