Between Le Sserafim and NewJeans, which group has the worst vocals?

Which concert would you pay to go see lip sync?

NewJeans aren't catching any heat for weak vocals. Stop it.

They're extremely stable during their encore stage, especially Hanni

As a chaewon and hanni stan, all i know is i never lose 😴

Anyway what a tasteless, tackily made thread. Almost as trashy as that thread earlier by that deranged mamamoo stan. That fandom is too infested with weirdos with a superiority complex it’s embarrassing to witness as a fellow mamamoo fan

Lesserafim. New Jeans' vocals are okay, they don't sound terrible during encores, they just have really mediocre live singing. But Lesserafim's singing is just bad.

Both groups have their own strength and weakness.

While I think LSF girls have great individualism and dance well as a team, their vocals don't complement each other. There's a wide gap in skills that it's hard to go unnoticed in their songs. Hybe probably didn't focus on vocals synergy while picking the members because they wanted quick success from existing fanbase of PD48/Izone.

New Jeans members' composition is better than LSF, both visuals and vocals wise (by this I mean they look and sound more like a team, if that makes sense). But this also means they lack individualism that LSF have.

I won't comment on their music because that's more about preferences. But IMO, New Jeans' songs suit their voices more than LSF suit theirs.

Quote from whips

As a chaewon and hanni stan, all i know is i never lose 😴

Anyway what a tasteless, tackily made thread. Almost as trashy as that thread earlier by that deranged mamamoo stan. That fandom is too infested with weirdos with a superiority complex it’s embarrassing to witness as a fellow mamamoo fan

What on earth does this thread have to do with MooMoos? Huh?

Where did the NewJeans bad vocals claims come from? They're not vocal power houses by any means but their vocals are quite nice.

IU put Hyein on her album after listening to her sing for 15 seconds and people want to pretend like NewJeans have bad vocals? Huh?

NJ is honestly pretty good for a kpop group. Haein, Danielle, and Hanni are all better than average.

Nmixx. Awful

More evidence of NewJeans having "poor vocals" when Danielle performed her version of the Little Mermaid song live in Mexico

Quote from YamaChwan

What on earth does this thread have to do with MooMoos? Huh?

Just a tangential observation this thread reminded me of Not an alien concept to go off on a tangent, as you’re aware, considering that that user brings up mamamoo in literally 95%+ of their posts when mamamoo had absolutely nothing to do with the topic at hand, every single time. It’s honestly a talent lol. I’m practically a newborn compared to their skills, let me live

Quote from OnceMidzy4ever

Nmixx. Awful

External Content www.youtube.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

damn.... that was atrocious

Quote from whips

Just a tangential observation this thread reminded me of Not an alien concept to go off on a tangent, as you’re aware, considering that that user brings up mamamoo in literally 95%+ of their posts when mamamoo had absolutely nothing to do with the topic at hand, every single time. It’s honestly a talent lol. I’m practically a newborn compared to their skills, let me live

I've been dethroned as the most problematic MooMoo this year and I don't know how to feel about it

Lesserafim

LE SSERAFIM

NJ by far.

Quote from YamaChwan

I've been dethroned as the most problematic MooMoo this year and I don't know how to feel about it

I'm very really sorry, mate. But conglats for being the best for many long years.🤣

Quote from whips

Just a tangential observation this thread reminded me of Not an alien concept to go off on a tangent, as you’re aware, considering that that user brings up mamamoo in literally 95%+ of their posts when mamamoo had absolutely nothing to do with the topic at hand, every single time. It’s honestly a talent lol. I’m practically a newborn compared to their skills, let me live

I'm still a rookie compared to other fandom members, and you started it now, not me.🤣

If I say NewJeans is miles better, I'm a HYBE stan?🤔

Quote from Blossomin88

They're always getting flak for being mediocre, with really simple songs. Discussions about their vocals trend every comeback, and criticism of their vocals is common, even on this site. The fact that they come from Hybe, which is already criticized a lot because of this, and often lip-sync or use backing tracks, obviously just strengthens this reputation further. Whether it's just a hate train or not, well, it exists.

I think the criticism comes from the style/genre of the songs, not the girls' vocals. I've never seen them being dragged for bad vocals on encores. As for overuse of lipsync, it's an issue of the entire industry not exclusive to Hybe groups.

Quote from killthisfenty

NJ by far.

Indefensibly stupid opinion

Le sserafim except Yunjin cause she’s the only member that has the best vocals out of the whole group.

NJ’s vocals is by far average.

Quote from YamaChwan

Indefensibly stupid opinion

Girl I dont know I thought it was who has the best vocals. Don’t be rude I was praising NJ for once

i thought they sucked equally

At least all of NJ can hold a note. Sakura, Eunchae, and Kazuha are not as good as Hyein, Danielle, Haerin. The weakest vocal in NJ is probably Minji, and she's a little better than Kazuha imo

Quote from killthisfenty

Girl I dont know I thought it was who has the best vocals. Don’t be rude I was praising NJ for once

This is a far more acceptable opinion. I accept the revision

As much as i like Lesserafim and love to hate on NewJeans i would take NewJeans's vocals any day, they are pretty mediocre vocalist but they at least don't sound horrible, they are just weak

Sakura is my bias from Lesserafim but she really can't sing so Lesserafim arw worse

NewJeans' vocal skills is understimated actually

why are newjeans getting called bad vocalists? i mean sure nobody is particularly strong vocally, but theyre all average vocalists and can do a good live performance.

LSF is worse...but i cant differentiate NJ's voice from each other...as the saying goes" they all sound the same"

NJ was awesome at Lolapalooza

LSF was good during Grammy Museum performance of Perfect Night. We shall see how they do at Coachella.

nj has hanni that can singish

haerin can sing i think, just never puts anything into it, the other 3 are passable

lsf only has chaewon, eunchae and yunjin are passable, sakura cant sing at all, kazuha is pretty

Quote from stxrrynight

Le sserafim except Yunjin cause she’s the only member that has the best vocals out of the whole group.

NJ’s vocals is by far average.

you gotta watch more lsf then, yunjin has been one of the biggest disappointments imo from trainee to idol

In terms of live singing, and which group has most stability might be lesserafim. so i agree with newjeans. but, at the same time, the two groups work hard and im fine with all their preformances by now because they are atleast trying their best and theyre still quite new?

Quote from Disturbia

you gotta watch more lsf then, yunjin has been one of the biggest disappointments imo from trainee to idol

That’s understandable. The thing is, I only listen to the group’s songs (like how I do with almost every group) but I don’t pay attention to anything else outside of that, so I wouldn’t know how much an idol has gotten better or worse in a particular skill as time comes.