discuss 
Do you think Lisa solo will surpass IU, Hyuna, Taeyeon and Sunmi!!
-
Please live up to your username.
-
surpass in what?
physical sales? for sure.
in views for mv? nothing more sure than that.
wins in music shows? Depending on the song and promotion
Success in the Korean charts? Not easy to compare. Would have to come back at the same time, but basically no one can defeat IU.
Sucess in international charts. Yup.
-
not in Korea, but internationally without a doubt
-
in terms of commercial success in Korea? Nope because YG is going to f@uk up her promotion
No guarantee for international charts either, it's really up to what YG is aiming for
TBH, I can see YG pulling a Victoria on Lisa and push her in the China market for her solo while the DJ Snake collab is for the Western market
but we'll see
-
-
-
yes
-
Display More
surpass in what?
physical sales? for sure.
in views for mv? nothing more sure than that.
wins in music shows? Depending on the song and promotion
Success in the Korean charts? Not easy to compare. Would have to come back at the same time, but basically no one can defeat IU.
Sucess in international charts. Yup.
^^^^what he or she said
-
SEA 100% sure, especially in Thailand, her home country.
-
-
Display More
surpass in what?
physical sales? for sure.
in views for mv? nothing more sure than that.
wins in music shows? Depending on the song and promotion
Success in the Korean charts? Not easy to compare. Would have to come back at the same time, but basically no one can defeat IU.
Sucess in international charts. Yup.
This
-
-
^^^^what he or she said
she
-
First 24 hr ULs, accumulated ULs over a period, years digital points can be used to compare, even when artists release at different times, but agreed that this one is multi-variate, like who else is releasing at the same time.
Is some other major event happening at the same time etc.
But even so, IUs records in such things when it comes to the Korean digitals, is so immense that it will take an exceptional song to beat it.
-
Only on YouTube.
-
-
lool without any question!
-
Not thinking about sales, but based on YGE's creative track record with MVs, it has the potential to be more appealing than 2.5 of the names listed.
If they do a double-A side title and at least one of the songs is Hip-Hop/Hip-Pop influenced, I would say that track would be more appealing than 3 of the listed names because of the synergy between Lisa's rhythm proficiencies (with rap cadences and physical coordination) and YGE's Hip-Hop sensibilities and competence.
-
Only on YouTube.
And international charts, album sales and probably music shows
-
And international charts, album sales and probably music shows
Music shows is a bit unpredictable depends a lot in the competition.
-
-
Music shows is a bit unpredictable depends a lot in the competition.
actually yeah probably not more than IU but the other artists mentioned didnt win much (or any) with their last releases
-
And international charts, album sales and probably music shows
Forget I said anything
-
-
she
she it is my friend
-
Rose solo didn't surpass any of the female solos artists I mentioned
Kpop stans need to learn how to differentiate between abusing the replay button on YouTube and actual recognition and impact.
-
-
-
-
-
There's no replay button for album sales and Rosé easily outsold.
-
-
-
-
-
Physicals?
Isn't it well established by now, that it is primarily the fans, who will never ever even unpack the album, don't even have a player to play, who will buy albums, out of loyalty to the idol, irrespective of the music.
Larger the fandom, more such buys.
Idols aren't complaining.
Nevertheless a far better indicator of a song's success is digital ULs.
And IU is unshakeable on the initial ULs, and pretty strong in longevity.
800K plus first 24 hr ULs, for Celebrity
Rose did 400K plus, that's pretty good, but doesn't surpass IU.
Wonder if Lisa can surpass Rose?
-
-
-
There's no replay button for album sales and Rosé easily outsold.
I just can't help but laugh at OP's comment about Rosé's solo. She did extremely well for a rookie soloist and an English song.
-
Display More
Physicals?
Isn't it well established by now, that it is primarily the fans, who will never ever even unpack the album, don't even have a player to play, who will buy albums, out of loyalty to the idol, irrespective of the music.
Larger the fandom, more such buys.
Idols aren't complaining.
Nevertheless a far better indicator of a song's success is digital ULs.
And IU is unshakeable on the initial ULs, and pretty strong in longevity.
800K plus first 24 hr ULs, for Celebrity
Rose did 400K plus, that's pretty good, but doesn't surpass IU.
Wonder if Lisa can surpass Rose?
When it comes to SK charting, I honestly believe Lisa won't surpass Rosé. For a rookie soloist, Rosé did 400k ULs when other top girl groups weren't able to do this year.
But maybe in international charting and sales, she might surpass Rosé. With BBH100, with bigger sales, she might chart higher than Rosé. With BB Global 200 and BB Global 200 Exc. US, she won't since Rosé got #1 on those charts. They might have the same ranking there. In China, she might surpass Rosé since she's more famous there.
Anyway, when it comes to international, Lisa might surpass Rosé but not in SK.
-
Display More
Physicals?
Isn't it well established by now, that it is primarily the fans, who will never ever even unpack the album, don't even have a player to play, who will buy albums, out of loyalty to the idol, irrespective of the music.
Larger the fandom, more such buys.
Idols aren't complaining.
Nevertheless a far better indicator of a song's success is digital ULs.
And IU is unshakeable on the initial ULs, and pretty strong in longevity.
800K plus first 24 hr ULs, for Celebrity
Rose did 400K plus, that's pretty good, but doesn't surpass IU.
Wonder if Lisa can surpass Rose?
i think the only member in blackpink can capable to give competation to IU is jennie in korea other than that no one capable do that not even jisoo who second most popular member in korea
-
-
Participate now!
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!
