Ranking GGs in different categories

lol nah

Gidle and Blackpink have better vocals than izone is a joke.

Yuri >> Rose

sry blink

You lost me the bottom half, and twice better than itzy at dancing? in what world GROUP rankings

For some reason, I think ranking is fun. I think there might be something wrong with me LMAO

I'm going to have to leave Dreamcatcher out I haven't listened to their music enough.

Finally a normal thread

Singing

1. Red Velvet

2. Mamamoo

3. G(IDLE)

4. Aespa

5. Iz*one

6. Twice = Blackpink

7. Itzy

Dancing

1. Twice

2. Itzy

3. Iz*one

4. Mamamoo

5. Blackpink

6. Red Velvet

7. Aespa

Rapping (I feel that the SM groups are more focused on vocals, especially RV)

1. Mamamoo

2. Blackpink

3. Twice

4. Itzy

5. Iz*one

6. Aespa

7. Red Velvet

Song Quality

1. G(IDLE)

2. Red Velvet

3. Mamamoo

4. Blackpink

5. Twice = Iz*one

6. Itzy

7. Aespa

Ok

Quote from evo-evolution

You lost me the bottom half, and twice better than itzy at dancing? in what world GROUP rankings

I agree, I love Twice but the lead dancers are kind of stiff. I think that Itzy is a dancer group. Everyone in the group is great dancers.

Quote from Abozu

Gidle and Blackpink have better vocals than izone is a joke.

Yuri >> Rose

sry blink

But Rose always sings live. No shade to izone

Also this is op's opinion. No need to get worked out

I'm having a go, LOL

Singing: ( Haven't heard enough of aespa yet)

1. RV

2. Mamamoo

3. Aespa

4. G-Idle

5. BP

6. Dreamcatcher

7. Izone

8. Twice

9.Itzy

Dancing:

1. Itzy

2. Gidle

3. BP

4. izone

5. Twice

7. aespa

8. RV

8. Dreamcatcher

9. Mamamoo

Rap:

1. BP

2. G-Idle

3. Dreamcatcher

4. aespa

5. izone

6. Mamamoo

7. Itzy

8. RV = Twice (Both SUCKKKK)

Song quality:

1. Red velvet

2. aespa

3. BP

4. Twice

5. idle

6. izone

7. Itzy

8. Mamamoo

9. Dreamcatcher (Never listen to them)

Quote from rainbowblink224

I agree, I love Twice but the lead dancers are kind of stiff. I think that Itzy is a dancer group. Everyone in the group is great dancers.

I dont even think twice are that bad dancers the majority are over average dancers but Dahyun lets them down cause she's a very non energetic dancer, she tries to do moves with as less energy as possible, also Jeongyeon is not always insync with the rest. They're good enough though and itzy is a dance heavy group

ㅋ

so like basically just list your favourite and go..???

you're a joke

Quote from evo-evolution

rapping

4. aespa

6. Mamamoo

aespa only have giselle and mamamoo have moonbyul... they should be even below twice. she rapped in her teaser ONLY, thats not enough to put her above chaeyoung yet alone moonbyul

Quote from taesv6

aespa only have giselle and mamamoo have moonbyul... they should be even below twice.

Have you heard Giselle's rapping? and Karina as well who's a lead rapper? and what twice does isn't rap, I dont know what that is but it sure as hell isn't rap

#1 blackpink

Quote from evo-evolution

Have you heard Giselle's rapping? and Karina as well who's a lead rapper? and what twice does isn't rap, I dont know what that is but it sure as hell isn't rap

ive heard her rap, its decent, moonbyul could eat her when it comes to rapping lol

Quote from taesv6

ive heard her rap, its decent, moonbyul could eat her when it comes to rapping lol

I beg to differ! not only did Queen Giselle rap one of the best rap songs to ever exist (Poetic justice my husband kendrickkkkk) acapella with perfect flow and timing, she also raps in three different languages

Now I'll wait for you to name me one rapper in the world that can do this...

Quote from taesv6

ive heard her rap, its decent, moonbyul could eat her when it comes to rapping lol

it's One thing when you have good flow in one language but in three different languages and to mix up the lyrics and pronounce all languages perfectly whilst maintaining the flow..... Giselle is a bomb! She's so boss I love it

Quote from evo-evolution

Have you heard Giselle's rapping? and Karina as well who's a lead rapper? and what twice does isn't rap, I dont know what that is but it sure as hell isn't rap

and giselle's legit rap? and when did you hear karina's rapping? aespa stans are soo bold with the little content they have

i'm not gonna be hating, but i definitely disagree with a lot.

