A Visual Comparison of Third Generation Girl Group Touring Attendance (or: Twice and Blackpink Still Dominating)

  • --==Please see here for the latest end of 2024 update==--


    It's often been said by members of the AKP forum that touring is the best indicator of success, as well as the most profitable activity that an artist can partake in. Thus, I wanted to examine concert attendance figures for major girl groups of the Third Generation.


    To do this, I first compiled published attendance numbers f‍rom Touring Data (on Twitter and Wordpress), Wikipedia, Fandom.com, and Namuwiki. However, the problem is that many concerts d‍on't actually have attendance figures listed, so in these cases, I had to estimate based on venue capacity. For smaller venues such as theatres and auditoriums, I used an estimate of 90% of capacity. For larger venues such as arenas and stadiums, I used 80% of capacity, since these larger venues typically d‍on't have existing stages, and thus construction of o‍ne necessarily reduces the number of people the venue can hold.


    My results are shown in the chart below. Sub-unit and solo concert attendance is not included. Each circular marker represents a concert, and they sum up cumulatively over time. Off‍icial co‍lours were used when possible, and the data are current to the end of 2022:


    3G_GG_Concert_Attendance.png


    As we can clearly see, Bl‍ackpink and Twice are the only groups with significant touring power. What I found interesting is that their attendance figures have largely mirrored each other over the years. Twice has historically maintained an edge for the most part, but Bl‍ackpink recently took a decisive lead, which isn't too surprising given that they've been touring extensively as of late.


    This then begs the question: what will 2023 bring for the t‍wo rivals? I'm expecting that the remaining 23 shows of the Born Pink tour will add on around 500K+ to Bl‍ackpink's total. But Twice likely isn't going to stand still, and I've heard people on this forum claim that they're planning on touring in 2023 as well. Will they expand their tour to finally include stops in South America and Europe? That seems like a logical mo‍ve to me, as does playing more shows in Southeast Asia. Twice will have to make up a deficit of about 560K to take the lead again by the close of 2023. This is certainly within the realm of possibility, but might require that JYPE takes some bigger risks, which the company may the loath to do.


    The next three groups with the highest attendance figures are Re‍d Velvet, Mam‍amoo, and Drea‍mcatcher. I think it's safe to say that none of them will be challenging Twice or Bl‍ackpink at the to‍p, but I also think that their positions probably won't be threatened by any of their other peers. I was pleasantly surprised by Drea‍mcatcher in particular, since they've actually toured in more countries than Bl‍ackpink and Twice, combined. In fact, I wouldn't be shocked if they eventually surpass Ma‍mamoo.


    Are there any other interesting observations to make? And are there any other groups that should be included in this analysis?


    Further Reading on This Topic:

    The Chart Above, Updated with 2018 Girl Group Debuts

    Table of Attendance Totals, Number of Shows, and Number of Countries

    The End of 2024 Update

    Edited 6 times, last by wsoet ().

  • GG touring really isnt a thing, is it? :eyes:


    I wonder what would happen if you included 4th gen in this. Izone barely toured and more than half of their lifespan was spent on hiatus cause of rigging scandal and COVID. But what about Loona, Itzy, and Idle? I dont think Stayc, Aespa, or any of the 4.5 generation groups have toured yet.

    that's because people don't want to include certain groups as 3rd gen despite being around about the same time

    Loona could be included in this list they are 3.5 gen

  • edit: can you include Loona? they technically have been around since 2016 maybe include other groups that debuted in 2018 since they could be considered 3.5 gen

    Please see the updated chart below. In addition to Loona (89,929 attendance), I also added (G)I-dle (58,055) and Iz*One (86,790). I believe those are the only three 2018 groups worth mentioning when it comes to concert attendance.


    Loona has essentially the same attendance as Dreamcatcher, though they were able to achieve that feat with about half the shows.


    3G+2018_GG_Concert_Attendance.png

  • Please see the updated chart below. In addition to Loona (89,929 attendance), I also added (G)I-dle (58,055) and Iz*One (86,790). I believe those are the only three 2018 groups worth mentioning when it comes to concert attendance.


    Loona has essentially the same attendance as Dreamcatcher, though they were able to achieve that feat with about half the shows.


    3G+2018_GG_Concert_Attendance.png

    thank you

  • Would be interesting see the number of dates and a count for the number of different countries alongside this.

