Posts by Cold_Wave
-
-
no one said touring is the ultimate decider of artist ranking but it is a pretty important metric. if someone had similar relevance to bp along with better touring numbers then yes they might be considered above bp. but the situation with twice is that they hold very little relevance outside of their fandom these days, when they drop a song it doesnt even chart in korea and gets very few global streams. so hypothetically even if they did get the biggest tour the people would be reluctant to call them the biggest girl group currently. how would it make sense to say "yeah no one much cares or even notices when they release music but they are the biggest girl group currently!". no much sense at all.
-
Bp will do well and twice will release a sad miserable flop.
But who cares about charts and fanwars let's just all enjoy the music
-
it depends. if they apologize to illit the people might forgive them
-
-
Display More
The only thing that doesn't matter is this coke rant.
Just because you're incapable of comprehending painfully easy to comprehend logic doesn't mean I'm contradicting myself.
You came in here trying to grind your blunt ass axe without any concept of how you would make a point worth responding to.
Cherish was a flop in the context of any standard we have for big hit songs, and it objectively performed far worse than The Chase. Period.
Bringing up a song by Mamamoo, that both charted at #1, set a MelOn record for 24 hour unique listeners and blocked BP from hitting #1 is moronic behavior.
And it's completely inapplicable to any argument I've made. Your corny ass is now trying to bring up NewJeans, as K-Pop fans are not capable of making any arguments without trying to "drag" a person's perceived "favs", but I have NEVER said Supernova wasn't a bigger song than How Sweet, so what is the point of bringing it up?
You have no idea what you're talking about, and don't you ever quote me with this dumb bullshit again or I won't be as kind, and I'll start making some BP threads that will really get you Blinks going.
you just dont get the point i'm making. i have to explain it in a more simple way i guess.
i never said you tried to say the 2024 NJ songs were bigger than supernova. the point is that even when a song does significantly better than another (like in this supernova example) that doesnt necessarily mean that artist is more popular/loved than the other. its not an accurate measure of popularity. so when you boast about an artist being more loved/popular than another based on a song comparison with very miniscule difference in results its kinda corny, you don't just say yia did better you do always try to insist mamamoo was more popular at the time.
go ahead make your bp threads. its not like you don't already try to do that all the time
-
Display More
Try making your arguments without bringing up a near 11 year old group.
You only highlight your own ignorance when you fail to do so.
I never said AIIYL wasn't much bigger than YIA overall. In fact, I have literally said since 2017 that the longevity of the song proved the public liked AIIYL much better than YIA in the long term, but that the way YIA completely overshadowed it and blocked it for a month proved that Mamamoo was still more popular in Korea than BLACKPINK. I've been making the same arguments and presenting the same evidence for almost a decade, and somehow you salty Blinks still find a way to fuck it up.
Cherish was a boring ass song that flopped in Korea and flopped internationally. It had no impact, and nobody outside of ILLIT fans will even remember it. Ever.
Stop trying to damage control how much of a forgettable snooze fest that song was. Yes, H2H's song performed FAR better.
doesnt matter that mamamoo is 11, i'm talking about when they were 3
aiiyl blocked YIA on all the charts apart from melon. the digital points on gaon/circle were practically the same. YIA didnt "completely overshadow" at all.
but anyway the point is you contradict yourself a lot. when it suits you even very slightly better charting is irrefutable evidence that a group is more loved than another. but when it doesnt then you pull out all the excuses like when supernova actually completely overshadowed NJ last year.
when you don't like the group low charting means the song was objectively bad but when its mamamoo it just wasnt the right timing or some other weird excuse.
-
It was BORING
And the charts reflected that as the majority opinion.
the charts reflected the general publics sentiments on hybe/belift which was much more negative at the time. if low charting means boring music then does that explain why mamamoo fell off? just boring song after the other
You literally have no idea what you're talking about as usual. Just straight up talking out your ass with no facts to back up any of the vitriolic nonsense you type up.
The Chase was a MUCH bigger song than Cherish on every platform. How the flying fuck is a song that peaked in the top 30 a flop? Your favorite girl groups would kill for that kind of flop with their latest title tracks.
not "MUCH bigger". cherish peaked #36 on melon daily. the chase peaked #26. the chase had better longevity but i still wouldnt call its performance "much better". if longevity matters so much you would have to admit aiiyl was MUCH bigger than YIA
how did the chase do better "on every platform" when its far lower on both spotify and youtube. cherish is older but still theyre both getting roughly the same daily streams currently so that gap isnt going to close. its fair to say cherish did MUCH better on these other platforms
i only mention mamamoo to point out the contradictions. not trying to attack them
-
Bye felicia
-
-
-
-
pepe is the best frog way better than kermit
-
everything wouldve been better if mhj wasnt a
-
OP with egg on his face yet again
-
it will be hard without the army support. they didnt even on US spotify last year
-
-
its not always like this but im just speaking generally.
males will be reluctant to own physical albums because of the social stigma. they can get away with listening to songs and watching the mv in private but to own a physical album is different. can't really hide that.
female fans like girl groups too but their dedication to boy groups reaches much higher levels because of the physical attraction
-
theyre really gaod at umm....
hmmmmmm...
*runs away*
-
