[Imagine ] if polarizing song from your fave sung by other group not your fave would you like the song?

of course not

I'm here for my faves vocals

the song would sound completely different without them

i would love to hear others' renditions. whether they can pull it off or not is another thing, but i respect people's efforts with covers whether or not they're "as good as the original".

Good examples. None of the groups there are my faves and I don’t like any of the listed song. Well, I like RBB a bit.

Edit: it’s ZZB. Then no, I don’t like that one.. it’s so bad

If they did a good job of it but some songs can only be sung for or by that group.

Quote from icyruios

ZIMZALABIMZIMZIMZALABIMZIMZIMZALABIMZIMZIM

ZIMZALABIMZIMZIMZALABIMZIMZIMZALABIMZIMZIM

ZIMZALABIMZIMZIMZALABIMZIMZIMZALABIMZIMZIM

ZIMZALABIMZIMZIMZALABIMZIMZIMZALABIMZIMZIM

ZIMZALABIMZIMZIMZALABIMZIMZIMZALABIMZIMZIM

ZIMZALABIMZIMZIMZALABIMZIMZIMZALABIMZIMZIM

ZIMZALABIMZIMZIMZALABIMZIMZIMZALABIMZIMZIM

ZIMZALABIMZIMZIMZALABIMZIMZIMZALABIMZIMZIM

ZIMZALABIMZIMZIMZALABIMZIMZIMZALABIMZIMZIM

ZIMZALABIMZIMZIMZALABIMZIMZIMZALABIMZIMZIM

ZIMZALABIMZIMZIMZALABIMZIMZIMZALABIMZIMZIM

ZIMZALABIMZIMZIMZALABIMZIMZIMZALABIMZIMZIM

Display More

I mean, I love AESPA and I don't like Savage at all.

Really, the only difference this makes is that I'm more likely to listen to the song in the first place if one of my fave made it, but who sings it doesn't really impact if I will like or dislike a song.

Thunderous wasn’t released by my fav and I still like it

I can't tell, the human elements of songs play a huge in its likability to me, and with that I mean vocal tones and skills, performance style etc. So this is not as simple as the question makes it seem.

probably not...if the song was polarising to begin with it probably wouldn't matter who sang it even if it were from my favs...

Quote from www1717

would you like a song you like if it was released by someone not you bias

For example like,

-If sticker was released for other bg not your fave, would you like the song?

- if thunderous was released for other bg not your fave, would you will like the song?

- if wadada was released for other gg not your fave, would you will like the song?

- if savage was released for other gg not your fave, would you will like the song?

-if zzb was released for other gg not you fave, would you will like the song?

(Source of polarizing song: akp common agreement)

Would you or wouldn't you?

Display More

It would be the same thing that happened with NCT: I dislike it at first and then it grows on me.

I'll be honest, Thunderous wasn't my favorite comeback from them, so I might listen to it occasionally, but I wouldn't like it as much.

I love all three of the girl group "polarizing" songs, so I would love them no matter who sang them. That being said, each of the respective groups aced singing the song that they got.

I hope that answered your question. Have a great day/night!

I don't know none of my faves make such polarizing songs so I don't even know

I most of these songs and they're all by groups I don't stan, so I suppose

No one and nothing not even TWICE themselves can ever make me like Heartshaker. Sorry!

Quote from MissBehave

if a song is to my taste and the performers suit it, I will like it no matter who sings it

There are songs I can't stand by my faves

I agree with this. A good song is a good song, no matter who sings it and a bad song is a bad song, no matter who sings it. There are also songs by my faves I don't like (Boxer) and songs by a group I don't stan that I love (Twit). Have a great day/night!

Quote from Pikachu-Senpai

No one and nothing not even TWICE themselves can ever make me like Heartshaker. Sorry!

I used to hate it that much too, but it grew on me. Is Sana gae is iconic.

Quote from icyruios

Literally my top 3 Twice songs you this scam fake fan

STREAM THE BEST TWICE SONG

NAYEON APPROVES

Thunderous couldn't have been released by anyone else, tbh

Quote from Pikachu-Senpai

STREAM THE BEST TWICE SONG

External Content www.youtube.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

NAYEON APPROVES

It's Nayeon's favorite song ever! We stan!

Quote from YouChanDoThis

It's Nayeon's favorite song ever! We stan!

EXACTLY QUEEN NAYEON LOVES IT SO WE MUST LOVE ALSO!

Quote from icyruios

Yikes you really are a fake fan how dare you even google search that song to contribute to its Youtube search algorithm

 

DON'T DENY THE POWER OF IGBAS. IT'S SO STRONG. IT WILL TAKE OVER K-POP.

Quote from Pikachu-Senpai

DON'T DENY THE POWER OF IGBAS. IT'S SO STRONG. IT WILL TAKE OVER K-POP.

It already has.

Quote from icyruios

I'm gonna be a star star I'm gonna be I'm I'm gonna be

SEE SO ICONIC EVEN SPONGEBOB AND PATRICK STANS THE SONG.

GLOBAL SONG!!!!!!!

I don't like any of those songs except savage and aespa are not my faves so not sure

think the opposite question would make more sense if i dont like a song by my faves, other groups sure ain't gona make it better in fact i might even dislike it more

Do txt have a polarizing song?

Maybe Cat & Dog English version

I don't think so, because I wouldn't give them the same chance.

I think Thunderous is good, though.

I love all the songs you mentioned except Wa Da Da and I only stan Stray Kids.

Like others say it's not that simple, if Sticker was already dragged to hell and back, I can't imagine if the group who did it wouldn't have the singers NCT 127 have, or had weaker rappers. Sticker without good vocal output and harmonization would completely loose it's purpose

Quote from MakotoNijima

I can't imagine if the group who did it wouldn't have the singers NCT 127 have, or had weaker rappers.

exactly which is why every bts cover sucks ass

Quote from Pikachu-Senpai

SEE SO ICONIC EVEN SPONGEBOB AND PATRICK STANS THE SONG.

GLOBAL SONG!!!!!!!

"Bitch, I'm gonna be a star but no Patrick"

Quote from yoonjinkook

exactly which is why every bts cover sucks ass

I wouldn't say every bts cover sucks but yeah 95% of them are bad, especially when you compare it to the original version

Quote from tenfour

"Bitch, I'm gonna be a star but no Patrick"

THE COLLAB WE NEED

Quote from lialve

I wouldn't say every bts cover sucks but yeah 95% of them are bad in comparison with the original

rap parts always suck cuz rappers who do them are no match for bts rapline, so it ruins everything for me