    That's easy enough to generate--please see the table below:


    3G+2018_GG_Concert_Attendance_Summary.png


    It's still a bit shocking to me that Dreamcatcher has performed in more countries than every other group in this analysis, combined.


    Dreamcatcher: Argentina, Australia, Brazil, Chile, Colombia, Finland, France, Germany, Indonesia, Italy, Japan, Malaysia, Mexico, Netherlands, Panama, Peru, Philippines, Poland, Portugal, Singapore, Spain, South Korea, Taiwan, United Kingdom, United States


    Every Other Group, Combined: Australia, Brazil, Canada, Chile, Denmark, France, Germany, Hong Kong, Indonesia, Japan, Macau, Malaysia, Mexico, Netherlands, Philippines, Poland, Singapore, South Korea, Spain, Taiwan, Thailand, United Kingdom ,United States

  • Dreamcatcher are probably the least successful group on that list domestically in South Korea, so they were always forced to look outwards with their concept. I'm also going to guess here and say they have a pretty low standard deviation? So when it come to picking countries the opportunity cost of performing in one place over another is probably not as large as say Twice.


    JYPE notoriously plays it safe with them - they'll send all their boy groups to Europe after a year or so but always refused to send Twice as they'd rather keep them in Japan where they are guaranteed to sell out large arenas and Domes. I think one of the main reasons Twice renewed is because they want to do one big and genuine world tour before completely slowing down so will be shocked if places like Europe, Australia and South America aren't included in their next tour.

  • Wait but how did u calculate the 26 shows bp already performed on born pink tour. There is only 2 shows reported

    So for their European concerts, I used the 160K attendance stated here and distributed that figure in pro rata fashion among their 10 shows, based on venue capacity.


    For the rest, I essentially estimated based on venue capacity, and do plan on updating my numbers once official Billboard results are released.

  • I wonder what would happen if you included 4th gen in this. Izone barely toured and more than half of their lifespan was spent on hiatus cause of rigging scandal and COVID. But what about Loona, Itzy, and Idle? I dont think Stayc, Aespa, or any of the 4.5 generation groups have toured yet.

    Please take a look at this post for the addition of Iz*One/Loona/(G)I-dle, whom some regard as 3.5th Generation.


    Itzy just started touring, and probably has around 50K attendance so far, though their Checkmate tour is continuing into 2023 with eight more shows. StayC hasn't done any concerts as far as I know, but Aespa did have a few "Synk" showcases.

  • Please take a look at this post for the addition of Iz*One/Loona/(G)I-dle, whom some regard as 3.5th Generation.


    Itzy just started touring, and probably has around 50K attendance so far, though their Checkmate tour is continuing into 2023 with eight more shows. StayC hasn't done any concerts as far as I know, but Aespa did have a few "Synk" showcases.

    Aespa will probably have a higher attendance than most of the groups on this through fanmeets/showcases alone I'd imagine

  • WJSN has tours?


    I just know of a few concerts in Japan (and Korea).

  • This is interesting. I feel like Twice’s Japan dates really gives them big jumps in the graph

    For sure; each of those dome shows essentially adds on around 40K-50K of attendance. Now that I think about it, Twice could probably catch up playing nothing but domes in Japan. I recall people on this forum stating that they had something like a million ticket requests for one of their Japanese concert tours.

  • I suppose this doesn't include the virtual concerts numbers or does it?

    It does not, as I don't think online concerts are quite equivalent to the real thing. In addition, there's no way to really estimate online concert attendance, since you don't have the constraints of venue capacity to work with.

  • Dreamcatcher are probably the least successful group on that list domestically in South Korea, so they were always forced to look outwards with their concept. I'm also going to guess here and say they have a pretty low standard deviation? So when it come to picking countries the opportunity cost of performing in one place over another is probably not as large as say Twice.

    I'm glad you brought that up. As shown in the table below, I've calculated both the standard deviation and relative standard deviation (= σ ÷ μ, which I generally prefer using) for all the groups. Dreamcatcher's RSD is middle of the pack, and isn't as low as one would expect, likely because they played some extremely small shows (a couple hundred people) early in their career. On the other hand, Twice's RSD is easily the highest among everyone here, as you correctly intuited.


