JYP really seems to shove Nmixx vocals down everyone's throats instead of giving them good songs

Quote from Aeicy

explain her :

lol very popular indeed, amongst the top echelons of Kpop.

In fact i was gonna list her as the only other obvious exception to the "Main Vocal not being the most popular member" argument. But then of course, i remembered a name that i literally wrote in my rant.

snsd-angai313.gif

Believe me, i too have no clue why Yoona is so popular. Her looks are completely average to me, i see 10 women like her every time i go to the mall tbh. And no one says anything about her vocals or dance abilities. But somehow, she captured the hearts of the entire nation and became one of the top It Girls of 2nd gen.

If it was up to me, Tae would easily be the most popular member of SNSD. She has some solid solo songs, including Weekend which is criminally underrated and one of the best retro songs ever in Kpop.

Quote from BlackpinkHouse

lol very popular indeed, amongst the top echelons of Kpop.

In fact i was gonna list her as the only other obvious exception to the "Main Vocal not being the most popular member" argument. But then of course, i remembered a name that i literally wrote in my rant.

snsd-angai313.gif

Believe me, i too have no clue why Yoona is so popular. Her looks are completely average to me, i see 10 women like her every time i go to the mall tbh. And no one says anything about her vocals or dance abilities. But somehow, she captured the hearts of the entire nation and became one of the top It Girls of 2nd gen.

If it was up to me, Tae would easily be the most popular member of SNSD. She has some solid solo songs, including Weekend which is criminally underrated and one of the best retro songs ever in Kpop.

Display More

so just because someone is not the most popular person in their group they can't be considered an it girl???

JYPE media play

literally and figuratively

Quote from randkpopstan

Was than proved already or you are just being a conspiracy theorists here?

Quote from Dreamer95

There is an article on pan.n

Can we get a link to the P‍ann article?

Quote from wsoet

Can we get a link to the P‍ann article?

pan.nchoa is censored in this forum for some reason, sadly can't paste it

If someone thinks: "It girls/Hot girls careers are over once they turn 25. Vocalists will win in the end"

Just look and Lovelyz Babysoul (main vocal) and Mijoo (it girl) careers after lovelyz disband

Quote from wsoet

Can we get a link to the P‍ann article?

Don't need a Knetz article anymore, JYP literally admitted that it was planned about 5-6 hours ago.

Quote from BlackpinkHouse

Emphasizing vocal "talent" means you've already lost tbh. The GP dont care about "vocals" in Kpop music.

I mean the list of flop main vocals is a MILE LONG. What It Girl has ever become an It Girl for channeling her inner Whitney or Mariah?

Jennie, Suzy, Irene, Yoona, Hwasa, Hani, Seolhyun, Wonyoung, Karina. Exactly zero became famous for their vocal prowess.

Hell, we can even lower the bar from It Girl to just being the most popular in your own group. I cant think of a single group where the main vocal is clearly the most popular member except for Baemon with Ahyeon. There are some names below where the main vocalist can be argued to be the most popular depending on whether you're talking about fanbase vs GP, domestic vs international, blah blah blah.

But overall, this list shows you exactly what being the "best singer" gets you in Kpop...

Bubkis.

Jihyo

Rose

Wendy

Seunghee/Hyojung

Yuri

Ningning/Winter

Dany/Hanni

Chaewon/Yunjin

Mia

Solar/Wheein

Lia

Lilly/Haewon

Belle

Liz

Haseul/Cherry

Miyeon/Minnie

Sieun

Fake Minju

Ahyeon

Display More

I just question what Kpop fans think is successful these days as half the people on that list are pretty famous Kpop idols

Am I the only one that kinda likes NMixx's songs?

Most are bops, if not chart toppers. Love me like this, Dash, Party O'Clock etc

Only O.O was mid, and that grew on me a bit.

Honestly, all JYP needs to do is give them music like recent Twice.

Quote from SooYoung

Actually that's the contrary for me i was obess with O.O and Dice

I was going to stan then they went a complete different road with generic and flop songs

Then came back with Love me like this, i was obsess ready to jump on the nmixx train again

But dash didn't do it for me, it lacked of the energy of their songs like O.O and dice

Haha, Dash is fun tho