I think we'll need more content from them before any judgements are made

I rank groups I'm familiar with

Singing

1. RV

2. Mamamoo

3. Idle

4. Aespa

5. Twice/BP

7. ITZY

Dancing

1. Itzy

2. Izone

3. Twice/Aespa

5. Idle/RV/BP

8. Mamamoo

Rapping

1. Idle

2. BP

3. Mamamoo

4. Itzy

5. Twice

6. RV

Song quality (negative points for non-sensical & cute songs)

1. Idle

2. Twice/RV/BP

5. Izone/Itzy

6. Aespa

Quote from evo-evolution

I'm having a go, LOL

Singing: ( Haven't heard enough of aespa yet)

1. RV

2. Mamamoo

3. Aespa

4. G-Idle

5. BP

6. Dreamcatcher

7. Izone

8. Twice

9.Itzy

Dancing:

1. Itzy

2. Gidle

3. BP

4. izone

5. Twice

7. aespa

8. RV

8. Dreamcatcher

9. Mamamoo

Rap:

1. BP

2. G-Idle

3. Dreamcatcher

4. aespa

5. izone

6. Mamamoo

7. Itzy

8. RV = Twice (Both SUCKKKK)

Song quality:

1. Red velvet

2. aespa

3. BP

4. Twice

5. idle

6. izone

7. Itzy

8. Mamamoo

9. Dreamcatcher (Never listen to them)

Display More

Nice listing. But I would've put Red Velvet somewhere around 3 or 4 in the dancing list :)

Seulgi is Top 3 of 3rd gen dancers, and Seulgi & Irene's comeback has shown how solid and high level their dance skills are with Irene even equaling (and in some dance aspects even surpassing) 3rd gen's top tier dancer, while concerts like La Rouge have shown how solid, flexible and versatile RV's dancing as a group is.

Kindly correct that mistake in your dance ranking please, thank you

Quote from evo-evolution

I beg to differ! not only did Queen Giselle rap one of the best rap songs to ever exist (Poetic justice my husband kendrickkkkk) acapella with perfect flow and timing, she also raps in three different languages

Now I'll wait for you to name me one rapper in the world that can do this...

you want me to name a better rapper than her? easy.

Quote from evo-evolution

it's One thing when you have good flow in one language but in three different languages and to mix up the lyrics and pronounce all languages perfectly whilst maintaining the flow..... Giselle is a bomb! She's so boss I love it

so giselle is a better rapper than moonbyul because she can rap in 3 languages? thats like saying minnie can sing better than wendy because she can do it in 5 languages lol ( i like minne better as a vocalist but i dont think shes better ). well its your opinion so i cant really go against it, lets just stick to our opinions lol.

Quote from taesv6

so giselle is a better rapper than moonbyul because she can rap in 3 languages? thats like saying minnie can sing better than wendy because she can do it in 5 languages lol. well its your opinion so i cant really go against it, lets just stick to our opinions lol.

Yeah but you've left out where I said her rhythm and flow is always on time, she easily has strong western influences which majority kpop idols don't and just rap fast or with "swag" so if moonbyul could hit notes as effortlessly as Wendy but in 5 different languages then she automatically becomes a better singer, I dont know cause I dont listen to mamamoo like that but yeah makes sense

Quote from taesv6

you want me to name a better rapper than her? easy.

I asked for rappers with actual rap flow and not the out of breath talking or cringe five words sentence during or after a song but actual good flow and strong rhythm, THAT can rap in 3 or Moree languages fluently..... Waiting...

Quote from evo-evolution

Yeah but you've left out where I said her rhythm and flow is always on time, she easily has strong western influences which majority kpop idols don't and just rap fast or with "swag" so if moonbyul could hit notes as effortlessly as Wendy but in 5 different languages then she automatically becomes a better singer, I dont know cause I dont listen to mamamoo like that but yeah makes sense

nice opinion. go hear moonbyul rap. its just weird to put her above moonbyul with such little rap and 0 raps in their songs yet lol.

