[instiz] IS SEULGI A BAD SINGER?


    [instiz] IS SEULGI A BAD SINGER?


    AVvXsEjdzbtc3R0cUtVLIvnnpfSr94HF3wOKabYH_9xRKOBnlz-Ochrv8lgSjt5i5p_JOb9oK5lXWOy0gwDsup6X_t9Df4Poni1QjIfUSVv5f8_F0-YJ68z7PFQvW0Ono1IY3uLkdFRYSkhplivBpkUSAcTR6eoCPvMmBnj24T--eYQeOyx_jw5yzEphI_fp6mYL=s16000

    External Content x.com
    Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.
    Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.


    original post: here


    1. Oh.... She really can't sing


    2. She's tone deaf... Why is her nasally voice so severe?


    3. Both of them can't sing


    4. Rather than Seulgi not being able to sing, this is my first time hearing something like that about her


    5. Seulgi is good, but it's true that she's bad here...


    6. ? I thought Sungchan was the bad one here?


    7. Hmmm ㅋㅋ How can I put this


    8. I always thougth Seulgi was a good singer... It looks like Sungchan is the issue here


    9. It looks like neither of them can harmonize, I'm curious about the original version of the song ㅋㅋㅋ


    10. The guy is worse

    Anyone who thinks this deserves a slap on the face.


    Girl has a body of work stretching 10 years and has never been a bad singer.


    Anyone remember her legendary Rookie performance where she got handed a working mic half way through the performance then slayed the rest of it?


    She's a queen, and wholesome AF.


    I won't stand for Seulgi slander.


    External Content www.youtube.com
    Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.
    Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

    Her vocal color and technique is not optimal for all songs. I think this was one of them

    And then the legendary encore happened. Seulgi handled it like a pro and sang well.

    I mean, she's obviously not Wendy, she's an average vocalist, but saying she's bad it's being dumb as hell.


    This song just doesn't suit her range, that's all. Also, this is SMTownLive 2025, even Idols didn't gaf about it.😂


    Both of them are literally fighting with the loud ass backtrack, btw.


    External Content x.com
    Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.
    Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

  • AllKill VIP
    Quote from Popper-of-Ks

    She is far from "average." This is Kpop, David, not a friggin' opera. She could easily be most groups' main vocalist. This whole thing is clickbait.

    AGAIN! Being AVERAGE doesn't mean you're bad! Especially in Kpop! I don't get why some people think "AVERAGE" is a degrading word. Just because this is Kpop doesn't mean everyone who's actually a great singer is on the same level with Opera singers.


    Read this, please!


    Red Velevet’s Seulgi Vocal Analysis


    Red Velevet’s Seulgi Vocal Analysis-[IMG=A4V]<br>[BCU]Seulgi’s Vocal Analysis<br>[IMG=C0B]<br>[BCU]Vocal Range</p> <p>C#3 ~ D6 (3 octaves an

    I don't have to think "average" means "bad," you schmuck, because she's objectively neither. And no, I'm not reading your propaganda.

    You: she's an average vocalist :SCREEECH:


    Why is that relevant enough to be pointed out each time? She's a good vocalist and thats all that matters, summing her vocal skills up to "average" is a form of degrading her skills.


    All of MAMAMOO are average vocalists.

    Quote from CaraFIMIE

    You: she's an average vocalist :SCREEECH:


    Why is that relevant enough to be pointed out each time? She's a good vocalist and thats all that matters, summing her vocal skills up to "average" is a form of degrading her skills.


    All of MAMAMOO are average vocalists.

    Why did I say she's an average vocalist? Because the thread is actually about her vocal skills.


    She's average! It's not degrading at all. It literally means, she's good enough to be a Lead-Vocalist in a vocal group like RV, and that's why she's a Lead Vocalist in RV. No one is degrading her skills!


    MAMAMOO are anything but average vocalists.


    Here are 3 reviews about their vocals. Only 3 because this was written in 2016 and back then Byul didn't do much as a vocalist, even tho she's an SME trainee.


    SPOILER: All 3 were rated Above-Average! 😉


    Now they are on a much higher level, especially Solar, since her Musical era. And yes, even Seulgi is better, so technically she could be an Above-Average now.

    Edited once, last by David33 ().

    :meme-stare:

    Mamamoo are good enough to be vocalists in a vocal group. That means they're all average.


    Your screwy "logic," not mine. But I'm not letting you have it both ways.

    Quote from CaraFIMIE

    :meme-stare:

    Why bother to reply if you don't say anything. This is why I don't like arguing about vocals with Kpop stans, you don't know anything about it, and when someone speaking facts, you ignore it.


    Quote from Popper-of-Ks

    Mamamoo are good enough to be vocalists in a vocal group. That means they're all average.


    Your screwy "logic," not mine. But I'm not letting you have it both ways.

    It's not MY logic you dummy, it's the logic of actual VOCAL COACHES, and as you can read it, everyone in Mamamoo are above average, or at least were in their ROOKIE years. Now, they're much better!


