good vocals aren't important if you don't sing live

Hit thread.

I think i can talk about it since my group fulfills the criteria.

no

I stan group who sing live. STAN TREASURE!

Singing Live isn't as important then you think

a singer should be able to sing live. end of the question.

In the West, it is an expectation. Some still do lip-sync if they are doing a lot on stage. I've been waiting for K-Pop groups to do more live, less backtracked singing a lot more often for a minute.

My faves cant relate lol

Sing live. You are a vocalist whose job is to sing. If not what else are you doing in the music industry?

I can understand if they have no control or input in their stage performances. But if it’s the artistes who don’t wanna sing live, I will feel cheated out of my money if I ever go for their concerts.

Anybody with an average voice will sound good after their vocals are well tuned during recordings. The only time fans can appreciate their vocals is when it’s live.

And I’ll rather hear my faves’ voice cracks. At least they make an effort to sing to their fans

True.

At the same time, most people like me only listen to recorded music so why should I care if they can sing good "live"?

But of cource I want them to be good live singers, it's just it's not very important for me.

It can sometimes be a bit fun to listen to older live perfomance when it was live and the techonlogy was not as good as it was today. You can get two reactions "Holy crap this sounds bad" or "Oh how nice to have geniun live vocals". Too often it sounded pretty bad.....

my faves can't relate !

Quote from Afriyieau1

Sing live. You are a vocalist whose job is to sing. If not what else are you doing in the music industry?

I can understand if they have no control or input in their stage performances. But if it’s the artistes who don’t wanna sing live, I will feel cheated out of my money if I ever go for their concerts.

Anybody with an average voice will sound good after their vocals are well tuned during recordings. The only time fans can appreciate their vocals is when it’s live.

And I’ll rather hear my faves’ voice cracks. At least they make an effort to sing to their fans

Display More

Ugh I agree and I’m so disappointed that vocals aren’t even a main thing anymore ??? Like I’m here to listen to music, but some can’t even sing like girl when I can hit the notes better I get so put off the group lmao and this lip syncing shit removes the novelty and it becomes boring, like yeah it’s nice to watch performances but I wanna hear some harmonies, some adlibs, but they can’t even do that cos they can’t sing and have to lip sync

Quote from zixzix

Ugh I agree and I’m so disappointed that vocals aren’t even a main thing anymore ??? Like I’m here to listen to music, but some can’t even sing like girl when I can hit the notes better I get so put off the group lmao and this lip syncing shit removes the novelty and it becomes boring, like yeah it’s nice to watch performances but I wanna hear some harmonies, some adlibs, but they can’t even do that cos they can’t sing and have to lip sync

Let poor me promote my boys. Stan TREASURE. Their vocals are amazing.

Quote from neixban

people talk about good vocals but if ur faves don't sing live then stop talking about vocals

proud to be an armyblink

Completely agree! thats why I wait to here a groups encore/ live to see if they can really sing or if they're famous for being pretty/ handsome. So far the groups ive seen that can actually sing are: (active groups won't mention all)

- Red velvet

- Mamamoo

- Gfriend

- NCT

- Blackpink

- aespa

- treasure

- secret number

- weekly

- enhypen

- Ateez

-Izone

- Apink

- Everglow

-oh my girl

My faves sing live and they can sing so

Is it about never singing live or lip syncing now and then? Because the latter applies to all groups (except maybe vocal focused groups or those with few content) no matter how their fans like to believe otherwise.

if you’re talking about groups who lip sync all the time and can’t sing live (which doesn’t make sense since good vocals allow you to sing with comfort so if they have good vocals they will be able to sing duh) there aren’t anyone I know tbh. There are those with not so good vocals that tend to lip sync but they also sang live before (obviously not great at it because again..duh..not having good vocals”)

it should also be able to SING LIVE DECENTLY

it's worst to lip sync, but it's also bad to sing live badly many times