If Blackpink & Aespa in one group
-
-
-
This is my opinion though. Rose has more versatile voice & high notes are pleasant to listen to and her lower register are good. Winter has restraining and screaming high notes but good lower register. I can’t put Giselle and Lisa both in lead because there’s a big gap in both their rapping.
What position would you give all of them if could?
-
-
Winter main vocal #2 it's not even debatable
And center i would give it to karina
Only because i think that usually center are visual because the public is directly attracted by the visual member so put them in center is often the best
And between jisoo, karina and winter who are the visual who get a lot of attention from the public
-
-
Display More
Winter main vocal #2 it's not even debatable
And center i would give it to karina
Only because i think that usually center are visual because the public is directly attracted by the visual member so put them in center is often the best
And between jisoo, karina and winter who are the visual who get a lot of attention from the public
Winter is good but i feel like her high notes are screaming and Rose has more musicality based in their adlibs and long notes. Yup visual in the center is common too. But i feel like Rose and Lisa who specialise in both(Vocal/Dance) & (Dance/Rap) always give the best and good stage presence compared to Karina
-
Display More
Jisoo : Sub vocal, visual?
Jennie : Main rapper, center?
Rose : Lead vocalist, lead dancer
Lisa : Main dancer, lead/main rapper
Karina : Lead/sub vocalist, lead dancer, visual?, center?
Giselle : Lead rapper
Winter : Lead vocalist, visual?
Ningning : Main vocalist
Could be too. But i wont put Lisa as main rapper because would be much to have 2 main rappers. Hence i put Giselle as sub rapper and the big gap between her and Lisa
-
-
-
-
Their music, faces and their vibe so different, wouldn't look harmonious in the one group. Here's my idea: 4th generation groups give a more harmonious atmosphere with 4th generation groups. So if you mix Blackpink, Red Velvet or Twice it will look more harmonious. If you mix Aespa with ITZY or IVE, they fit together better. 4th generation groups have give same vibe. The 4th generation gives me a unique, bold, cool and fancy vibe. Although Blacpink carries luxury brands, the members are not that fancy, they just give off an air of elegance chic outside of award ceremonies. The 4th generation is Tiktok generation, they are overly communicative and assertive and overconfident what they do.
-
Ningning main vocal
Rosé lead
Winter lead but more like in nayeon
Lisa main dancer
Rosé : lead dancer
Jennie main rapper
Lisa lead rapper
Karina and Giselle are okay rapper guy wouldn’t add anything
Jisoo visual, sub-vocal
Karina sub-vocal
Giselle???
But this lineup is messy. To much gap in talent sometimes and charisma/stage presence.
-
The OP doesn't seem to like Aespa
And a group is not a question of position, there is also the concept, the cohesion between members, etc...
Not a fan of these kind of topic (except on BG)
Lol i’m not a fan of both groups. But i listen to them when there are new songs. Yeap sorry i forgot to put ‘the positions imo if bp and aespa are in one group’ lol
-
Looks like a boring Quora thread
-
Their music, faces and their vibe so different, wouldn't look harmonious in the one group. Here's my idea: 4th generation groups give a more harmonious atmosphere with 4th generation groups. So if you mix Blackpink, Red Velvet or Twice it will look more harmonious. If you mix Aespa with ITZY or IVE, they fit together better. 4th generation groups have give same vibe. The 4th generation gives me a unique, bold, cool and fancy vibe. Although Blacpink carries luxury brands, the members are not that fancy, they just give off an air of elegance chic outside of award ceremonies. The 4th generation is Tiktok generation, they are overly communicative and assertive and overconfident what they do.
Haha yes relatable. Indeed tiktok generation. I just wonder what would i put if they are in one group because they have some of the least members among all kpop groups so i dont have to list more than 8 names
-
Become the group with the most akgae / solo stans
As if both groups arent already having the worst akgae problems / most solo stans
-
-
-
This is my opinion though. Rose has more versatile voice & high notes are pleasant to listen to and her lower register are good. Winter has restraining and screaming high notes but good lower register. I can’t put Giselle and Lisa both in lead because there’s a big gap in both their rapping.
What position would you give all of them if could?
no, im questioning why giselle is a subvocal if shes better than Rosé. and lisa aint even too good of a rapper so them both being lead isn't really too crazy.
Winter is actually main vocal material and way closer to Ning² in vocals compared to Rosé. Everyone is aespa is better than Rosé. Not that Rosé is that bad it's just that aespa is too good vocally.
-
-
-
-
Looks like a boring Quora thread
Roses, be nice. Please?
-
Roses, be nice. Please?
Naur
-
momo, winter and yeris a subrapper in their respective groups for example
Winter is not sub rapper
-
I would stan both extra hard 🥺
-
-
I would stan both extra hard 🥺
My wife
-
My wife
She's so pretty
-
She's so pretty
Sure she is. Whenever she performs, my heart falls apart
-
-
u can keep it
-
-
Same.
-
-
-
-
-
I'm not mean to you auntie Youchan. Just to the troll op
-
-
I know, I just hate seeing people unhappy or fighting with each other. Why can’t it be sunshine and rainbows all of the time? Anyway, focus on the positives, YouChan pink era is coming.
The op wants a fight so I'm bringing the fight against him
I'm just granting their wish.
And when the YouChan black era?
-
Participate now!
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!
