Why are people acting like as if noise accusations are brand new to kpop and no other group ever faced it.
Leave alone 3rd gen…..Are y’all telling me fantastic baby was soothing and calm? Tf lol.
Noisy kpop has ALWAYS been a hit and people have called a lot of kpop noisy over and over again. Your group isn’t special.
PS : being called noisy doesn’t mean I personally hate those songs so don’t go get your knickers in a twist over it.
Noise is noise. I don’t have a problem with what ppl label. But when ppl think this is some 4th gen exclusive or kpop is taking a direction for the worse well.
What happened?
Nobody in the 3rd Gen made bad noisy music like 4th gen groups do today, 4th gen groups obviously are running out of ideas so now they need to "experiment" with their lack luster music. Nobody in 3rd Gen made experimental terrible noisy music. Noisy doesn't equal edm, because edm isn't noisy its just edm. Noisy is when there's 20 different things going on in the song. Nobody in 3rd Gen was giving O.O by nmixx or Next Level by Misspa.
The closest thing BTS has to noisy music is probably Fire for a title track and I'm Fine and Dionysus for a b-side... and noisy as probably disjointed, I think when people complain about noisy music in kpop they're probably talking about hyperpop/experimental influences that have been kinda popular with gen z
The closest thing BTS has to noisy music is probably Fire for a title track and I'm Fine and Dionysus for a b-side... and noisy as probably disjointed, I think when people complain about noisy music in kpop they're probably talking about hyperpop/experimental influences that have been kinda popular with gen z
Maybe now in retrospect but there was discussions about being noisy just like this on forums for multiple pages. And people may do the same for these groups too in a few years as well.
Anyway idc about the actual definition of noise that’s a separate issue. But songs being labeled noise isn’t new in my experience.
What happened?
It’s Friday
Nobody in the 3rd Gen made bad noisy music like 4th gen groups do today, 4th gen groups obviously are running out of ideas so now they need to "experiment" with their lack luster music. Nobody in 3rd Gen made experimental terrible noisy music. Noisy doesn't equal edm, because edm isn't noisy its just edm. Noisy is when there's 20 different things going on in the song. Nobody in 3rd Gen was giving O.O by nmixx or Next Level by Misspa.
No.
We’re y’all on forums when Kill This Love was released even
The closest thing BTS has to noisy music is probably Fire for a title track and I'm Fine and Dionysus for a b-side... and noisy as probably disjointed, I think when people complain about noisy music in kpop they're probably talking about hyperpop/experimental influences that have been kinda popular with gen z
I thought Idol was pretty noisy, but I don't know if that was ever discussed. 
We’re y’all on forums when Kill This Love was released even
People even said D4 was noisy and messy. D4!!!
I thought Idol was pretty noisy, but I don't know if that was ever discussed.
For many pages
Lotto Kill This Love Hard Carry many songs had ppl calling it noisy and discussed for many pages
People even said D4 was noisy and messy. D4!!!
Absolutely.
Elle go away.
"Good noise" "noise done right" are the funniest terms Kpop stans have come up with in the recent months.
It sounds more like a cope mechanism.
Elle go away.
Spoke the truth and you cannot handle it. #itsokay #truth #repent
BTS & BP weren’t really ever called noise though. I think have some songs that are louder than usual. Not Today & KTL were the ones called loud, but their productions have always been very pristine and layered. Personally, I think what separates them is that there is a lot more nuances in their production. Say what you want, but BTS/BP will never simply give you a loud song from beginning to end. It will have bombastic chorus but the verses will be usually very punch in delivery or very melodic in singing. Plus both groups are pretty versatile as well sonically.
BTS & BP weren’t really ever called noise though. I think have some songs that are louder than usual. Not Today & KTL were the ones called loud, but their productions have always been very pristine and layered. Personally, I think what separates them is that there is a lot more nuances in their production. Say what you want, but BTS/BP will never simply give you a loud song from beginning to end. It will have bombastic chorus but the verses will be usually very punch in delivery or very melodic in singing. Plus both groups are pretty versatile as well sonically.
We lived very different forum lives
You’re saying this only in retrospect. These songs were definitely called noisy during their time
We lived very different forum lives
You’re saying this only in retrospect. These songs were definitely called noisy during their time
Only Not Today and Kill This Love were the ones I remember called noisy to an extent. Other examples like Fire and D4 was called disjointed and messy more than noisy. Before like 2019, it wasn’t really that much of a complaint. I mean, NCT wasn’t even called noisy until recently. But that’s how I remember it. Other people could view it different.
Like literally the current 4th gen quote marks noise makers quote marks such as skz and ateez were all compared to bts for their music style who were compared to bb themselves
But i guess with bb out of the scene and bts new music direction no one but 4th gen is really out there making quote marks noise music quote marks
Only Not Today and Kill This Love were the ones I remember called noisy to an extent. Other examples like Fire and D4 was called disjointed and messy more than noisy. Before like 2019, it wasn’t really that much of a complaint. I mean, NCT wasn’t even called noisy until recently. But that’s how I remember it. Other people could view it different.
I genuinely feel people forget how songs used to be perceived after it’s been a while and they were hits.
Blinks definitely used to fight the noise tag tbh.
We’re y’all on forums when Kill This Love was released even
yes. god that shit was brutal.
Like literally the current 4th gen quote marks noise makers quote marks such as skz and ateez were all compared to bts for their music style who were compared to bb themselves
But i guess with bb out of the scene and bts new music direction no one but 4th gen is really out there making quote marks noise music quote marks
Definitely.
yes. god that shit was brutal.
Made it to my Top 10 of the year tho. People were tasteless 🚶♀️🚶♀️🚶♀️🚶♀️🚶♀️🚶♀️
i think people are having amnesia
I dont think I ever hear a bts song being called noise, I think people dislike idol for the mv
for bp the only song that ever fall in that category is ktl and its bc of the trumpets (hence being used in the trucks protest thing outside yg 
) but aside from that its a more fluid beat and instrumental than any 4th gen gg has
the noise thing was more attached to only nct
The closest thing BTS has to noisy music is probably Fire for a title track and I'm Fine and Dionysus for a b-side... and noisy as probably disjointed, I think when people complain about noisy music in kpop they're probably talking about hyperpop/experimental influences that have been kinda popular with gen z
this
its not about the song being loud bc fire, ddu du ddu du, ktl, not today are all loud hype song
its about songs from new groups being disjointed, doesn't help the rappers in those songs are just not might to rap so the end result its just very poor
It’s the constant rewriting of history that gets me. Even if we want to ignore massively “noisy” tracks from everyone from TVXQ to f(x) in 2nd Gen, it’s the way people are like “oh song X is not noisy, it’s not ewwww noisy like song y” when song X very much had people clutching their pearls when it came out. I mean you can just do a quick internet search around noisy Kpop and see people tearing their hair and lamenting over Dalla Dalla and KTL and the impending noise apocalypse in Kpop as recently as 2019. (No, I don’t particularly think of those as “noisy”, but once upon a time, the “my ears are bleeding” crowd certainly did.)
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!
#ellenotetedtalk #speakingMYtruth #freakyfishy
