BLACKPINK vs GIDLE - How would you rank them in terms of skill & preference
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Correct answer?
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
(G)-Idle
Skill: 8/10
Performance: 9/10
Personality 9/10
Skill: 8/10
Performance: 6.5/10
Personality 9/10
I'd score Lisa way higher for performance, but I do think this is BP's weak point as a group .
One thing both groups do really well is that they exude personality. All the members are very easily recognizable. They're not just a bunch of pretty girls that you can barely keep apart.
-
External Content twitter.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
original article: https://t.co/yz3hE8j6qv
-
G-idle - all of the girls have show cased various talents and they are not afraid to show it. They also have Soyeon so what else can we say?
Blackpink I feel like the girls might have some talents but afraid to show them or not able to fight their label for more artistic freedom.
So one group embodies girl power and the other one just act. That’s why G-idle is my preference.
-
Okay, I'll take the bait , but don't forget Blinks, I didn't ask this question.🤣 So...
Talent: G-Idle, of course, only blind and deaf people think otherwise.
My G-Idle ranking:
1. Soyoen - Without her, there's G-Idle - as a singer, she's average, as a REAL rapper, she's one of the best in the industry, and no, not because she's fast! That's like the last thing you should care about. The order: writing, flow, versatility, and style. Also, she's a good dancer too.
2. Miyeon - She's a main vocalist for a reason, she's not The Best vocalist in Korea, but she's the best in G-Idle and compared to the members of BP, she's like Celine Dion compared to a rookie singer.
3. Minnie - She's the other main vocalist, but she's not better than Miyeon, not miles away, but her resonance isn't as good.
4. Yuqi - Pretty much average in everything, she's like Jennie, but with better stamina.
5. Shuhua - She's average too,
In terms of VOCALS only, my raking would look like this: Miyeon, Minnie, Yuqi, Soyeon and Shuhua.
Talent - I don't even want to go there.😅
So, my ranking:
1. Rose - Average vocalist with the most potential
2. Jennie - Decent "fake" rapper, below-average singer and average dancer. With years of training, she could be much better. FAKE RAPPER: means, if you don't write your own rap verses, you're not a REAL rapper!
3. Jisoo - I will surprise everyone, I think, Jisoo could be just as good VOCALIST as Miyeon, and better than Rose with YEARS of training, they literally like VOCAL TONE TWINS! As for dance and "rapping". Just forget it. It's not her style, at all, and that's why she's not my first. She would be, if she's at least a below-average "rapper" and dancer.
4. Lisa - One of the best dancer in Kpop, but that's all she can do. Average "fake" rapper, and one of the worst vocalist in Kpop. I don't think she could be better than average, even with years of practice.
As you can see, my list isn't based on whom I like more, it's purely about TALENT. It's based on my musical background.
It's not an opinion, it's a fact, and you don't need to agree with me, so don't even try to attack me if you see your fave lower than you want to see.
Lastly: VISUALS! Just forget it! It's not important. It's time to move on from that middle-age thinking!
-
Just talent in general? Hmm, ok. Lemme try not to be biased here
i’m a blink so ya1. Soyeon - I mean, obviously. She’s an amazing songwriter and one of the best female rappers in kpop of any generation. She is right up there. Dancing is great, stage presence is great. She isn’t a singer but I do actually like her singing voice too.
2. Rosé - Imo she’s the most talented member of Blackpink. Her voice is really pretty and unique, her dancing is amazing and she has really really great stage presence. She’s the second best dancer/stage presence in Blackpink, which is saying a lot bc I think stage presence is where Blackpink really shines.
3. Jennie - An all rounder. She isn’t as good as a rapper as Soyeon, bu she’s still really great. Great rapping, great singing and great dancing. Her stage presence can be inconsistent but in general she really shines on stage. There’s a reason locals gave her the title “eminem’s daughter” after Coachella.
even tho soyeon deserves that title4. Yuqi - she has a dancing position, a vocal position AND a rap position so ofc she’s gonna be high. I put Jennie before her because I feel like Jennie is a much stronger rapper and I prefer her voice. Yuqi’s voice is very unique though, doesn’t sound at all like I expected.
5. Lisa - One of the best dancers of the third gen and has AMAZING stage presence. Her rapping is sometimes cringy but I really like it and she has the “swag” to pull it off. Not a singer, but I don’t think she really needs to be.
6. Minnie - Very unique and cool voice. I actually didn’t know she was considered the main vocalist? I thought that was just Miyeon. She has really great stage presence too.
7. Miyeon - I do think she’s slightly weak compared to other main vocalists, but I like her voice. Very pretty too.
8. Jisoo - A lot of people say she’s not talented but she is, it’s just that amongst all these idols I can’t justify putting her at the top. Her dancing/performance is awkward sometimes but she has a very nice voice and I loved her solo.
9. Shuhua - I don’t dislike any of these idols but someone has to be last. I do think she’s shown improvement over the years, especially after Soojin left her dancing and stage presence got better but it’s still weaker than the other ones here. Her lack of lines kinda makes it hard for me to judge her voice.
-
Participate now!
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!
