If you had ability to kick out a member from groups for whatever reason you want, which idols would you kick out

None unless they were actively doing something negative to harm the group especially after consulting the other members of the group.

There's reason some of us are responsible for other people and others are not.

If you had your own business, you'd run it into the ground all by yourself with some of the people you listed.

kickin out the money makers in a group is pure blockberry creative behavior

only one member?
wish you include multiple members if not I remove so many  
especially NMIXX ,Loona and WJSN or even some older Gen GG

Lesserafim - Eunchae ( reason is after Garam kickout
pro Eunchae stans? is the most irritating for me aside from she my least favorite)

NewJeans - Hyein least favorite

Itzy - Chaeryeong least favorite

F(x) - w her look like their is a male in their line-up

Kara - Hara (out of respect I never say what the reason)

Momoland - Joe without her Momoland will consider a visual focus group

Aespa - Karina she the least pretty for me
then they became SES of the 4th Gen which is better
rather than boring Kwangya

Quote from thebadguy

For me

Lesserafim - chaewon (average visual of group will go up significantly)

Itzy - draw between ryujin ( try hard & annoying) and yuna (always acts stupid)

NewJeans - hyein (my least favourite member in group so bye)

Ive - wonyoung ( if i start listing reasons it will take me a hundred years probably)

Fromis_9 - jiwon ( she's crazy, mijoo level of crazy )

Aespa - Giselle ( average group visuals will go up and problematicness would go down significantly)

Stayc - J ( don't ask me why, i don't know)

Weeekly - monday ( she's awkward and acts the way that gives me really bad second hand embarrassment)

Display More

What about Gidle? I'd pick Shuhua, she has never really stood out to me in any capacity, i dont think they would miss a beat.

Quote from Michael-6

only one member?
wish you include multiple members if not I remove so many  
especially NMIXX ,Loona and WJSN or even some older Gen GG

Lesserafim - Eunchae ( reason is after Garam kickout
pro Eunchae stans? is the most irritating for me aside from she my least favorite)

NewJeans - Hyein least favorite

Itzy - Chaeryeong least favorite

F(x) - w her look like their is a male in their line-up

Kara - Hara (out of respect I never say what the reason)

Momoland - Joe without her Momoland will consider a visual focus group

Aespa - Karina she the least pretty for me
then they became SES of the 4th Gen which is better
rather than boring Kwangya

Display More

Karina? Wut? Are you insane? She is ROCKETING up my bias list right now with all the new fanservice content. I always thought she was the ace of Aespa with her vocals, rap and visuals, but i didnt realize just how charismatic and engaging she could be oncamera with her lives, variety show and other fanservice content. She's right up there in the top tier of biases with my fave Izone members, Mina, and Lisa.

Quote from BlackpinkHouse

Karina? Wut? Are you insane? She is ROCKETING up my bias list right now with all the new fanservice content. I always thought she was the ace of Aespa with her vocals, rap and visuals, but i didnt realize just how charismatic and engaging she could be oncamera with her lives, variety show and other fanservice content. She's right up there in the top tier of biases with my fave Izone members, Mina, and Lisa.

but agree on some fan post about how good Karina treat her fans etc
I admire it ..
but I already make an first impression in AESPA
I can't stand their Kwangya concept
also their style of resting bitch face on stage
I don't get that as a stage presence

personally
look at my list
Karina , Hara , Hyein and maybe Eunchae
those for look like similar beauty facial?
not ideally for me

Quote from BlackpinkHouse

What about Gidle? I'd pick Shuhua, she has never really stood out to me in any capacity, i dont think they would miss a beat.

100% bring back Soojin and drop the empty position

chaewon 🤨

Quote from doesitneedsaying

chaewon 🤨

I literally choked on my ayataka green tea when I read that

Quote from thebadguy

she's my least favorite in among the remaining gidle members

remaining?? someone else left gidle???

Quote from icyruios

I literally choked on my ayataka green tea when I read that

i wouldn't kick anyone but if my life depended on it she would be the last choice lol

The only one I would kick out of a group would be the Keeho from P1harmony just for the fact that FNC didn't kicked him after what had happend back in the days as he debuted

Quote from JiminieKookie

The only one I would kick out of a group would be the Keeho from P1harmony just for the fact that FNC didn't kicked him after what had happend back in the days as he debuted

those were proven false years ago

are you from blockberry creative ?

Min Heejin as NewJeans producer counts?

Quote from thebadguy

She's a troll and always savage, i find her funny. I'd kick minnie, she's my least favorite in among the remaining gidle members.

Well i assume we are talking about talented people right? funny does not translate on stage as well in her line of work