My versions of aespa, IVE, LSFM & NewJeans

Hi so I wanna share my fictional versions of the main 4th gen ggs. Tell me what you think and then which members would you add or remove? (all fictional, just fo the game)

So I'm gonna start in order of debut.

aespa

Visual & magnae: Sullyoon

Main vocal: Ning Ning

Main dancer: Helen (sm trainee)

Lead vocal: Winter

Lead dancer & 2nd visual: Karina

Rapper: Giselle

Aeri Helen Sully Kari Winter Ning

I think Sullyoon totally fits the ae concept, she is a walking doll herself and i think the top 4th gg visul. She would have been a perfect continuation of SM visual dominance following the line of Yoona, Sulli and Irene.

I personally think karina would have still remained the face of the group and also be a 2nd visual like Yujin in Ive but Sullyoon would have been the center and lead visual.

Sullyoon

forum.allkpop.com/suite/attachment/252403/

Karina is beautiful and talended but I really think aespa is lacking a promer SM visual and a proper main dancer. As such Sullyoon and Helen would have been a perfect addiction. Helen would have also bought more charisma and swag to the group, the hip hop vide they kinda lack.

here's a short video of Helen her dancing (could improve but she got the vibes)

Then Ive.

Yuri Lesoo Won Yujin Liz Rei

Ive biggest weekness is their vocals. No offense but i don’t understand Gaeuls position in the group, what is it she brings to the group on a professional level? (not human obviously).

So the member who i think would have made this group good or even fine is Jo Yuri (Izone). Her vocals with Liz and Rei would have been very needed addition. Sh would have pull of the group and take it somewhere vocally. Right now they are embarassing to listen to in their encore. They are even worse than Twice, at last twice has Jihyo.

Ps: and Yuri is so freaking cute to, i think she would have been a perfect addition to Ive ad make it a somewhat coherent unit

She has such a nice voice 👌

Then LSFM

The only member i would have add again would be Kim Minju (Izone). I think they need a proper main visual like Minju. Zuha is really good, she is popular among koreans but she isnt Korean and again she is a perfect lead visual but i think the group would be more powerful and more complete with a visual like Minju. Visually, the Garam loss i think had an effect on the groups visual power/impact. Now all the girls are gorgeous (secialy kura my favorite) like in aespa but still. They need a more classical powerful main visual.

forum.allkpop.com/suite/attachment/252402/

And lastly New Jeans.

New Jeans is fine as they are. With or without addition they are already pretty exeptional in term of beauty and talent yet if i had to imrpove the group, i would want to add another consistant vocal on the level of lets say Winter or Jo Yuri or Chaewon.

I personally thought of Loona Heejin. I like her voice and i think she is really talented and charismatic. She can be both cute and sexy and fierce. She has various charmd as a perfomer. She is cute but i think she also has disposition for hip hop, a sort of swag or toughness to her. I found her crazy good in her cover of Greedy, Full moon and Cherry bomb. She is very versatile and honestly, i think she is wasted in Loona. New jeans would have given her more light to shine.

Moreover she even looks like a rabbit and even thought she is a bit older, she looks young and cute and would have add a bit more diversity in their visuals. I think she could have been a nice addition

Here is her cover of Greedy

So if you bothered to read my thread, what do you think? What would you change? (as a game)

Quote from Rainbowlicious

I was happy until I saw this IVE/Twice slander

Sorry was not trying to be hurtful 🥲, they are nice groups but i just think they are lacking vocally but hey i complimented Jihyo

Quote from Rainbowlicious

Ooh, please share! I haven't heard of this trainee!

Well Helen is not that new, she is known since 2020 i think.

Here is a video of her:

And that, i think she has a cool and nice personality too

Quote from doesitneedsaying

op gets you

i know nothing about yuri but visually wise minju fit so well le sserafim. there was a chance of this scenario happening but sadly, she turned down the offer

And with Minju all this Garam bullshxt would have never happened too 🥲

Quote from BlackpinkHouse

I love your additions except for Sullyoong/Aespa. Karina is one of the top visuals in all of Kpop they dont need another visual. They could use a top notch dancer/performer.

Ive with Yuri would be literal FIRE. Ive doesnt have much vocally (i think Liz is way overrated, Rei actually has a better tone and Leeseo surprised me with Afterlike, she might have the best tone in the group).

I dont much care for or follow Newbeans but Heejin is an all around ace. She would make any group better.

LSRFM and Yujin would also be literal FIRE. If Minju had the same passion for dance as Chaewon and joined LSRFM, i think they would be challenging Ive and Idle right now for supremacy. Imagine them adding both Minju and Yuri too, it wouldnt be fair to everyone else.

FfW9muPaAAAifat.png

FS1pyFcaAAA-fet.jpg

Display More

mmm i disagree personally, as someone who liked sm ggs since SNSD, Karina's visual in my opinion is not up there for me sorry. She is in Seulgi's league for example (which is gorgeous and exeptional), but not Irene or Yoonas league.

I know right! With Yuri Ive would be taken to another level and so would LSFM with Minju. I don’t think Yuri is needed tho, with Chaewon and Yunjin they're more than enough. (they are pretty consistant vocalists by 4th gen standarts).

Yup, kinda underweming how Minju has no passion for dancind and singing 🥲.

Quote from doesitneedsaying

iirc garam wasn't the last one added to the group? don't ask me who it was, i forgot maybe eunchae?

I dont know either