    3G+2018_GG_Concert_Attendance_Summary_SD.png

    JYPE notoriously plays it safe with them - they'll send all their boy groups to Europe after a year or so but always refused to send Twice as they'd rather keep them in Japan where they are guaranteed to sell out large arenas and Domes. I think one of the main reasons Twice renewed is because they want to do one big and genuine world tour before completely slowing down so will be shocked if places like Europe, Australia and South America aren't included in their next tour.

    Yes, I've often seen people on this forum complain about JYPE playing it safe with Twice, but hopefully that'll change given their recent contract renewal. I just ran the numbers, and according to my estimates, a whopping 659,948 of their 971,638 total comes from Japan--that's 68%!

    Aespa will probably have a higher attendance than most of the groups on this through fanmeets/showcases alone I'd imagine

    I'm not including fanmeets currently, though I am taking into account showcases if they're "concert-esque", i.e. not like a press showcase that groups often put on at the start of a comeback period.

  • WJSN has tours?


    I just know of a few concerts in Japan (and Korea).

    I'm including standalone concerts for the purposes of this analysis. For WJSN, I'm showing:


    WJSN 1st Concert "Would You Like – Happy Moment"

    2017-05-19 | South Korea | Seoul | Blue Square Samsung Card Hall

    2017-05-20 | South Korea | Seoul | Blue Square Samsung Card Hall


    WJSN Concert "Would You Stay – Secret Box"

    2019-03-02 | South Korea | Seoul | Blue Square iMarket Hall

    2019-03-03 | South Korea | Seoul | Blue Square iMarket Hall


    WJSN 1st Mini Live "Would You Like?" 2019 Zepp Tour in Japan

    2019-08-17 | Japan | Tokyo | Zepp DiverCity

    2019-08-24 | Japan | Osaka | Zepp Osaka Bayside

    2019-08-25 | Japan | Nagoya | Zepp Nagoya


    2022 WJSN Concert "Wonderland"

    2022-06-11 | South Korea | Seoul | Olympic Hall

    2022-06-12 | South Korea | Seoul | Olympic Hall

  • JYP announced 100k While touring data on Twitter the source is reported by Billboard the total numbers were 80k

    Can you provide links to the sources for these numbers? I'd like to update my spreadsheet accordingly, and I'm also wondering how my estimates could have been off by so much.

  • Can you provide links to the sources for these numbers? I'd like to update my spreadsheet accordingly, and I'm also wondering how my estimates could have been off by so much.

    Bad Bunny Has the No. 1 Tour of February With Nearly $40 Million in Ticket Sales
    The Puerto Rican star saw an average of $3.3 million and 15,240 tickets per show.
    www.billboard.com


    It’s only based on 6 dates though I don’t think BB reported these 2 California dates I guess they may have passed the +100k marks

  • It’s only based on 6 dates though I don’t think BB reported these 2 California dates I guess they may have passed the +100k marks

    Ah thanks. If I look at only the first six US concerts of the III tour, my numbers line up much closer. The 140K figure I mentioned earlier was for all nine shows.


    On a related note, have you seen any numbers for Itzy's recent US shows yet?

  • Please take a look at this post for the addition of Iz*One/Loona/(G)I-dle, whom some regard as 3.5th Generation.


    Itzy just started touring, and probably has around 50K attendance so far, though their Checkmate tour is continuing into 2023 with eight more shows. StayC hasn't done any concerts as far as I know, but Aespa did have a few "Synk" showcases.

    If you want to throw in JYPE's Japanese sister group that just started touring. Their number is around 380,000. Since they are supposedly doing a Korean release Early/Mid next year people might want to cross consider them a JPOP/KPOP 4th Gen group.

  • If you want to throw in JYPE's Japanese sister group that just started touring. Their number is around 380,000. Since they are supposedly doing a Korean release Early/Mid next year people might want to cross consider them a JPOP/KPOP 4th Gen group.

    Yep that 380K figure is around what I was estimating as well: (16 × 11K) for their first leg + (4 × 50K) for their second leg = 376K.


    It just goes to show that it can be quite lucrative to tour just solely in Japan.

  • Moderator

    Moved the thread from forum KPOP to forum KPOP.
  • 2023 so far.


    1. @BLACKPINK (2023) - 1.1M [31/38 shows so far]
    2. TWICE (2023) - 530K [23/38 shows so far]



    External Content twitter.com
    Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.
    Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

  • This thread contains 23 more posts that have been hidden for guests, please register yourself or login to continue reading.

Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!