Was it easier to get Perfect All-Kill in the past or were the songs just soooo gooood?

  • All songs to achieve a Perfect All-Kill (PAK) in history:


    2010
    IU, Lim Seulong - Nagging
    IU - Good Day


    2011
    IU - Only I Didn’t Know
    BIGBANG - TONIGHT
    Kim Bumsoo - Please Park Bom - Don’t Cry
    2NE1 - LONELY
    Hyun Bin - The Man
    2NE1 - I AM THE BEST
    Park Myungsoo, G-DRAGON, Park Bom - Having an affair
    miss A - Good-bye Baby
    Leessang, Yoon Mirae, Kwon Jungyeol - Turned off the TV
    IU - You&I


    2012
    BIGBANG - BLUE
    Busker Busker - Cherry Blossom Ending
    Busker Busker - If You Really Love Me
    PSY - Gangnam Style
    G- DRAGON - That XX
    NAUL - Memory Of The Wind


    2013
    Leessang, Eugene - Tears
    SISTAR19 - Gone Not Around Any Longer
    PSY - GENTLEMEN
    Lee Hyori - Miss Korea
    Huh Gak, Jung Eunji - Short Hair
    SISTAR - Give It To Me
    Yoon Mirae - Touch Love
    Busker Busker - Love, At First
    IU - The Red Shoes
    Park Myungsoo, Primary, Gaeko - I Got C
    IU, Jang Yi Jeong - Friday


    2014
    Idina Menzel - Let It Go
    IU - My Old Story
    Soyou, Kwon Soonil, Park Yongin - The Space Between
    Kwak Jin Un, Kim Feel, Do Hyuk - Only You
    MC Mong, Jinsil - MISS ME OR DISS ME


    2015
    Jung Seung Hwan, Park Yoonha - I have to forget you
    miss A - Only You
    BIGBANG - LOSER
    SISTAR - SHAKE IT
    BIGBANG - Let’s not fall in love
    IU, Park Myungsoo - LEON
    IU - Twenty-Three
    OH HYUK - A Little Girl


    2016
    Crush, TAEYEON - Don’t Forget
    GFRIEND - Rough
    MAMAMOO - You’re The Best
    Davichi - This Love
    TWICE - CHEER UP
    10cm - What The Spring ??
    Urban Zakapa - I Don’t Love You
    ONE, G2, BeWhy, DayDay, Simon Dominic - I’m not what you knew
    ONE, Simon Dominic, GRAY - Comfortable BeWhy - Forever
    Wonder Girls - Why So Lonely
    BLACKPINK - Whistle
    Lim Chang Jung - The Love I Comitted
    Han Dong Geun - Making a new ending for this story
    IOI - Very Very Very
    TWICE - TT
    Heize - Star
    BIGBANG - FXXK IT


    2017
    Kwanghee, Gaeko, OH HYUK - Your Night
    Ailee - I Will Go To You Like The First Snow
    TWICE - KNOCK KNOCK
    IU - Through The Night
    IU, OH HYUK - Can’t Love You Anymore
    IU, G-DRAGON - Palette
    G-DRAGON - Untitled, 2014
    Heize, Shin Yong Jae - You, Clouds, Rain
    Nucksal, Hanhae, Rhyno, MyunDo, Jo Woochan - 1/n
    Yoon Jong Shin - Like It
    Woo Won Jae, Loco, GRAY - We Are
    IU - Autumn Morning
    Bolbbalgan4 - Some
    Epik High, IU - LOVE STORY
    Naul - Emptinese In Memory
    DEAN - instagram


    2018
    iKON - LOVE SCENARIO
    BIGBANG - Flower Road
    HAON, VINXEN - Bar Code
    Loco, HwaSa - Don’t
    BTS - FAKE LOVE
    Bolbbalgan4 - Travel
    BLACKPINK - DDU-DU DDU-DU
    Red Velvet - Power Up
    Sunmi - Siren
    Lim Chang Jung - There has never been a day i haven’t loved you
    ph-1, Kid Milli, Loopy, CODE KUNST, Paloalto - Good Day
    IU - BBIBBI
    TWICE - YES or YES


    2019
    BTS, Halsey - Boy With Luv

    Bolbbalgan4 - Workaholic

    AKMU - How Can I Love The Heartbreak, You’re The One I Love
    MC Mong, Song Ga In, Chancellor - FAME

    IU - Love Poem

    IU - Blueming


    2020
    ZICO - Any Song

    IU - Give You My Heart

    IU, SUGA - Eight
    BLACKPINK - How You Like That

    SSAK3 - Beach Again

    BTS - Dynamite

    Refund Sisters - Don’t Touch Me

    Mirani, Munchman, Khundi Panda, MUSHVENOM, GroovyRoom, JUSTHIS - VVS


    2021
    IU - Celebrity
    Brave Girls - Rollin’
    IU - LILAC
    BTS - Butter

    MSG Wannabe - Foolish Love

    The Kid LAROI, Justin Bieber - STAY

    aespa - Savage I

    U - Strawberry Moon
    sokodomo, Zion.T, Wonstein - MERRY-GO-ROUND


    2022
    TAEYEON - INVU

    (G)I-DLE - TOMBOY

    BIGBANG - Still Life

    IVE - After LIKE

    (G)I-DLE - Nxde

    YOUNHA - Event Horizon

    NewJeans - Ditto


    2023
    IVE - Kitsch

    IVE - I AM
    (G)I-DLE - Queencard
    NewJeans - Super Shy
    AKMU - Love Lee
    IVE - Baddie


    2024
    IU - Love wins all
    BIBI - Bam Yang Gang
    (G)I-DLE - FATE
    ILLIT - Magnetic
    aespa - Supernova
    DAY6 - HAPPY

    source

    External Content x.com
    Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.
    Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

    External Content www.youtube.com
    Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.
    Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

  • The numbers seem to indicate a pattern,


    That more acts/songs achieved PAK in the past, than recently.

    But recently songs achieve more PAK hours than in the past, when many songs had hours only in single digits.


    But I don't think it correlates to "easy".

    There were way too many charts, at a time 22(?). So that was not easy, compared to current 4-5 charts?


    What it correlates, is that in S Korea, variety is reduced, it is increasingly difficult for small, unknown, Indie acts to strike it big.

    It is all corporate, big business, pushing and promoting with advanced marketing strategies.


    The industry is now consolidated and organized with the big players occupying 90%+ of the market. Minnows have been reduced to few and have it harder to rise to prominance.

  • i feel like now its easier to manipulate charts due to money + there only being 4 ish music charts contributes the fact of low paks

    ᴏɴ ʜɪᴀᴛᴜꜱ

    ɪᴠᴇ ᴛxᴛ ᴛᴡɪᴄᴇ ᴇɴʜʏᴘᴇɴ ᴛʀɪᴘʟᴇꜱ


    2a806ffe9815a47ac4e5534b70069637ce97908b.gifv

  • well yt chart wasnt there, which is a weekly chart

    so pak, wasnt just more accesible thru the week, it was also faster

    This


    For Day6 at least it was YouTube that took the longest so I do think this was the chart blocking many songs from getting a PAK which they would have gotten if YT Chart was not part of the criteria

  • It's far more easier today for Idol Fandoms to get their biases' PAKs and to block others getting PAKs than it was in the past where many Non-Idols were getting PAKs.


    We can make such a conclusion by the length that certain Idol Groups are getting PAKs, even if they aren't getting a PAK, their real time numbers are preventing others from doing that.

  • But such analysis does not matter, when it comes to IU.

    She PAKs whether it be 20+ charts or 4+, whether there are diverse acts competing, or just the corporate monsters.

Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!