Top 5 Girl groups digitally now?

  • Nah, nobody cares about index points now, i mean nobody cares that HYLT is 50 and Nonstop is 40 or whatever. People only care when the songs are released. Did the song reach #1 on Melon? How many weeks? How many weeks in the top 10?


    HYLT had 16 weeks in the top 10 and 3 weeks at #1. LSG had 22 weeks in the top 10 tying the alltime record for Kpop songs.


    How many weeks did Dolphin and Nonstop get at #1? Zero. How many weeks did they stay in top 10? 10 weeks? 12 weeks?

    you cant even compare them since nonstop was released when there was really strong competition, while the competition hylt had were only maria and yoo jae suk's group.


    people cared about hylt, but it aged badly. people cared about nonstop and dolphin too and it was memorable since they both have monster longevity.


    you need to understand having a hit song isnt just about hitting #1. aiiyl and pwf are undeniably bigger than both hylt and lsg, but did they hit #1? no. did they stay in the top 10 of gaon for more than 9 weeks? no

  • you cant even compare them since nonstop was released when there was really strong competition, while the competition hylt had were only maria and yoo jae suk's group.


    people cared about hylt, but it aged badly. people cared about nonstop and dolphin too and it was memorable since they both have monster longevity.


    you need to understand having a hit song isnt just about hitting #1. aiiyl and pwf are undeniably bigger than both hylt and lsg, but did they hit #1? no. did they stay in the top 10 of gaon for more than 9 weeks? no

    I think you undetstated HYLT too much.

    The song appeared in Gallup top10 song in 2020 while OMG wasnt there. This speaks for korean more than we can.


    The song might have higher burn out rate than non stop / dolphin, but doesnt mean the song wasnt bigger. Moreover, BP has newer release LSG on chart + Rosé solo on top30. And BP has been silent for quite a while. Their last activity in korea was in 2020 excluding Rosé solo.


    And it is delusional to think pwf / aiiyl was bigger than HYLT, when HYLT is breaking records before melon reform, after reform, chart super well on korean youtube chart and even on gallup top10.


    We have yet to see how good is HYLT longevity but so far the song is almost 1 year on chart. It is impressive. OMG is a rising group, i think their songs will stay on chart much longer as they didnt have explosive start but very good longevity, i.e. constantly attracting new listeners to their songs, keeping their songs longer on chart.

  • people cared about hylt, but it aged badly. people cared about nonstop and dolphin too and it was memorable since they both have monster longevity.

    Everything nonstop achieved hylt did it faster. And hylt is still very much in top100. Why r u acting like it left the charts? Dolphin still hasn't caught up to nonstop itself.

    Nonstop and dolphin r huge but hylt was bigger. Let's not forget it topped the charts too. Why should it be taken away from its achievement due to longevity which is not even bad? More weeks in top10 too.

    Also it was memorable considering it was on gallup.

    need to understand having a hit song isnt just about hitting #1. aiiyl and pwf are undeniably bigger than both hylt and lsg, but did they hit #1? no. did they stay in the top 10 of gaon for more than 9 weeks? no

    This would make d4 a smaller hit in front of aiiyl and pwf. Which is not true. Longevity isn't everything. Hylt is bigger than aiiyl and pwf. Mind u hylt will most probably stay longer on the charts than pwf. Don't think its doing lesser number of weeks than it.

    And why wouldn't lsg be bigger than all these song considering it has longevity that u give so much importance to? Lsg spent 22 weeks in top10 itself.

    ..:* :**:. .:**:.*.:.

    04434535149d480644979509a033f1412f0a8b79.gifv 9f94f4554694478127beddde683e313fd35bd916.gifv 96bd481068553f584de446481c17bf31d11a505c.gifv

    Edited 2 times, last by atropos ().

  • I'm just pointing out that most of them don't really listen to idol groups at all.

    You do not need to point it, because I have already do it. If you had taken the time to read my previous post maybe.


    I'll help you :

    I said old people in Korea probably prefer songs coming from Twice, MMM, or RV. Eldery in Korea love cute concept. It doesn't mean they buy the albums or stream the songs.

    You saw it now ? it's ok ? So we're agree on this point i guess. :pepe-use-head:

    Not the first time I've seen you making negative comments about BP.

    So When I say that BP has a bigger fanbase than RV & MMM it is negative?

    Or saying BP don't get the GP support because GP means all the people so it's also include elderly it's negative ?


    43724deb70139932dd8ddd92005e3ebc.jpeg


    (it's Iz*one then Twice for ggs actually, btw!)?

    I believe you. And if you take the time to reread my posts you will see that I have never affirmed anything. And besides Iz * one no longer exists.

  • A resurrected thread?


    Hmm, it depends I guess.


    Based on this year's, 2021 performance, I'd say:

    1. Brave Girls

    2. Aespa

    3. Oh My Girl

    4. TWICE

    5. STAYC


    Based on the international digital performance of the past 1-2 years:

    1. BP

    2. TWICE

    3. Red Velvet

    4. ITZY

    5. I-dle?


    Based on Korean digital charts performance of the past 1-2 years:

    1. BP

    2-3. Oh My Girl / Brave Girls

    4-5. Red Velvet / TWICE

Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!