f(x) or Red Velvet or aespa?

I love cake, so Red Velvet. She's my cake!

pasted-from-clipboard.pngpasted-from-clipboard.png

aespa.

Obviously red velvet any day of the week.

I will go with neither

Red Velvet & aespa.

I only know some f(x) songs:

Red Light

4 Walls
Signal

Quote from DaisyTheGenuine

As a group: f(x)>> red velvet>> aespa

Vocally: aespa> f(x)> red velvet

Titles: aespa> red velvet> f(x)

Discography: red velvet>>f(x)>>>>>>>>>> >>>aespa

Visually:red velvet> f(x)> aespa

As performers: Luna>Seulgi

Display More

someone strip this persons posting privileges

Red Velvet has amazing discography, concepts, visuals and singers . They get my vote

f(x) has 2 great albums and one good album, don't like their other songs. Their discography is short, the group is unbalanced in terms of talent and their stylish and visuals was inconsistent. Good group nonethless

Don't like Aespa music or concept, so they are the easy third place for me

Red Velvet mostly due to their Velvet side

Aespa > RV > Fx

I like all the groups, music, concepts, but Aespa's members stand out more individually.

aespa!

Red Velvet. I am not biased.

red velvet > aespa > f(x)

My fav

it used to be f(x) but these days its RV

aespa just aren't innovating their sound enough, it's been like 4 years already

Quote from naanoway

someone strip this persons posting privileges

Thank God, I didn't say this, but I wanted to. 🤣 Wendy alone, ending everyone as a vocalist.

I love all 3, btw.

Red Velvet with a small margin to F(X). Aespa is not even close imo.

Wendy and Luna are amazing, probably the best SM vocalists along with Tayeoen (I know there are some The Grace girls but I know nothing about them)

Seulgi is good

Joy and Krystal are competent

The other members are nothing to write home about

I don't think I have listen Aespa singing live outside of Coachella so I can't rate them, but Ninging and Winter are probably bellow Wendy and Luna and above Seulgi

Quote from DaisyTheGenuine

Just going by fan representation on here, f(x) barely has fans, I never expected them to come close to 2nd fr

Actually Luna is best. Wenseul are a stronger duo tho

I judge groups vocally not just by their best but also their worst. NingNing is the "weakest" main vocal but she's still plenty skilled and Aespa wins in my book because they're a rare group without a jarring subvocal

I mean, yeah, Luna is great too, but I think Wendy is more skilled and versatile. To be fair, Luna didn't really get a chance. Is she even active as a singer? I don't really follow her anymore.

In Aespa I think Winter is the best vocalist. I never understood why Ning is the main. I mean, she's not bad, but as good as Winter. Seulgi would come in 3rd after Wendy and Luna.

I’m glad taste prevailed.

Red Velvet 💖

RV and Aespa for me

Quote from YamaChwan

I have been a kpop stan long enough to see f(x)'s discography become underrated

were you there when this dropped?