Quote from evo-evolution

I asked for rappers with actual rap flow and not the out of breath talking or cringe five words sentence during or after a song but actual good flow and strong rhythm, THAT can rap in 3 or Moree languages fluently..... Waiting...

lisa. fluent rap in thai, english, korean. there you go, is she not to good enough for giselle

Quote from taesv6

nice opinion. go hear moonbyul rap. its just weird to put her above moonbyul with such little rap and 0 raps in their songs yet lol.

Valid point but rap isn't the same as singing abilities, you only need a limited time to see how good someone is at rapping, then they can branch off with techniques and styles, expressions, creativity, rhyme etc Bare in mind I barely listen to moonbyul so I'm moving from a place of bias - ness LOL, I'll go listen to some mamamoo in a minute

Quote from evo-evolution

Bare in mind I barely listen to moonbyul so I'm moving from a place of bias - ness LOL,

there you go then. thats the answer.

Quote from taesv6

there you go then. thats the answer.

LOL it takes two, you have defo be bias as well

Quote from evo-evolution

LOL it takes two, you have defo be bias as well

dont stan neither. havent heard giselle rap enough for me to put her above moonbyul yet. simple. thats not biased lol.

Quote from evo-evolution

I'm having a go, LOL

Singing: ( Haven't heard enough of aespa yet)

1. RV

2. Mamamoo

3. Aespa

4. G-Idle

5. BP

6. Dreamcatcher

7. Izone

8. Twice

9.Itzy

Dancing:

1. Itzy

2. Gidle

3. BP

4. izone

5. Twice

7. aespa

8. RV

8. Dreamcatcher

9. Mamamoo

Rap:

1. BP

2. G-Idle

3. Dreamcatcher

4. aespa

5. izone

6. Mamamoo

7. Itzy

8. RV = Twice (Both SUCKKKK)

Song quality:

1. Red velvet

2. aespa

3. BP

4. Twice

5. idle

6. izone

7. Itzy

8. Mamamoo

9. Dreamcatcher (Never listen to them)

Display More

I don't think you should be putting a 3-month-old rookie group with 1 song at n.2 spot in song quality. Also, putting Aespa above TW and MMM in rapping? Maybe you just don't listen to those groups as much but knowing SM rapper's(Female mostly) are DEFINALTY not SM's strength, I don't think you should be putting Giselle higher than moonbyul and chaeyoung. The only one I do agree with is the singing category(I do think your a bit biased in that one) but I'm not really gonna argue with the rank Aespa(I do think your biased with there ranking to in singing) but Aespa are eating CDs and there only rookies so I can't really argue with that

Quote from thataurora

I don't think you should be putting a 3-month-old rookie group with 1 song at n.2 spot in song quality. Also, putting Aespa above TW and MMM in rapping? Maybe you just don't listen to those groups as much but knowing SM rapper's(Female mostly) are DEFINALTY not SM's strength, I don't think you should be putting Giselle higher than moonbyul and chaeyoung. The only one I do agree with is the singing category(I do think your a bit biased in that one) but I'm not really gonna argue with the rank Aespa(I do think your biased with there ranking to in singing) but Aespa are eating CDs and there only rookies so I can't really argue with that

I hear what you're saying sis but you're missing the post, technique wise chaeyoung is an amazing rapper that I dont question But the songs twice get do not show that off at all. I thought we were going with group based as opposed to individuals from groups etc groups. Therefore, the little I've heard aespa rap has been better in my opinion than the majority of all twice raps, plus irene and yeri aren't great rappers hence why I never placed them high, I didn't say sm were good with rappers but Giselle who so happens to be in SM is an amazing rapper as so Karina. And Girl you know my song quality is gonna be bias as hell

If anything song quality is subjective anyways, the same one song might not mean the same thing for two different people anyways

Quote from thataurora

I don't think you should be putting a 3-month-old rookie group with 1 song at n.2 spot in song quality. Also, putting Aespa above TW and MMM in rapping? Maybe you just don't listen to those groups as much but knowing SM rapper's(Female mostly) are DEFINALTY not SM's strength, I don't think you should be putting Giselle higher than moonbyul and chaeyoung. The only one I do agree with is the singing category(I do think your a bit biased in that one) but I'm not really gonna argue with the rank Aespa(I do think your biased with there ranking to in singing) but Aespa are eating CDs and there only rookies so I can't really argue with that

And no need for drama I dont go looking for trouble

I only get into arguments when people are straight up rude or disrespectful on aespa, it's an easy equation :)