Twice/BlackPink/Red Velvet/Mamamoo/GFRIEND or NewJeans/IVE/LE SSERAFIM/(G)I-DLE/aespa?

3rd gen girl groups because their music is better.

Quote from DaisyTheGenuine

Mamamoo is the weak link so 4th gen

I see you, you're working hard, huh? You don't want to give me that 1000 Akorn, eh? I won't take the bait, honey.🤣

Quote from YamaChwan

Mamamoo raises the floor and ceiling of any list they're a part of. I see what you're trying to do with this shady comment

Don't worry, she's doing it because she's afraid she has to give me 1000 Akorn if I won't mention one group for 2 weeks.🤣

Also, of course it's 3rd gen, this isn't even a real competition. Cakes and Radishes ruling Kpop! GFriend is good too, too.

The first ones because RV are my ults and vocally RV, Yuju and Mamamoo clear all of 4th gen.

Quote from YamaChwan

You can't listen to Melting or Yellow Flower and tell me that's not amazing music. Not to mention Reality in Black

Purple is by far the superior album.

I want to vote for the old team, but i dot want to vote for Mamamoo. What i can do?

Mamamoo's inclusion made this a much harder decision than it should've been, but I ultimately went with the third gen groups, because even that handicap couldn't keep them down. 4th gen is pretty meh by comparison.

Quote from YamaChwan

Mamamoo's music is more respected in Korea than Twice's

I like 3 groups from each generation, so is a draw for me.

Quote from YamaChwan

You can't listen to Melting or Yellow Flower and tell me that's not amazing music. Not to mention Reality in Black

Quote from butterbutterfly

Purple is by far the superior album.

See? THIS is why I LOVE Mamamoo! I don't think I've ever met someone who mentioned the same album as their favorite. Even in the fandom. That's good, that means they're versatile! For that alone, you can't say they're the weakest link DaisyTheGenuine. One thing not liking their music, even tho there are more than 200 song, but that doesn't mean they're the weakest. It means you have a different taste in music, and you probably didn't even hear 80% of their songs.

For me these are the best 3 Mamamoo albums in order: Melting, WAW, Reality in Black. I'm a sucker for ballads, but Yellow Flower EP is next to RIB.

Quote from DaisyTheGenuine

No, for what?

Quote from DaisyTheGenuine

External Content youtu.be

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

I prefer third generation girl groups music to fourth generation girl groups in general. My favorite Kpop groups are Red Velvet and Mamamoo. I also find Twice and Gfriend music fantastic and I like Blackpink.

3rd gen music is better, especially earlier 3rd gen.

Then somewhere along the way, companies decided that they wanted to own all rights to songs, the quality dropped.

I would've picked 3rd gen if it were BP/Twice/RV/ Gfriend/OMG

So which one do you choose between Mamamoo and Newjeans?

I pick MMM, RV & (G)I-DLE

This is not straightforward for me

A tier:

I love NJ and like RV. I could elaborate further but I simply enjoy both groups

B tier:

I enjoy LSRF a lot as performers and their discography is good, I think the group lack of strong musical identity and lacking of vocal skills are preventing me to jump in them for good

Mamamoo is amazing live and have good songs, I think they comes next. However they subtle change in music direction post the 4 seasons project was a turn off for me which decreased them from A to B tier

C tier:

Neutral towards Gfriend. They are talented and gave many good songs but their career is largely redundant

G Idle is... alright I guess? They used to be much better. I appreciate their efforts to be different than other groups both musically and conceptually and the fact they are self produced surely deserves praise but otherwise same opinion of GFriend, talented group I simply don't care for

D tier:

Aespa discography is one of the worst among Big 4 girlies. IVE is just basic and boring. They are in the bottom of the list. But so are Twice and Blackpink. I will still choose BP and Twice over Aespa and IVE. Those groups are iconic at least, can't say the same about IVE and Aespa

In all I will choose the 3rd gen, simply because I can't think anything positive on Aespa and IVE to choose over TWICE and Blackpink

4th gen since there are more groups in there that I fav than the third gen

If TWICE and BP are the book ends of Concepts where every other GG Concept of the 3rd gen fits in between then the 4th Gen lacks a BP as NJ's is probably the TWICE Concept equal but there is no BP Concept version, just a whole lot of pretenders.

We also saw this with SNSD and 2Ne1 which I consider the strongest generation of Kpop GGs, so there is hope that NJ's will find thier BP/2Ne1

i chose 4th gen bcs i love ive, lesserafim and aespa's music

You could put any other group in the 3rd gen line instead of mamamoo and it would have been better like EXID/ Momoland/oh my girl/IOI/izone/ gidle... anyway, the 3th generation will always be my final answer

The first choice because it has the most amount of my favorites.

Impossible choice. Both options have great as well as shit groups. Voted 3rd gen with a slight advantage.

they don't play in the same league

Hmm blackpink has 4 good songs bexause they have 5 songs. Red velvet’s quality declined by like a lightyear after wendys fall. Twice has always been hit or miss title wise for me, and they were always miss after Itzy was born essentially. Mamamoo i dont even care about. G-friend i only love Navillera and Mago.

4th gen 100%

this is hard af bc I know that RV, Gfriend and Twice have sm bops, but I dislike Mamamoo and BP

For 4th gen, I dislike only (G)-IDLE

I'll go with 4th

Quote from ellenote

3rd gen girl groups because their music is better.

this