    There are categories for a reason! Below-Average, Average, and Above-Average is not the same category, my friend!


    You can see the difference between Seulgi, MAMAMOO, Wendy and Taeyeon! Plus I will add the best female Kpop vocalist too, Ailee!


    Red Velvet’s Vocal Analysis: Wendy: Proficient Vocalist (Competent)


    Girls’ Generation’s Vocal Analysis: Taeyeon: Competent Vocalist


    Ailee’s Vocal Analysis: Good to Great Vocalist


    This is the last time I did research for you, I'm not wasting more time on people who don't want to learn these things, but still acting they know what they're talking about!

    A couple things:


    1. YOU said she was both "average" and "good enough to be a lead vocalist in a vocal group," NOT some vocal coach I couldn't care less about. If you want to apply that logic to Seulgi, I can damn well apply the same logic to Mamamoo.


    2. Vocal coaches are just like anyone else, they have both opinions and ass holes, and they both stink. In other words, stop trying to spread this person's subjective opinion like it's gospel.

    Quote from Popper-of-Ks

    A couple things:


    1. YOU said she was both "average" and "good enough to be a lead vocalist in a vocal group," NOT some vocal coach I couldn't care less about. If you want to apply that logic to Seulgi, I can damn well apply the same logic to Mamamoo.


    2. Vocal coaches are just like anyone else, they have both opinions and ass holes, and they both stink. In other words, stop trying to spread this person's subjective opinion like it's gospel.

    You want an Award for talking nonsense? Sorry, I can't give you any, but hey, at least you know, you're talking nonsense! 😂


    You don't even understand simple words, and you didn't make any valid argument, just tried to discredit the analysis of the professionals. Yes, Seulgi is average, and she's good enough to be a Lead, but that doesn't mean she's a "GOOD VOCALIST", it's not the same thing, my guy!


    Vocal Analysis are NOT opinions. It's literally the same thing when you go somewhere buying a car, and you read the details about the car. It's not an opinion, it's FACT, based on what a car can do! Simple as that! And the funny things, just like singers, even a care be better if you replace something in it, and singers can develop if they want! I literally said Seulgi could be an ABOVE-AVERAGE vocalist now, but I won't write a whole book about it, because you're too lazy to read it, and you don't understand it anyway.

    Quote from David33

    You want an Award for talking nonsense? Sorry, I can't give you any, but hey, at least you know, you're talking nonsense! 😂


    You don't even understand simple words, and you didn't make any valid argument, just tried to discredit the analysis of the professionals. Yes, Seulgi is average, and she's good enough to be a Lead, but that doesn't mean she's a "GOOD VOCALIST", it's not the same thing, my guy!


    Vocal Analysis are NOT opinions. It's literally the same thing when you go somewhere buying a car, and you read the details about the car. It's not an opinion, it's FACT, based on what a car can do! Simple as that! And the funny things, just like singers, even a care be better if you replace something in it, and singers can develop if they want! I literally said Seulgi could be an ABOVE-AVERAGE vocalist now, but I won't write a whole book about it, because you're too lazy to read it, and you don't understand it anyway.

    According to my professional analysis, your entire argument is one big, misguided appeal to authority, whether real or imagined, and is objectively about as valuable as a piece of lint.

    Quote from David33

    Why bother to reply if you don't say anything. This is why I don't like arguing about vocals with Kpop stans, you don't know anything about it, and when someone speaking facts, you ignore it.

    I don't like arguing in general and you can't be "speaking facts" when your "facts" come from a place of blatantly obvious bias.

    Quote from David33

    You don't even understand simple words, and you didn't make any valid argument, just tried to discredit the analysis of the professionals. Yes, Seulgi is average, and she's good enough to be a Lead, but that doesn't mean she's a "GOOD VOCALIST", it's not the same thing, my guy!


    Vocal Analysis are NOT opinions. It's literally the same thing when you go somewhere buying a car, and you read the details about the car. It's not an opinion, it's FACT, based on what a car can do! Simple as that! And the funny things, just like singers, even a care be better if you replace something in it, and singers can develop if they want! I literally said Seulgi could be an ABOVE-AVERAGE vocalist now, but I won't write a whole book about it, because you're too lazy to read it, and you don't understand it anyway.

    If you think being a MAMAMOO stan gives you the nerve to be speaking on the vocal capabilities of others then you're wrong. She IS A "GOOD VOCALIST" and no amount of your denial will change that.


    Aint no way you fr comparing a vocal analysis to car manual :skull::skull:


    A vocal analysis can be an opinion because the professional's analysis is based on THEIR experience and education. Those professional likely have never worked with her in person nor are aware of the physical and internal voice indicators that can affect her vocal capabilities. They are going solely based off of their experience and what they see on the internet.


    Not saying their experience is invalid but that doesn't mean its entirely dependable, either.


    And i will say this again, idols are not just singers!!


    I don't even get what gives you the right to be making such judgemental comments about her and her vocals when you can't even do half the things she does.

