like man the competition for female rookie award is just on another level, its hella competitive, ofcourse we have 2 top group IVE and NewJeans but Le Sserafim also doing really well while both nmixx and kep1er also sold lot of album. meanwhile for boygroup i literally know 0 rookie this year like theres no any rookie boygroup this year that make any noise
can we remove rookie award for boy group and give it to 2 or 3 girl group instead
-
-
No
-
God I hope so
-
so participation trophies?
-
no
It will dilute the impact
-
girl groups be like
-
so participation trophies?
But is it really a participation trophy if the girls deserve it for doing way better than the boys
Anyway, if they do give it to a male rookie I hope it goes to xdinary heroes. I hope the jyp privilege finally works on them, jyp should use his big4 money to buy their award
-
I don't want to competing this but, is there any bg rookie that having a good impact like the gg rookies this year?
-
I don't want to competing this but, is there any bg rookie that having a good impact like the gg rookies this year?
Nowhere near the gg rookies' impact but bg rookies that made a little bit of noise I guess are xdinary heroes, tempest, tnx and atbo. Doubt atbo will get it since they're are very new and I know absolutely nothing about tnx other than they were formed through the survival show with psy and jyp. Tempest have hanbin fans backing them and could get a few votes from people who watched i-land, such as engenes. So they could win in voting heavy awards. But xdinary heroes could get a few votes from jyp stans and I think they have more recognition amongst kpop stans than the others. So yeah it will probably be between xdinary heroes and tempest.
-
-
-
-
Nowhere near the gg rookies' impact but bg rookies that made a little bit of noise I guess are xdinary heroes, tempest, tnx and atbo. Doubt atbo will get it since they're are very new and I know absolutely nothing about tnx other than they were formed through the survival show with psy and jyp. Tempest have hanbin fans backing them and could get a few votes from people who watched i-land, such as engenes. So they could win in voting heavy awards. But xdinary heroes could get a few votes from jyp stans and I think they have more recognition amongst kpop stans than the others. So yeah it will probably be between xdinary heroes and tempest.
Ah I see.
Then, I hope we would get a great rookie bg this september or next year.
-
-
But yeah, I wonder, by removing it for the bg and giving it all to the ggs this year, could that motivate companies to improve so their bgs would having a good impact in both gp and fandom?
-
I don't want to competing this but, is there any bg rookie that having a good impact like the gg rookies this year?
Xdinary Heroes and TAN are come in mind
-
The problem for bgs is no big company debut. Look at which ggs are competing this year mostly all big company ones
-
Xdinary Heroes and TAN are come in mind
-
NO. Participation trophies as one other user said, and another is making those bgs feel as if their contributions aren't being appreciated. It's good that we are finally giving women the recognition we deserve but not at the expense of the opposite gender.
-
The problem for bgs is no big company debut. Look at which ggs are competing this year mostly all big company ones
But, should that even be a greater opportunity? Like, since there are no big company debuting bgs, that means a new bg that are coming from mid/small company could get more spotlight?
Shouldn't they just goes all in debuting their bg because there are no competition from the big ones?
-
But, should that even be a greater opportunity? Like, since there are no big company debuting bgs, that means a new bg that are coming from mid/small company could get more spotlight?
Shouldn't they just goes all in debuting their bg because there are no competition from the big ones?
That's not how it goes tho. Small companies in general don't get attention so unless they go viral or something it's impossible to gain more attention. Like for me i can't even name one bg who debuted recently except tempest and tan. Why big3/hybe get attention because they have a big company name attached to them most of the time.
-
Participate now!
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!