    Quote from CaraFIMIE

    I don't like arguing in general and you can't be "speaking facts" when your "facts" come from a place of blatantly obvious bias.


    If you think being a MAMAMOO stan gives you the nerve to be speaking on the vocal capabilities of others then you're wrong. She IS A "GOOD VOCALIST" and no amount of your denial will change that.


    Aint no way you fr comparing a vocal analysis to car manual :skull::skull:

    Did you bother to actually read those reviews? If not, stop talking! I said this many times, my mother is a vocal coach, I worked with singers, and I can see if a random review online was written by an actual professional or not. All of those are well-written and detailed analysis! Not just some random fan, wrote: "Oh, she's the best."


    This is the reason I can talk about vocals, not because I'm a Mamamoo, Taeyeon or Wendy stan. I have the knowledge, just like the people who wrote those reviews. The only one who's in denial is you! A typical fan who can only accept the same opinion, and in this case want to ignore actual facts, because it doesn't suit their agenda.


    Vocals and cars are pretty much the same, my friend. Both can be developed into a better one! That's my point! If you can't understand a simple analogy like this, I'm not wasting my time on you, either.


    Quote

    A vocal analysis can be an opinion because the professional's analysis is based on THEIR experience and education. Those professional likely have never worked with her in person nor are aware of the physical and internal voice indicators that can affect her vocal capabilities. They are going solely based off of their experience and what they see on the internet.


    Not saying their experience is invalid but that doesn't mean its entirely dependable, either.

    So, now you're saying being a vocal coach or a vocalist is based on personal experience? It's like saying learning to read can be different to everyone. No, you learn the same thing. You may need more time to learn to read, but the skills are the same.


    You don't have to work with a singer, to understand the level of their skills. Again, you're saying, a vocal coach can't do a real analysis if they don't work with them in person. It's like saying, you can only know if a car is fast if you're driving it! That's not how these things work.


    The funny thing is, if I say, Seulgi is an amazing vocalist, you would agree, so this instantly makes your argument invalid! You're only arguing with me, because what those vocal coaches and me saying is different from what you think.

    Quote

    And i will say this again, idols are not just singers!!


    I don't even get what gives you the right to be making such judgemental comments about her and her vocals when you can't even do half the things she does.

    We are talking about VOCAL SKILLS, the rest doesn't matter.


    What gives me the right is that this is a Forum and everyone can have an opinion, and the topic is about Seulgi and her vocal skills. Also, I have the background to know if someone is a good singer or not. Not to mention, I'm not judgemental, I didn't say she's crap, I said, she's AVERAGE, and you're acting like I hate her, when I'm literally a Reveluv.😂


    Lastly: It doesn't matter what I can do! I can judge anything I want, I don't have to be a Formula 1 driver to know which car or driver is the best!


    Side note: The fact that SME put Seulgi in the LEAD-VOCALIST position, means she's not the best vocalist in the group! But, hey, maybe you know better than them as well.😂

    Edited once, last by David33 ().

    Quote from David33

    Did you bother to actually read those reviews? If not, stop talking! I said this many times, my mother is a vocal coach, I worked with singers, and I can see if a random review online was written by an actual professional or not. All of those are well-written and detailed analysis! Not just some random fan, wrote: "Oh, she's the best."

    So...NOT a vocal coach, and NOT a professional singer?? Got it :finger-heart:

    Quote from David33

    Vocals and cars are pretty much the same, my friend. Both can be developed into a better one! That's my point! If you can't understand a simple analogy like this, I'm not wasting my time on you, either.

    Bad analogy, actually. To develop a car into a "better" one, you would have to redesign and reconstruct, consider all the trade-offs between the changes you are making and the pre-exisiting features of the car, etc, and THEN come out with a new model which is very costly and is a risk to take if the new model does not sit well with consumers.


    And no, they are not very much the same. Vocal ability is very subjective and the only thing way a car is remotely similar in that way is that you buy a car based on preference.

    Quote from David33

    I'm not judgemental

    Why lie

    Quote from David33

    I said, she's AVERAGE

    Again, why is this relevant enough to include?


    The haters are calling her a bad singer based on one incident and instead of saying something in her defense (supposedly being a reveluv), you're basically reducing her skills and talents to "average."


    If there were any of those haters on here, they would've taken your words and ran with it, with the opinion that she's no better than most idols even though, like you said, she's "good enough to be a lead vocalist in a vocal group." Why would she be lead vocalist if she is simply "average"??!

    Btw I know who Ahmin is lol ( I think it was his name right?) I've talked to him a few times lol


    There is a reason why he stopped doing vocal analysis and ranking idol vocals so kpop fans don't use it to weaponize and lowkey for fanwars. That vocal analysis blog haven't been updated in ages tho. It has been so long but some people improved, other regressed so we don't really know their progress at the moment. According to what he said a while back Taeyeon vocal technique had gotten better . She is a much better vocalist than when she when she was a rookie. so who's to say other idols can't improve?

  • This thread contains 48 more posts that have been hidden for guests, please register yourself or login to continue reading.

Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!

Register Yourself Login